Search results

Im not really a fan of Twal either but he has a significantly higher output despite playing around 20 minutes less per game on average, and isn't on that much more than Seyfarth. You are talking out of your ass. If you want to stick your head in the sand and support a mediocre player, go ahead...

LMAO saying Alex and "provide power" in the same sentence has to been one of the biggest lies told on this forum. Just goes to show some of our fans either aren't watching games or a already half-plastered by the time they do watch.

I agree it's not his biggest issue although it's still up there. In 2025, he gave away two less penaties in while playing two less games, was placed on report 4 times vs 3 times and his error went from 4 to 10. although I'll grant you that he played more minutes. Still it's like saying instead...

He literally cost us a game against the Warriors this season with one of his dumb penalties, and he’s good for at least one of those every game. He is absolutely one of our more pressing problems, hopefully less so with KPP starting. Any team with Seyfarth in the 17 (outside of injuries) are...

Imagining stanning for a player who has shown little to no improvement over 4-5 seasons under 3 coaches, has actually cost us games out of sheer ill-discipline, and has little to no impact in attack. And in the same breath, these idiots will say our forward pack is not up to scratch but always...

LMAO so total and average metres, total and average tackles, missed tackles, minutes per game, LB, TB, Offloads (totals and averages) are cherry picked stats? Go on, you dense fool, enlighten everyone how using just about every standard metric for a second rower is cherry-picking? Should I have...

Yeah we definitely don’t have the brightest bunch on here 😂 “But..but.. he tries hard”. Yeah so does my 10 y/o nephew in his park footy games on the weekend. Absolute dipshits.

Appreciate the response and feedback. I pulled these together in less than 10 minutes at the time so they’re not the most comprehensive collection of stats but they present a pretty clear picture. From memory, I think the list contained starting right side 2nd rowers for a fair comparison...

Because it’s a forum and I can discuss it if I want to so pipe down. Boy, that jab at the Magpies must have really hurt your feelings to bring you out from under your bridge lol

LMAO you brought Benji into it, genius. I didn’t even mention him nor did the other poster. I called him out for stanning for a mediocre player which all the stats show is an objective fact. But I know you sometimes struggle with reading comprehension and have a side of the ‘tism so I’ll let it...

I would but it wouldn’t matter, according to you. After all, wasn’t it you who’s been questioning Benjis coaching all season? Claiming he’d rather be a friend first than a coach?

Here’s how he was comparing after about 10 rounds as a starter. I’ll update with the remaining ~5 games he started in when I get the chance. Here’s his per game stats up to RD21 You could also use your eyes and brain but I understand Magpie supporters struggle with both those things.

People criticising this signing are acting like hes been called a star signing. No, he’s not a star but he is a huge improvement on the steaming pile of shit that Seyfarth is in the second row or frankly, any position.

LMAO yes, let’s keep starting the guy who was statistically the most ineffective starting second rower in the comp over last season until Benji wised up and benched him. You can support him and your precious Magpies in NSW Cup.

Anyone who has had the misfortune of reading Vicious suggestions would know he had no credibility to begin with. This is the same guy who said he didn’t know what the difference was between Twal and Terrell May.

Going off your drinking habits and inability to string a coherent sentence together, I seriously doubt you have much of anything to stake let alone a wage.

Yes

I’ll bake a cake the day that cancerous worm, Burgess, has nothing to do with our club.

Really? So how would you have proposed he improve Ben Matulino who was signed with a chronic knee injury that forced him into retirement? Or how about Packer, who after one good year spent nearly the rest of career on the sideline mostly injured? How about Josh Reynolds who was played 22 games...

Gee it’s almost as if he was working with a bunch of dud signings by the previous coach who were taking up nearly half the cap and were locked into three or four contracts.