Search results

Reading the last few pages, one thing is very clear. AD and To’a are the new forum whipping boys. Jerome, Alex x2, Skelton, Royce, Sukkar you are safe!

It remains to be seen if both the signings are top 30. IF they are then yes we probably have 1 too many. I’m saying that though Sukkar and Geyer are only signed until 26. Seyfarth has proven time and time again he sucks on the edge.

Didn’t say they couldn’t, but it’s less common and I’m fairly sure Ian Roberts doesn’t. And just like that I’m on a wests tigers forum debating reproduction in gay men. Didn’t have that one on my bingo card.

Good point. When KPP or Samuela are unavailable it will be great not to play Seyfarth there.

Don’t think Ian Roberts will have a biological son any time soon.

Pure speculation but I think Geyer is top 30 and Roberts is a development deal. I hope the focus is now prop and/or lock if AD leaves.

Hassett probably wants a longer contract. 1 year works out okay with Saukuru and Godinet coming through IMO

Geyer and Roberts wouldn’t be top 30 would they? Roberts especially.

What did he do in the 2 games that weren’t against the Titans? He still has a bit to do to get to To’a’s pre-injury form.

Fair point but I am still very keen on us re-signing To’a. Still our best centre until Taylan and Makasini prove otherwise.

If the reported offers are true, there is no way he’s going to take $150k less per season than a club at a similar level to us. This might happen with Melbourne, but we are not them.

That goes for all of them right? Not just Doueihi?

It’s good that we’re trying not to pay overs, but to think we paid nearly twice as much for Bateman boggles the mind. The fact that AD covers so many positions makes him easily worth $450k IMO. Can we just give St George Jack Bird back and call it square?

$350k is an absolute steal if he takes it

I agree with all that, but is there a player in our side that is consistent? To me the question is, is there a better player to take his spot? If he’s keeping out Latu after Latu has had a few games in the 7, why is Latu a better option next year? He may need another year before he’s ready.

I remember Todd Carney flipping the bird when the Roosters won that finals game in extra time. Annoyed me but he could celebrate however he wanted. It's not up to the NRL to decide what verbal/non-verbal gestures are allowed. Move on, and worry about fixing the good team bias instead.

Webster wanted Seyfarth earlier, Bird hopefully Super League, and Kit we can probably pay out on this years' cap.

He kicked the winning goal in golden point vs Sharks, kicked the winning field goal against Titans and was best on ground yesterday. He's been our best player for the last 6 weeks and I think some are blinded by their hate. He deserves to get the best deal he can. Just like Luai did.

Take a leaf out of the Sharks book who are making room for Kennedy. Seyfarth, Bird, Kit free to go.

Just like Latu’s $600k team friendly deal?