The Cambo Curse

sorry I might have misread the question i thought it was what years did we play 3 games at CSS ?

No .. my interpretation of the guys statement was that the club had a period of time where they played those three weaker teams only at CSS and this led to the team having a high winning percentage of Campbelltown. ..

Didn’t make much sense to me
 
No .. my interpretation of the guys statement was that the club had a period of time where they played those three weaker teams only at CSS and this led to the team having a high winning percentage of Campbelltown. ..

Didn’t make much sense to me

ah ok mate totally misread it lol
geez agree it doesnt make much sense you can only.play who you are drawn to play at each ground. That poster was way off the mark
 
Said it before and I'll say it again, if we are good enough we will win anywhere.

Hopefully we are currently working on that.
 
Ai says the West's tigers have broken the cambo curse quite a few times and by some big margins, how you explain that?
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_2026-11-16-08-54-43-67_40deb401b9ffe8e1df2f1cc5ba480b12.jpg
    Screenshot_2026-11-16-08-54-43-67_40deb401b9ffe8e1df2f1cc5ba480b12.jpg
    152.6 KB · Views: 12
Ai says the West's tigers have broken the cambo curse quite a few times and by some big margins, how you explain that?
WESTS TIGERS – LAST 30 NRL GAMES AT CAMPBELLTOWN STADIUM
(Tigers score first, most recent first)

10/07/2026 – LOST v Warriors 6-32 – Crowd: 10,445
20/06/2026 – LOST v Dolphins 22-36 – Crowd: 12,281
18/04/2026 – LOST v Broncos 20-21 – Crowd: 17,316
12/04/2026 – WON v Knights 42-22 – Crowd: 15,221
20/06/2025 – LOST v Raiders 12-16 – Crowd: 9,328
18/05/2025 – LOST v Rabbitohs 12-22 – Crowd: 11,102
30/03/2025 – LOST v Warriors 24-26 – Crowd: 12,020
07/03/2025 – LOST v Knights 8-10 – Crowd: 13,160
06/09/2024 – LOST v Eels 26-60 – Crowd: 17,311
17/08/2024 – WON v Rabbitohs 18-16 – Crowd: 11,420
23/06/2024 – WON v Raiders 48-24 – Crowd: 10,106
27/04/2024 – LOST v Broncos 10-34 – Crowd: 17,351
14/04/2024 – LOST v Dragons 12-24 – Crowd: 17,141
17/06/2023 – LOST v Storm 6-28 – Crowd: 8,517
02/06/2023 – LOST v Raiders 19-20 – Crowd: 11,201
23/04/2023 – LOST v Sea Eagles 16-22 – Crowd: 10,033
07/08/2022 – LOST v Knights 10-14 – Crowd: 9,621
12/06/2022 – LOST v Sea Eagles 4-30 – Crowd: 10,231
25/03/2022 – LOST v Warriors 12-16 – Crowd: 7,182
08/05/2021 – LOST v Titans 28-36 – Crowd: 8,411
21/03/2021 – LOST v Roosters 6-40 – Crowd: 6,107
20/06/2020 – WON v Cowboys 36-20 – Crowd: 104 (COVID)
13/06/2020 – LOST v Raiders 6-14 – Crowd: 109 (COVID)
24/08/2019 – WON v Knights 46-4 – Crowd: 11,107
31/03/2019 – LOST v Bulldogs 8-22 – Crowd: 15,127
24/03/2019 – WON v Warriors 34-6 – Crowd: 9,881
23/08/2018 – WON v Sea Eagles 22-20 – Crowd: 8,163
17/06/2018 – LOST v Raiders 12-48 – Crowd: 10,237
23/03/2018 – LOST v Broncos 7-9 – Crowd: 11,434
25/08/2017 – LOST v Cowboys 14-22 – Crowd: 9,346

SUMMARY
Record: 7 wins, 23 losses (23% win rate)
Points: 546 for, 714 against (–168)
Average score: Tigers 18.2, opposition 23.8
Close losses: 9 of the 23 losses were by 6 points or fewer
Biggest win: 46-4 v Knights (24/08/2019)
Biggest loss: 12-48 v Raiders (17/06/2018)
Most points scored: 48 v Raiders (23/06/2024)

