Search results

He faked an injury vs warriors but realistically he is just out of form and not trying

He had 2 bad series for nsw in 2022 and 2023. For samoa crichton sent them into the world cup final. He's not a main man

Luai was a passenger at penrith. The superstar status is largely due to being helped by a great team. He is unproven and so far he looks average outside the penrith system

Dylan Brown has 3 TAs in 2025 with reserve grade halfbacks volkman and hawkins. Luai has 0, less than Fainu, Galvin and Doueihi. As the halfback.

Attack was a lot smoother and dangerous. Not clunky and slow

We scored 5 tries tonight. Having him out there would not have changed the scoreline despite his 'energy'

And yet luai tonight is out and the tigers are playing a top 4 team playing better without him. All that energy and defence still there, but even better attack. If penrith are missing him, send him back. We could use that 1.2 million elsewhere

Lol and there's people here saying my take was the worst they've seen

Other than the turuva try vs dolphins where he was 1st receiver, you can't just include the fact he passed the ball in a sequence of play for other tries and give him credit there. The attack dies with him a lot. At least galvin can set up tries. If latu plays well I think luai might play in...

First half kicks a very shallow kick with 10 minutes left, then warriors go up field and target him in defence and score. He's a liability when he gets involved, which is barely

Wow one try 'assist' multiple passes back. Really stretching it there and ignoring the quick passing that also helped create the overlap

You're upset with facts. All those guys I've mentioned have played pivotal roles in getting penrith premierships. Martin has a CCM, so does Edwards. To'o has had multiple great finals games. Leota was the best forward in the 2022 and 2023 grand finals. Luai has not starred in a single finals...

They offered him 850K for 2 years. He's not valued by them. They bought a young talented kid from parramatta to replace him, not an experienced or solid player. Shows how he's just a cog in a system

Nathan Cleary, Isaah Yeo, Dylan Edwards, Brian To'o, Liam Martin, JFH, Moses Leota and Stephen Crichton are all more important to their success

It's quite pathetic tbh. The cognitive dissonance of our fans to find a new saviour while completely ignoring it is quickly becoming Luke Brooks 2.0, or worse...

They probably just mean the energy and vibes. Because he brings absolutely nothing on the playing side of things

His kicks haven't been great. He let in two tries recently vs warriors one being the crucial match deciding one and one against niukore. The week before he let nikorima outmuscle him. He ran for 11 metres. 11 metres on the weekend. That is luke brooks in a tigers jersey numbers. At least luke...

Is what I said not true? You could name 5 penrith players at least who are more important to their dynasty. Ivan was happy to let him go

Always an excuse

He's been next to nathan cleary in 4 of those premierships, and a stacked side too. He has not proven himself