LIVE GAME Round 26 v Cowboys

Live Game Discussion
tigerballs said:
Mak can tackle, he just makes poor decisions. A lot of poor decisions. And he's only 18.
Sak can't tackle at all and makes poor decisions. I think he might be a chicken.

I think Mak can be fixed. Sak, I doubt it.
Click to expand...
Mak. is 19 now.
And if you think you can teach Mak; there's a chance Sak may learn as well. But a mystery how he got to this level with no feel for what's needed in defence.
Mak 'n Sak seem to have had the same defensive issues?
Not sure you can teach them speed though.
Wasn't Tupou a centre at some stage here at WT? Just a thought.
 
Yossarian said:
It’s terrible and not what the rule was intended to address. They were trying to stop guys reaching around to disrupt dummy halves passing. Tom M has moved forward a few steps. Is the idea markers are not allowed to make a tackle on a dummy half?

The T May no try was an awful call. No way is Drinkwater stopping him or even getting across to him. Smart players will just step in front of lead runners, draw contact, get a penalty.
Click to expand...
I could cop the May no try if it was always ruled that way, which it is not. No way Drinkwater gets anywhere near May but you shouldn't be sending your prop down that channel.

The Api one was one of the worst calls I've seen in the NRL this year. Not only does Mikaele take off, API actually makes a tackling motion, he doesn't slap at the ball, he extends his arms then immediately wraps. He actually tackles Mikaele, the guy hits the ground. How can you be penalised for a slapping action when you bring the opponent down in the same motion?

Agree with Benji on the Skelton one. I can actually cop the Cowboys try where Madden gets barged, if they don't call the Skelton one a penalty. They are both the same category of potential infringement and have to be ruled the same.

I personally think the whole disruptor rule is bulldust, you should be able to ddo whatever you please if you get to the ball early enough and don't physically touch the opponent. Skelton's one he's there first and he doesn't even body-check the opponent, he just wins the ground position. Never takes his eyes off the ball and never looks at the opponent.
 
Not just the bad decisions, but the contempt from Atkins when Api questioned the decisions. Didn't even want to have a discussion. Does he treat every captain like that? Somehow I can't imagine him speaking to Isaah Yeo in that manner. Api doesn't appear to be behaving outrageously.

Atkins should be dropped after that debacle. How come it is fine for one team to do something then there is no consistency a few minutes later when a similar situation occurs.
 
Alex Seyfarth's #1 Fan said:
I thought people were just salty about referee Atkins. Feels like there were double standards on display tonight. The look on his face when Api is trying to talk to him looks like contempt. I don't want to see him referee our games again.
Click to expand...
Correct. Respect works both ways including for the captain of our team who approached him in a respectful manner.
 
Lestronge said:
This has been the most bullshit ref display in ages . So many dubious to wrong calls . Like how the hell can you say sexton takes our Drinkwater , then literally the next set 3 cowboys players take out madden and it’s a try .
Or what if pole gets the ball in that X play near the line . Can Drinkwater dig it then ? So May gets the ball and strolls over and it’s somehow a penalty . Never ending wtf decisions keeping the ball in our half rucking it out . Such bullshit …. I hate the nrl refs . Klein is clearly corrupt af and atkins has 1000 on every home team plus minus . I’m so angry about that game
Click to expand...
The NRL wants out of team towns in the finals, it means great audiences and $. It is entertainment and not a sport,
 
Fish88 said:
Bunty was on for about 15 minutes too long. Sukkar went off Hia amd we have a backrower on the bench but don’t use him.

Mason is horrible but if you’re going to select him, use him when he can actually try and do something.

ps a fly would knock Saukuru over in defence
Click to expand...
 
The officiating has been absolutely putrid vomit this year. It's across all most every game I've watched as well, not just Tigers.
Absolutely pathetic. I enjoy watching my son play u10s a lot more as the officiating is much better with a 14yr old referee and 2 x 40year old Dads running the sideline.
Bunker ruins the game with calls it shouldn't get wrong and not being able to celebrate a try untils 5 minutes later when it's finally confirmed.
Rant over 🤬
 
Alex Seyfarth's #1 Fan said:
Not just the bad decisions, but the contempt from Atkins when Api questioned the decisions. Didn't even want to have a discussion. Does he treat every captain like that? Somehow I can't imagine him speaking to Isaah Yeo in that manner. Api doesn't appear to be behaving outrageously.

Atkins should be dropped after that debacle. How come it is fine for one team to do something then there is no consistency a few minutes later when a similar situation occurs.
Click to expand...
Yeah he does actually. Always talks and acts like a pill to players in just about every game I’ve watched him referee. Arrogant prick.
 
Tiger Stripes said:
Mak. is 19 now.
And if you think you can teach Mak; there's a chance Sak may learn as well. But a mystery how he got to this level with no feel for what's needed in defence.
Mak 'n Sak seem to have had the same defensive issues?
Not sure you can teach them speed though.
Wasn't Tupou a centre at some stage here at WT? Just a thought.
Click to expand...
A lot of kids come through looking like stars because they physically may develop earlier or are just naturally stronger so can just run over players and dominate them in the lower grades. Its a curse cause it stops tgem from developing tge rest of their game, tgey rely on running over people. But once they make the step up, they cant just rely on the physicality anymore and thats when all the defficiencies in their game show.
 
liltiger said:
A lot of kids come through looking like stars because they physically may develop earlier or are just naturally stronger so can just run over players and dominate them in the lower grades. Its a curse cause it stops tgem from developing tge rest of their game, tgey rely on running over people. But once they make the step up, they cant just rely on the physicality anymore and thats when all the defficiencies in their game show.
Click to expand...
Makasini was in demand from a number of clubs for a reason. Yes he does have to work on his game but he is a recently turned 19 year old, I do believe he should be played in the centres so he can work on his defence
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 1,906 (members: 3, guests: 1,903)
Back
Top