CROWDS
Total: 321,013
Average: 10,700 (11,457 leaving out the 2020 COVID games)
Biggest: 17,351 v Broncos (27/04/2024)
Smallest (not counting COVID): 6,107 v Roosters (21/03/2021)
6 crowds above 15,000, and 5 of them were from 2024 onwards

TRENDS
Since 2024: 3 wins, 10 losses, average crowd 13,400
2017–2023 (not counting COVID): average crowd 9,773
Crowds are up about 37%, but results haven't improved
Only 2 of the last 15 games at the ground were wins
 
WESTS TIGERS – LAST 30 NRL GAMES AT CAMPBELLTOWN STADIUM
(Tigers score first, most recent first)

10/07/2026 – LOST v Warriors 6-32 – Crowd: 10,445
20/06/2026 – LOST v Dolphins 22-36 – Crowd: 12,281
18/04/2026 – LOST v Broncos 20-21 – Crowd: 17,316
12/04/2026 – WON v Knights 42-22 – Crowd: 15,221
20/06/2025 – LOST v Raiders 12-16 – Crowd: 9,328
18/05/2025 – LOST v Rabbitohs 12-22 – Crowd: 11,102
30/03/2025 – LOST v Warriors 24-26 – Crowd: 12,020
07/03/2025 – LOST v Knights 8-10 – Crowd: 13,160
06/09/2024 – LOST v Eels 26-60 – Crowd: 17,311
17/08/2024 – WON v Rabbitohs 18-16 – Crowd: 11,420
23/06/2024 – WON v Raiders 48-24 – Crowd: 10,106
27/04/2024 – LOST v Broncos 10-34 – Crowd: 17,351
14/04/2024 – LOST v Dragons 12-24 – Crowd: 17,141
17/06/2023 – LOST v Storm 6-28 – Crowd: 8,517
02/06/2023 – LOST v Raiders 19-20 – Crowd: 11,201
23/04/2023 – LOST v Sea Eagles 16-22 – Crowd: 10,033
07/08/2022 – LOST v Knights 10-14 – Crowd: 9,621
12/06/2022 – LOST v Sea Eagles 4-30 – Crowd: 10,231
25/03/2022 – LOST v Warriors 12-16 – Crowd: 7,182
08/05/2021 – LOST v Titans 28-36 – Crowd: 8,411
21/03/2021 – LOST v Roosters 6-40 – Crowd: 6,107
20/06/2020 – WON v Cowboys 36-20 – Crowd: 104 (COVID)
13/06/2020 – LOST v Raiders 6-14 – Crowd: 109 (COVID)
24/08/2019 – WON v Knights 46-4 – Crowd: 11,107
31/03/2019 – LOST v Bulldogs 8-22 – Crowd: 15,127
24/03/2019 – WON v Warriors 34-6 – Crowd: 9,881
23/08/2018 – WON v Sea Eagles 22-20 – Crowd: 8,163
17/06/2018 – LOST v Raiders 12-48 – Crowd: 10,237
23/03/2018 – LOST v Broncos 7-9 – Crowd: 11,434
25/08/2017 – LOST v Cowboys 14-22 – Crowd: 9,346

SUMMARY
Record: 7 wins, 23 losses (23% win rate)
Points: 546 for, 714 against (–168)
Average score: Tigers 18.2, opposition 23.8
Close losses: 9 of the 23 losses were by 6 points or fewer
Biggest win: 46-4 v Knights (24/08/2019)
Biggest loss: 12-48 v Raiders (17/06/2018)
Most points scored: 48 v Raiders (23/06/2024)

CROWDS
Total: 321,013
Average: 10,700 (11,457 leaving out the 2020 COVID games)
Biggest: 17,351 v Broncos (27/04/2024)
Smallest (not counting COVID): 6,107 v Roosters (21/03/2021)
6 crowds above 15,000, and 5 of them were from 2024 onwards

TRENDS
Since 2024: 3 wins, 10 losses, average crowd 13,400
2017–2023 (not counting COVID): average crowd 9,773
Crowds are up about 37%, but results haven't improved
Only 2 of the last 15 games at the ground were wins
Man that's a terrible record. I didn't think it was that bad.
I'm worried about next year without any Leichhardt oval games, where we won 3 from 3.
Hopefully something changes at Campbelltown. No wonder we haven't made the finals in the last decade if you have a 23% win rate at your home ground.
 
