Search results

You and I have got heated over the years but I never thought you were arguing in bad faith which I appreciated. And like you said, we even found common ground after we explained both our positions more and agreed to disagree on some things (Brooks and Seyfarth). You’ll be shocked to k ow I’m...

Yeah that’s fair enough regarding the classification of valued. I’ll concede he might be offered a top 30 spot elsewhere although I doubt it would be for a top team and he wouldn’t be near the top 17 unless due to injury. Definitely agree he wouldn’t be a core player if he left, especially...

Sorry mate but the eye test and his stats say it is an objective fact despite what his little cult claim (not including you in that btw). The Warrior's offered him a contract, that’s not going hard. Bumping up the offer after he rejected it due to wanting to remain in Sydney would’ve been going...

You really are quite the spin artist. That was in 2023 when he was offered a contract with the Warriors (according to Seyfarth), and it was rumoured that Canterbury were interested, not that he been offered a deal. Canterbury hadn’t played finals since 2016 and wouldn’t again until 2024 while...

I don’t hate him as a person, just as a first grade NRL player. Believe it or not, I was a big believer when I first saw him coming through NYC and NSW Cup. I hate that he’s heavily featured in the team despite barely improving in 6 seasons, that he’s a liability in attack 90% of the time and...

Oh I’m sorry, you said players like Seyfarth “help” the club sign players like Luai. Because that’s less stupid, right? 🤣🤣 You’re just embarrassing yourself now, Mrs Seyfarth.

Yep, it’s like a cult or they’re probably friend and family. I gave just about every one of his stats across every round, including totals and averages, as well as comparing against other second rowers. One of the moron crew said I was cherry-picking yet couldn’t tell what I left out lol

At least the guy is a solid troll.

Right. It was because of players like Seyfarth that Luai, Terrell signed on and Taylan and Bula re-signed 🤣🤣🤣

lol no you're not. But keep deflecting as it appears to be the only thing you’re good at 👋

I’ll translate this: WestsEffTheRest ran his mouth about cherry-picked stats, realised he was talking out of his arse, ran and is now deflecting. It’s okay, bud. Im sure you’ll learn to think before posting one of these days.

R360 would pay to keep him away. Imagine the fall in viewership after watching Seyfarths “hit-ups”

No surprise a Magpie supporter would revel in mediocre players being “integral” to the team 🤣 Still waiting for you to point out which of Seyfarths laughable stats I “cherry-picked” but I won’t hold my breath.

Holy strawman, Batman!

I give respect to forumers who debate/argue in good faith and don’t lie, which happens to rule out quite a few on here.

LMAO saying Alex and "provide power" in the same sentence has to been one of the biggest lies told on this forum. Just goes to show some of our fans either aren't watching games or a already half-plastered by the time they do watch.

I agree it's not his biggest issue although it's still up there. In 2025, he gave away two less penaties in while playing two less games, was placed on report 4 times vs 3 times and his error went from 4 to 10. although I'll grant you that he played more minutes. Still it's like saying instead...

He literally cost us a game against the Warriors this season with one of his dumb penalties, and he’s good for at least one of those every game. He is absolutely one of our more pressing problems, hopefully less so with KPP starting. Any team with Seyfarth in the 17 (outside of injuries) are...

Imagining stanning for a player who has shown little to no improvement over 4-5 seasons under 3 coaches, has actually cost us games out of sheer ill-discipline, and has little to no impact in attack. And in the same breath, these idiots will say our forward pack is not up to scratch but always...

LMAO so total and average metres, total and average tackles, missed tackles, minutes per game, LB, TB, Offloads (totals and averages) are cherry picked stats? Go on, you dense fool, enlighten everyone how using just about every standard metric for a second rower is cherry-picking? Should I have...