AFL West Sydney

Poppa

New member
Looks like the AFL is moving into west Sydney NRL heartland,with the Great Kevin Sheedy to coach to start off in 2012.So should NRL become worried?.There may become a battle between both codes for juniors.Interseting times ahead…......
\
\
:supporter: :supporter: :supporter: 😛ray: 😛ray:
 
AFL will take the kids to unco and small for NRL or Rugby.

That and kids who look forward to a life of trolling the boggers for future talent
 
Had to laugh at the various quotes Paul Osborne (Parra CEO) has come out with:

"I am not particularly worried by it,… it's a pretty ordinary game and we've got a much better product."

"I am not too concerned as I am sure they will come back when they see how boring it is. They are quite intelligent in Western Sydney."

"We've had a couple of chats with the Panthers and the Bulldogs and we all believe we have the much better product and that our heartland is very much here,"

"It (Sheedy's appointment) is a publicity stunt. Who cares? They are pouring a lot of money into a big black hole. They will get nothing back. AFL is boring."

There's another one I can't find right now where he said something like it is boring, "almost as bad as rugby". Tell us what you really think! :laughing:
 
:laughing: Well I agree with him about how ugly and boring the game is but I think he should be worried.

The AFL have a lot money and they are generally pretty well organised.

I used to watch a bit of AFL but I see this as war and I'm not gonna watch another AFL game again!

Ive taken my side of the battle!!!
 
@Poppa said:
Looks like the AFL is moving into west Sydney NRL heartland,with the Great Kevin Sheedy to coach to start off in 2012.So should NRL become worried?.There may become a battle between both codes for juniors.Interseting times ahead…......
\
\
:supporter: :supporter: :supporter: 😛ray: 😛ray:

my kids will be staying true to league :smiley: :slight_smile: :wink: :frowning: :astonished: 😱pen_mouth: 😕 :sunglasses: :laughing: :angry: :stuck_out_tongue: 😢 :imp: :smiling_imp: :unamused: :exclamation: :question: :bulb: :arrow_right: :neutral_face: :mrgreen: :nerd: :sign: :deadhorse: :master: :righton: :supporter: :wahoo: :wahoo: :wahoo: :wahoo: :wahoo: :wahoo: :ugeek: :brick: 😛ray:
 
I am sick of having AFL rammed down my throat. They need to realise that it won't win people over, it just pisses them off. As for Sheedy (I've never heard of him really), will anyone stop watching Jennings or Hayne or Marshall play to watch him coach. Imagine if the NRL set up a Perth franchise and said Chris Anderson would coach it. Do you really think the locals would care? If they sign a Jarryd Hayne I'll worry, but a coach means nothing.
 
I look forward to seeing the club die a slow death out there. The AFL seem to run a tight ship but money can't buy you everything.
I reckon the vast majority of their fans won't be league converts at all but rather Swans supporters jumping off the bandwagon.

_''Good on them, let them waste their money out there. AFL is a low game - almost as bad as rugby.''_
Couldn't agree more.
 
@Marshall_magic said:
I am sick of having AFL rammed down my throat. They need to realise that it won't win people over, it just pisses them off. As for Sheedy (I've never heard of him really), will anyone stop watching Jennings or Hayne or Marshall play to watch him coach. Imagine if the NRL set up a Perth franchise and said Chris Anderson would coach it. Do you really think the locals would care? If they sign a Jarryd Hayne I'll worry, but a coach means nothing.

Yep I agree totally. The way the AFL goes around thinking its the greatest sport in the world just gives me the s***s and its turned me against them even more.
They say its not a war and that all codes can work on their own but really the AFL would love to kill league and knock it out as quick as possible.
I mean why isnt there any talk about the AFL signing Rugby Union players like Matt Giteau? Because it wouldnt create the publicity or impact that it would by signing an elite Rugby League player.
Also the way Premier Rees has supported and funded the move has annoyed me more because there are a lot of Rugby League grounds out there that need funding and repair, yet Rees decides to fund an AFL ground for a team that are going to be playing matches at Homebush anyway.

It'll be really interesting to see what the crowds will be like because Swans get around 30K to their matches but then only another 150K people watch their matches on tv in Sydney, so if those numbers get split with the extra team coming in, then the tv ratings and attendances are going to be absolutely terrible for both teams… Hopefully!! 😛ray:
 
I don't like what the AFL are doing but you know why? It IS a threat, a very serious threat. They've got the $200mil war chest that with the introduction of 2 more teams in the coming years, on top of what many would say is an increase in it's marketplace power and honestly we've got a fight on hands. We may "have" western sydney but we don't have the resources to battle that. We're a smallish code played predominantly in 2 states with an administration that needs a complete overhaul that desperately needs to be simplified because right now it acts like something 20-30 years behind the times.

On top of that we seem to show very little concern for growing our game. I've been critical of that lawyer….Gallop and his lack of vision for 2-3 years now. He has none! Any suggestions just get overlooked. Right now the vibe i read is that we're resting on our laurels as a code and we better watch out because we've got a war on 2 fronts. AFL and Football and both of them are top shelf in the administration and development of their codes, something we lack in a big way.

Do i fear for our future? Yes! Absolutely. Bottom line is we need to enhance our game, enhance our share in the market, we NEED to expand once again but only when more money becomes available so when the negotiations of the broadcasting deal come up again we need top dollar because this time, our livelyhood is on the line.
 