Ai says the West's tigers have broken the cambo curse quite a few times and by some big margins, how you explain that?
You gave me an idea.

I asked AI (claude opus 4.7) what it thought of Holman Barnes Group and whether they were fit to hold the license for an NRL franchise. This was the response:

-----

Let's talk about the circus Holman Barnes Group is running - and has been running - for years now.

This isn't a bad week. It isn't a bad month. This is YEARS of self-inflicted dysfunction from the people who hold 90% of the club and the NRL licence. Let's lay it out:

The HBG Board — a revolving door of chaos:
  • 2024: Three directors — Tony Andreacchio, Rick Wayde and David Gilbert — banned for a COMBINED 23 YEARS. Their crime? Daring to instigate the independent review of the Tigers.
  • 2025: Chair Julie Romero rolled in a boardroom coup — right after delivering the best returns HBG had ever seen.
  • 2025: Long-time CEO Simon Cook walks out the door.
  • April 2025: Dennis Burgess installed as chair. Francesco Primerano as deputy. New regime, same old debenture-holder stitch-up.
  • Dec 2025: Burgess resigns in disgrace after it's revealed his "wildmandenny" Instagram account was following 200+ sexually explicit pages. He quits the Tigers board too.
  • 2026: Rick Wayde settles his Supreme Court action against HBG.
  • Oct 2026: Ousted director Tony Andreacchio launches ANOTHER Supreme Court action to blow up the entire debenture system — the 1950s relic that hands control of a $100M empire to just 20 people while 28,500 members get to vote on TWO board spots.
  • Nov 2026: CEO Daniel Paton stood down in "mysterious circumstances" — made to wait in the corridor while Burgess walks in with a lawyer. Allegations not even shared with the board. Two directors abstain from the vote. Paton himself still doesn't know what he's accused of.
  • Ongoing: Liquor & Gaming NSW investigating HBG over the debenture system. Again.
  • Oh, and: While all this is burning down, they tried to give THEMSELVES a pay rise — chairman's honorarium bumped to $70k, higher than clubs 10x their size.
Now the Wests Tigers board — thanks to HBG's "stewardship":
  • 2023: Entire board under Lee Hagipantelis removed by HBG following the Crawford-Barnier report. CEO Justin Pascoe gone.
  • Jan 2025: Independent board installed — Barry O'Farrell (former NSW Premier), Annabelle Williams, Charlie Viola, Michelle McDowell. Shane Richardson as CEO. Club posts first profit in a decade.
  • Dec 2025: HBG SACKS all four independents in fear they would lose control of the Wests Tigers Football Club if they turned another profit.
  • Dec 2025: Shane Richardson resigns — 18 months into a 4-year deal. Seven-figure payout. The one bloke who turned the place around, GONE.
  • Dec 2025: Burgess resigns from Tigers board (Instagram scandal).
  • Dec 2025: NRL and V'landys force HBG to reinstate the independents days later — but HBG restructures to give themselves effective control anyway. Independent board? Dead in less than 12 months.
  • Dec 2025: Within DAYS of reclaiming control, they lock Benji in until 2030 — reportedly with no exit clause. A multi-million dollar time bomb.
  • 2026: Shaun Mielekamp becomes CEO.
  • Nov 2026: Now CEO Paton (also a Tigers director) stood down. More instability bleeds into the football club.
The scoreboard:
  • 15 years without finals. Longest drought in the comp.
  • 3 finals appearances in 27 years since the merger.
  • 2 CEOs chewed up and spat out in 2 years.
  • An entire independent board sacked over a JERSEY COLOUR.
  • The owners dubbed "the most chaotic board in NSW."
  • NRL now openly considering STRIPPING THE LICENCE.
  • Supreme Court cases, L&G investigations, protest movements, Wests Tigers Unite forming.
This isn't a football problem. This is a GOVERNANCE problem. Twenty debenture holders — a club-within-a-club from the 1950s — are strangling a 28,500-strong membership and an NRL joint venture worth $100 million. Every time someone tries to professionalise this club, HBG blows it up to protect their own power base.

