Bug's Player Ratings

Balmain_Bug

New member
**Bug's Pull No Punches Player Ratings**

1\. Tim Moltzen 2/10 Terrible game. Looked nervous, threw some terrible passes back to his wingers on the ball returns, was very unsafe at the back, showed zero penatration. He is a terrible option at fullback.

2\. Beau Ryan 7/10 A top game by Beau. Did everything right tonight. If he was wearing a Bronco's jersey his no-try would have been awarded.

3\. Blake Ayshford 6/10 Strong defensive game.

4\. Chris Lawrence 8/10 Simply brilliant. Simply Simply Brilliant.

5\. Matt Utai 7.5/10 Needs to be re-signed. Top player, plenty of ticker, tried his guts out.

6\. Benji Marshall 8.5/10 Should have ran to the line alot more, especially in the first half . Why he does not do that is beyond me because he is brilliant at it. All Class though in the 2nd half. He is just a genius.
7\. Robert Lui 6.5/10 Good game. Too many missed tackles again but he is our best option by far at halfback. Did some good things and kept the Scum in two minds alot.

8\. Bryce Gibbs 7.5/10 Not many metres gained at all but a brilliant game in my opinion. He was aggressive, he hit hard, his desperation tackles were magnificent. We will miss him badly in 2012\. Outplayed NSW SOO front rower KING.

9\. Robbie Farah © 8/10 Great game. Tackled his ass off. Great attack, Awesome kicking game. Great try assist. Lets see Cam Smith do that !!

10\. Keith Galloway 8.5/10 Simply Great at everything. Easily outplayed NSW SOO front rower KING.

11\. Liam Fulton 7.5/10 Top effort. Tried his guts out despite being manhandled quite a bit, Ran great lines which really made the Scum panic. Top effort.

12\. Gareth Ellis 9/10 Fantastic. The Worlds best back rower. Was Watmough even playing ????

13\. Chris Heighington 7/10 Great game. Typical effort.

15\. Todd Payten 3/10 Struggled to get involved. Played poorly. Looks effected by injury.

16\. Mitch Brown 0/10 No game time but still played better than Moltzen.

17\. Aaron Woods 5.5/10 Tried hard and did some good things but a shocking effort to allow Balin past for that try. He should be made to run back to Concord. Obviously it should have been our penalty but sometimes the refs dont care. Terrible play.

18\. Matt Groat 5/10 Played well but gave away 2 penalties in a row that could have killed us. he is not better than Fifita and should not be there instead of Fifita.
 
Well summed up bug, but I think Moltzen did a little better than you made out. Was really hard at the back tonight the ground was like a ice ring. I mean no better than 5, but he will be better for the run
 
Yeah I thought I saw Payten get injured, then looked to struggle the next time I saw him.
Hope its not the last we see of him
 
@Balmain Bug said:
2\. Beau Ryan 7/10 A top game by Beau. Did everything right tonight. If he was wearing a Bronco's jersey his no-try would have been awarded.

yeah I just saw the Bronco's highlights, I thought Beau had more control of the ball than Wallace
 
I can`t disagree with much of that, only I`d score Ayshford a little higher, I`m not always his biggest fan, but thought he went well again tonight. I`d also score Aaron Woods at around 7.5, I know he cost us a try by not playing what was in front of him, but I thought some of his strong charges really helped lay the platform which led to our second half dominance.
 
@innsaneink said:
Yeah I thought I saw Payten get injured, then looked to struggle the next time I saw him.
Hope its not the last we see of him

He definitely made the right call in not playing beyond this season.
 
Moltzen made two try saving tackles that Mckinnon would have struggled with, however I reckon Mitch Brown would have also made them.

Those two tackles alone are worth at least 2 points each - id give him at least a 4
 
@Balmain Bug said:
**Bug's Pull No Punches Player Ratings**

1\. Tim Moltzen 2/10 Terrible game. Looked nervous, threw some terrible passes back to his wingers on the ball returns, was very unsafe at the back, showed zero penatration. He is a terrible option at fullback.

2\. Beau Ryan 7/10 A top game by Beau. Did everything right tonight. If he was wearing a Bronco's jersey his no-try would have been awarded.

3\. Blake Ayshford 6/10 Strong defensive game.

4\. Chris Lawrence 8/10 Simply brilliant. Simply Simply Brilliant.

5\. Matt Utai 7.5/10 Needs to be re-signed. Top player, plenty of ticker, tried his guts out.

6\. Benji Marshall 8.5/10 Should have ran to the line alot more, especially in the first half . Why he does not do that is beyond me because he is brilliant at it. All Class though in the 2nd half. He is just a genius.
7\. Robert Lui 6.5/10 Good game. Too many missed tackles again but he is our best option by far at halfback. Did some good things and kept the Scum in two minds alot.

8\. Bryce Gibbs 7.5/10 Not many metres gained at all but a brilliant game in my opinion. He was aggressive, he hit hard, his desperation tackles were magnificent. We will miss him badly in 2012\. Outplayed NSW SOO front rower KING.

9\. Robbie Farah © 8/10 Great game. Tackled his ass off. Great attack, Awesome kicking game. Great try assist. Lets see Cam Smith do that !!

10\. Keith Galloway 8.5/10 Simply Great at everything. Easily outplayed NSW SOO front rower KING.

11\. Liam Fulton 7.5/10 Top effort. Tried his guts out despite being manhandled quite a bit, Ran great lines which really made the Scum panic. Top effort.

12\. Gareth Ellis 9/10 Fantastic. The Worlds best back rower. Was Watmough even playing ????

13\. Chris Heighington 7/10 Great game. Typical effort.

15\. Todd Payten 3/10 Struggled to get involved. Played poorly. Looks effected by injury.

**16\. Mitch Brown 0/10 No game time but still played better than Moltzen.**
17\. Aaron Woods 5.5/10 Tried hard and did some good things but a shocking effort to allow Balin past for that try. He should be made to run back to Concord. Obviously it should have been our penalty but sometimes the refs dont care. Terrible play.

18\. Matt Groat 5/10 Played well but gave away 2 penalties in a row that could have killed us. he is not better than Fifita and should not be there instead of Fifita.

:roll :roll :roll
 
Back
Top