2016 report card

[Club_Sandwich]

Rankin C+? You're joking right? Did you see the Panthers game?
Definitely an F from me

 

[larrycorowa]

Rankin C+? You're joking right? Did you see the Panthers game?
Definitely an F from me

Yeah, I watched all his games….did you?

 

[Russell]

Lol well done Larry we are now blaming Farah for other's poor seasons?
This guy is the devil incarnate.

If you don't think it played some part you obviously have never been in a team with fractured leadership. It's is a distraction and takes an emotional toll. Woods and Lawrence were heavily invested in Farah but also in trying to improve the club, that's all I am saying.

I couldn't find my car keys this morning….I don't know him, never met him and live thousands of kilometers away but it stands to reason Robbie had something to do with their disappearance. Dammmnnnn him!!!!!

That is ridiculous Stryker - everyone knows he had them in his back pocket. Lol

 

[Club_Sandwich]

Rankin C+? You're joking right? Did you see the Panthers game?
Definitely an F from me

Yeah, I watched all his games….did you?

Yeah champ I did. And he still gets an F.

 

[TCL]

Teddy, Moses and woods had a very good year and have been rewarded with rep honours. A's

nofa, sue, ET, Ava , Aloio had a solid year. B's

kev, grant, Simona played well but need to improve. C+

Brooks, Lawrence. C

The rest D

JT - D+

Our back line and halfs are good, just need some tweaking, I agree with previous post if rankin could kick 80% or better and only played wing I would keep him. If we could buy a fast winger that could kick I would be happy to let rankin go.

Stronger and bigger forwards Grant size and runs like Sue (x2 please)

Our defence, it's been said before we need aggression and to work as a unit. Good structures and line speed. This is what lets our team down.

JT, his fate lies in his results early next year?

I don't think we are far off a team that is ready to compete week in week out and make the finals consistently!

 

[larrycorowa]

Rankin C+? You're joking right? Did you see the Panthers game?
Definitely an F from me

Yeah, I watched all his games….did you?

Yeah champ I did. And he still gets an F.

You have nfi

 

[Club_Sandwich]

Rankin C+? You're joking right? Did you see the Panthers game?
Definitely an F from me

Yeah, I watched all his games….did you?

Yeah champ I did. And he still gets an F.

You have nfi

I think you'll find the vast majority of users agree with me fella. Let it go

 

[Tigertigertiger]

Gotta love it when our great fans are arguing over how crap Rankin is

 

[Born_tiger]

Yeah, I watched all his games….did you?

Yeah champ I did. And he still gets an F.

You have nfi

I think you'll find the vast majority of users agree with me fella. Let it go

TigerWoods giving Rankin an F is a complement…

Rankin;

If at first you don't succeed, then maybe you just suck.

(Thanks, TTT)

 

[Born_tiger]

Yeah champ I did. And he still gets an F.

You have nfi

I think you'll find the vast majority of users agree with me fella. Let it go

TigerWoods giving Rankin an F is a complement…

Rankin;

If at first you don't succeed, then maybe you just suck.

(Thanks, TTT)

 

[Masterton]

Yeah, I watched all his games….did you?

Yeah champ I did. And he still gets an F.

You have nfi

I think you'll find the vast majority of users agree with me fella. Let it go

Time for a "what rating do you give Rankin" poll.

 

[Telltails]

The problem is we are so small and unable to communicate on that side of the field… need a new system or new players, i dont want to see nofo and naqaima on the same edge

No way is Kev better than simona. I think you are blinded by the poor end to season and his lack of opportunities on left side when brooks was injured. Simona is a nrl player who needs to be more consistent, Kev I'm not so sure about. Seems to be panic stations whenever the ball went two or three passes to the left from the ruck in defence and Kev was a big part of that.

Yeah if simona was playing at melbourne or sharks I think you would find he would really be pushing for rep honours

I love Simona and rate him highly but he was really poor this year.

Simona had shoulder op immediately at seasons end -suspect he may have been carrying an injury for sometime.

 

[rex2ce]

Rankin is an honest toiler , as is Lovett, can't carry both in first grade squad imo

 

[claws]

I suggested that JT should be given the keys to the city if we make the top 8\. He nearly got them. I predicted bottom 3\. I believe we exceeded expectations. The youth & lack of experience out performed all expert analysis. No matter what people think, this year was a very successful year. Why are critics so harsh on the coach? I would like to see these critics operate in the environment that he has been operating in for the past two years. On performance, I give the whole organisation a B+. Had we made the 8, I would have given an A+. The salary cap will be organised post 2017, then the coach can really start to implement his own team, not just tweak around the edges. Go Weststigers in 2017.