Benny Elias Vs Robbie Farah?

[Russell]

Someone even mentioned comparing Churchill and Inglis - joke of the century of course.

I actually said its pointless comparing them.

But who cares about reading things in context ay?

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_

I agree Abraham - I read it in context . The point I was making was - that you mentioned Inglis in the same sentence as "The Little Master" - That was the joke.

 

[happy_tiger]

And yet check the man of the match awards in games where Elias played a Walters. Of course I'm biased though - Elias was a champion to me growing up. However suggesting this was solely due to a strong forward pack is nonsense. Besides it's not like Walters played behind Nevilles

Would Mike McLean , Steve Jackson or Gary Larson made any of the NSW sides in Benny's era

Not a chance in hell

Seeing that a few are upset that I'm picking on Balmain royalty

Obvious Balmain boys do cry

 

[LaT]

I guess it depends on perspective, Balmain boys cry…QLDs whinge about bias yet again. Rinse repeat.

 

[happy_tiger]

I guess it depends on perspective, Balmain boys cry…QLDs whinge about bias yet again. Rinse repeat.

How am I whinging LaT ??

All I've said about this is Benny had a far better pack playing in front of him than Farah ,Walters or Smith at club level ,state level

Is that BS ??

NO

 

[LaT]

I guess it depends on perspective, Balmain boys cry…QLDs whinge about bias yet again. Rinse repeat.

How am I whinging LaT ??

All I've said about this is Benny had a far better pack playing in front of him than Farah ,Walters or Smith at club level ,state level

Is that BS ??

NO

Not whinging…just "picking on balmain royalty" right?

Look, most people here are all for the back and forth banter but in this thread you seem willing to throw some darts but get extremely touchy when the serve is returned.

 

[stevetiger]

Coming in late however you must be kidding if you think Benny isn't better than Robbie has been so far and Robbie is better than any of the Waters brothers. Benny was the best hooker I've seen.

I think Robbie can surpass Smith if he plays like he has been this year for another season or two.

 

[Go_Moltzen]

Loved both but Bouncing Benny over Robbie by a mile, sorry km for you young dudes.

 

[Justo]

I'd like to applaud Roosterman for starting this great thread. Great question!!!

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_

 

[happy_tiger]

I'd like to applaud Roosterman for starting this great thread. Great question!!!

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_

Yeah it is actually

And I thought I'd start a thread on the Chook Pen naming a past and present Roosters junior great who plays in the same position and I couldn't

Roosters don't have any local juniors who are good in the same position , they buy all their players in