Well said Tigerpete,hope NRL officals look hard at this move by AFL,and move to protect our game.Remember Melbourne Storm wasn't going to last in Melbourne either,but look where they are now…...enough said....

😛ray: 😛ray: 😛ray: :brick: :brick:
 
@Jazza said:
:laughing: Well I agree with him about how ugly and boring the game is but I think he should be worried.

The AFL have a lot money and they are generally pretty well organised.

I used to watch a bit of AFL but I see this as war and I'm not gonna watch another AFL game again!

Ive taken my side of the battle!!!

ozzy has got the brains..

he is the reason parra went to the finals
 
Ozzy's approach is similar to that of Michael Searle, public enemy number 1 for the Gold Coast team. Every time they make an announcement he rubbishes it, or talks it down, look at how he reacted to the Hunt signing, basically said it was b/s and a publicity stunt.
 
![](http://i38.tinypic.com/1550un4.jpg)
>
**Tell the AFL they're dreaming, says Geyer**
Greg Prichard | November 11, 2009
>
PENRITH great Mark Geyer hit as hard with his words as he used to with his shoulder yesterday, entering the debate over rugby league versus AFL in western Sydney and declaring that while the AFL knew how to create publicity they were doomed to fail in their bid to gain significant support in league's heartland.
>
Geyer, who was at Penrith's home ground, CUA Stadium, to help publicise the club's membership drive, said he knew from growing up and living in the area that when the Greater Western Sydney team started playing in 2012 it wouldn't get the level of crowd support the AFL was aiming at.
>
''I'm just as concerned about the AFL threat as Melbourne would be about a second rugby league team,'' Geyer said. ''In other words, I'm not concerned. The fact they've got Kevin Sheedy as coach brings big publicity points to their franchise, since he is probably the AFL equivalent to Wayne Bennett, but ultimately they're in for a rude shock once they get out here into the western suburbs and realise AFL is a game that really doesn't compete with rugby league.
>
''Karmichael Hunt diving over to the AFL, Grant Mayer, Sheedy, they're all good for publicity, but it won't sustain it. I've been here for 40 years, so I know exactly what the people in the west think and how they live, and while AFL is getting publicity out here at the moment it certainly won't be any challenge to rugby league.''
>
Geyer said he didn't envisage the AFL managing to sign a league superstar. Jarryd Hayne (Parramatta), Israel Folau (Brisbane), Michael Jennings (Penrith) and Jamal Idris (Bulldogs) are understood to be included on their wish list, from which they would like to grab one to boost the GWS push.
>
''The last time I looked, there were no Polynesian players in the AFL, but they're the players they're targeting,'' he said. ''I think it's all baloney. I don't think the Polynesian player has the build for AFL. Rugby league he has, big-time. I think they're throwing up names willy-nilly - Jarryd Hayne's about to re-sign for Parramatta.''
>
Asked if he thought the NRL needed to be more active in a bid to match the AFL, Geyer said he believed the league couldn't have had a better advertisement for the game than this season.
>
''I don't think they can do much more than they're doing at the moment,'' he said. ''Maybe a team on the Central Coast and maybe another one in Queensland, but I think when you're celebrating such a big year as we've just had it's very hard to start planning and putting other teams in. You look at the 2009 league season and that's your blueprint for success, and if they go away from that in any way, shape or form then they could be in trouble.''
>
Penrith's premiership-winning captain from 1991, Greg Alexander, was similarly confident the sky would not be falling in on league in western Sydney just because the AFL was competing for public support.
>
''It's not as if AFL's a new game to Sydney - the Swans have been here for 30 years,'' Alexander said.
>
''I think league should be on guard but … It's not a new sport - everyone knows about it.''

Panther's Legend Mark Geyer….love that pic.

The NRL should be worried...I work in a school that produced the likes of Minichello and De Gois........Four years ago AFL didnt exist.....they came along giving the school equipment........ offering free assistance to the P.E. staff to develop AFL into the cirriculum..they accepted......We now have 2 full teams in the MCS competion.....

While Rugby League still rules the skool.... I was a bit shocked the other day when games of AFL where being played at recess and lunch.....

This is where the AFL have it all over the NRL.........they have the $$$$$ and they are not afraid to throw it at the grassroots level....something the NRL..... thank you Mr Gallop........take for granted.......
 
It worries me though that there are a lot of influential league figures who are laughing, rubbishing and writing off the GWS bid. Ok, so it may fail as they say so but thats hardly the attitude that is going to bring it down. As you said Geo, it appears that the nrl is taking things for granted. The lack of action in growing the game this past decade has been appalling. Perhaps it is the money they have in the coffers which leaves us disadvantaged but like i said earlier, with a new tv deal, we need to think big and get things right because we're under serious threat here.
 
@Tigerpete said:
It worries me though that there are a lot of influential league figures who are laughing, rubbishing and writing off the GWS bid.

It worries me too.

The blokes running our game cannot take the strong hold on sydney's west for granted. I don't think much will change, but the AFL will stick it through for 10,15 yrs… the AFL has expanded on a few occasions and every-time it has been successful... with the sides performing well and the club becoming financially successful.

I don't think anyone can claim the same for the Storm. Yes they have won x amount of premierships, featured in 4 finals in a row and blah blah... but they are not financially viable and as soon as News Ltd leave the game... the storm are in trouble.
 
I saw another picture of Geyer in another article, and he was wearing a Western Reds jersey. How hard is it to find one of him in a Penrith jersey???
 
Back
Top