Its funny, I think Brooks has all of the attributes necessary, except the balls big enough to tell players where they need to be an when....
Brooks isnt an alpha personality, and has lived with Benji big balling him for too long. You could set the deepest running line in the history of RL, and Bunji would crab walk them all out of space. Not benji's fault, Luke is supposed to be setting the lines, but would anyone here believe Brooks is leading you into war, or trust Bunji could no-look you into a win? Sad as it is, I know who I would back.....
We need a part time half who can get us from A to B and let Luke finish his decade long apprenticeship, someone who could play percentages. I wish he was there already, but he isnt. Not from lack of skill, but lack of default settings (for lack of better descriptive language). teach him to set the off line, teach him to call the hooker, teach him to set himself deeper late int the set...
Everyone scoffs at Green, but Brooks isnt going to be a 6, the flair isnt there. He is a stud system 7, A to B man plus.... you can dig out unreliable freaks everywhere, but the reliable Pierce, Cronk, Reynolds.... all plus models, but you can rely on them to manouvere the offensive weapons into field position.