Best record against the storm?

[Andy666]

The tigers have won 4 from 10 since 2005 against the storm. Do we have the best record against them, bar maybe the worriers who seem to be there voodoo team?

Im betting those 4 wins were at Leichhardt, goes to show how much of an advantage that ground is to us….

 

[Guest]

We have been to Melbourne 9 times and have never won there. Not many teams do win down there.

 

[larrycorowa]

do we discount the years they were cheating the cap?

 

[Brisbane_Tiger]

Warriors and Manly have better records than us.

 

[Juro]

Since the start of 2005, we have actually played them 11 times, for 4 wins. That gives us a win % of 36.4%, ranking us equal 4th.

1\. Manly - 8 wins / 15 = 53.3%
2\. NZ - 7 wins + 1 draw / 17 = 44.1%
3\. Titans - 3 wins / 8 = 37.5%
=4\. Wests Tigers, Sharks, Eels - 4 wins / 11 = 36.4%
…
16\. Souths - 1 win / 12 = 8.3%

A win on Friday would put us up into 3rd place on 41.7%.

 

[Juro]

If you were to take 2005 out of the equation (we lost to them twice that year - I was so happy when the Cowboys knocked them out of the finals for us), we would be second only to Manly. We would be 4 wins from 9 = 44.4%. Manly are on 7 wins from 14 for that period = 50%.

And a win on Friday would obviously lift us to 50% too. Amazing considering we have such a terrible record down there!

 

[Illek]

Im betting those 4 wins were at Leichhardt, goes to show how much of an advantage that ground is to us….

I know one of those wins was at gosford. From memory I don't think we've played them at campbelltown.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[Yossarian]

Im betting those 4 wins were at Leichhardt, goes to show how much of an advantage that ground is to us….

I know one of those wins was at gosford. From memory I don't think we've played them at campbelltown.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

We have played at Campbelltown in 2008 for a loss. 3 wins at Leichhardt, 1 at Gosford.
\
\
Winner Score Venue Round Year
Melbourne 12-4 Leichhardt Oval Round 15 2011
Wests Tigers 26-14 Leichhardt Oval Round 25 2010
Melbourne 14-12 Olympic Park Round 15 2009
Wests Tigers 16-6 Leichhardt Oval Round 6 2009
Melbourne 30-18 Campbelltown Round 18 2008
Wests Tigers 30-12 Bluetongue Stadium Round 8 2007
Melbourne 18-16 Olympic Park Round 1 2007
Melbourne 46-4 Olympic Park Round 22 2006
Wests Tigers 30-28 Leichhardt Oval Round 4 2006
Melbourne 34-22 Olympic Park Round 25 2005

 

[happy_tiger]

Was the Blue Tongue game an away game for the Storm or a away game for Us ??

 

[Yossarian]

Was the Blue Tongue game an away game for the Storm or a away game for Us ??

Storm home game I am pretty sure Happy. This was during the time they used the CC as their feeder team.

 

[jirskyr]

That game 2009 at Olympic Park, Daine Laurie catches a football and we win. We should have had our first Melbourne win that day, played all over them.

 

[innsaneink]

Hoodoo….not voodoo

 

[Bismark]

Wow…Such a dominant display against their opposition in the last 7 years for 0 Premierships and 2 lost Grand Finals. They are up there with St George on the choke scale when you think about it.

 

[Jazza]

Was the Blue Tongue game an away game for the Storm or a away game for Us ??

Storm home game I am pretty sure Happy. This was during the time they used the CC as their feeder team.

Nahh mate it was our home game, I remember because in 2007, we played down at Olympic Park in rd 1, it was Folau's debut match… And Moodie's comeback match. It would of been Morris' first match for us as well. So the 2nd match against them that year was our home game in Gosford.