V'landys needs to stop monitoring and start acting. The NRL has the power. Use it. Either force a proper independent board PERMANENTLY, break up the debenture system, or take the licence.

----

Thanks for the idea @westielife.
This should put the debate to bed for some of the unhinged loyalists who think this is a balmain vs wests witch-hunt.
Even AI can see the level of incompetence without having any self interest.
 
Last edited:
Man that's a terrible record. I didn't think it was that bad.
I'm worried about next year without any Leichhardt oval games, where we won 3 from 3.
Hopefully something changes at Campbelltown. No wonder we haven't made the finals in the last decade if you have a 23% win rate at your home ground.
Simple fix, mate, just slap a coat of paint on the front gate and call it Leichhardt2.

Throw a couple of rusty turnstiles out front, put a cardboard cutout of the Wayne Pearce Hill behind the dead-ball line and the boys won't know the difference and watch that 23% jump straight to 100%.
 
Simple fix, mate, just slap a coat of paint on the front gate and call it Leichhardt2.

Throw a couple of rusty turnstiles out front, put a cardboard cutout of the Wayne Pearce Hill behind the dead-ball line and the boys won't know the difference and watch that 23% jump straight to 100%.
people turn up to the venue whether it be a Thursday night or driving rain and stand on the hill,
the other venue they simply do not turn up even with 2 for 1's etc.

At least 2027 should be the time to change that hopefully tigers fans can turn up and we get some wins
 
The team has to turn up before we worry about the fans.
That would definitely help!

The people of Campbelltown are either not interested in rugby league or they are smart enough not to turn up and and pay their hard earned just to put themselves through the pain of having to witness one of the most underwhelmingly performed league teams of the 21st century. I do wonder about the masochistic tendencies of the Leichhardt faithful who turn up in droves each time 😂
 
Simple fix, mate, just slap a coat of paint on the front gate and call it Leichhardt2.

Throw a couple of rusty turnstiles out front, put a cardboard cutout of the Wayne Pearce Hill behind the dead-ball line and the boys won't know the difference and watch that 23% jump straight to 100%.
Gee you keep making ideas like this, you will get the vacant CEO gig with HBG.
 
That would definitely help!

The people of Campbelltown are either not interested in rugby league or they are smart enough not to turn up and and pay their hard earned just to put themselves through the pain of having to witness one of the most underwhelmingly performed league teams of the 21st century. I do wonder about the masochistic tendencies of the Leichhardt faithful who turn up in droves each time 😂

Probably people turn up at Leichhardt because they are supporters who know that we win more games than we lose there.I know some people don't believe it is a factor but i disagree,we have to start winning games at CO as the club wants to play most of our games there because a continuation win rate of about 20 percent will kill the club in the long tern even if HBG don't.
 
That would definitely help!

The people of Campbelltown are either not interested in rugby league or they are smart enough not to turn up and and pay their hard earned just to put themselves through the pain of having to witness one of the most underwhelmingly performed league teams of the 21st century. I do wonder about the masochistic tendencies of the Leichhardt faithful who turn up in droves each time 😂
Just LO loyalty that has built over time. And it has a vibe that CSS will never have, imho.
 
Probably people turn up at Leichhardt because they are supporters who know that we win more games than we lose there.I know some people don't believe it is a factor but i disagree,we have to start winning games at CO as the club wants to play most of our games there because a continuation win rate of about 20 percent will kill the club in the long tern even if HBG don't.
Winning 2 of the last 15 there, how can it not be a factor lol
 

Latest posts

Staff online

Back
Top