No mention of the great Isaac Moses’s assessment of Benji’s coaching Skills. The media should be rubbing the creeps nose in it for the crap he put our club through
there was this article :
Benji Marshall coaching dossier: Why Wests Tigers should burn ‘can’t coach’ file
Earlier this year, a dossier was handed to Wests Tigers outlining reasons why Benji Marshall couldn’t coach. Now, the evidence points in the opposite direction. This is the dossier that proves Benji can coach.
Tyson Jackson and
Fatima Kdouh
In April, he said, “No one thinks I can coach anyway.”
In July, he said he was “saying my own eulogy.”
It’s now August and not only is Benji Marshall well and truly alive, but so are his coaching prospects, with his Wests Tigers still a chance of doing the unthinkable.
They’re still a mathematical chance of being alive in September.
The faint heartbeat that is their 2025 season is almost certain to flatline when the eighth-placed Sydney Roosters, four points ahead of the Tigers, face Parramatta on Saturday night.
But the fact that the Tigers will not only avoid a fourth straight wooden spoon, but finish not far out of the top eight, is a giant step in the right direction.
Sensationally taking over from Tim Sheens in 2024, Marshall inherited a roster that had finished last in consecutive seasons.
But, as Sydney crawls out of weeks of downpour and towards the first week of spring, there is evidence of some green shoots in Concord.
The Tigers have peeled off three wins in their past four weeks, snapping a run of seven straight defeats that looked destined to end in another piece of unwanted cutlery.
Skipper and three-time premiership winner Api Koroisau, who has played under the likes of Michael Maguire, Des Hasler, and Ivan Cleary, credits Marshall’s leadership.
“I’m going to take my hat off to Benji here,” Koroisau said.
“He keeps everyone pretty humble. Yeah, there’s no getting carried away with him or getting complacent. To be honest, he’s riding us pretty hard.
“Our standards have picked up for us in three weeks, and that’s the back end of the season, so, yeah, as a coach, I think he’s doing a great job.”
While Koroisau holds his coach in high regard, he also revealed that Marshall is his own — and the team’s — toughest critic.
Tigers fans have backed coach Benji Marshall in the wake of the Lachlan Galvin contract saga.
Even with victories against heavyweights like the Bulldogs, Cronulla, and the Roosters, Marshall remains unsatisfied with the club’s progress.
“He’s been nitpicking, making sure that our standards are staying the same or even going to another level at this time of the year,” Koroisau said.
“We’ve got three rounds to go, but he’s made a big point of playing week by week, and he hasn’t been happy with the wins either.
“For us, it’s about not being happy with simply what we have done so far.”
Young halfback Latu Fainu, who has settled in at halfback following the ugly exit of Lachlan Galvin, has also been quick to praise his inexperienced coach.
Galvin was believed to compiled a document listing the reasons that justified his request to leave the club and make a bombshell mid-season move to Canterbury.
Fainu has shown glimpses of why the Tigers are so confident of his long-term prospects despite spending a lot of time on the sidelines.
“When I went through my injuries, I was so lucky to have him as my coach. He’s been a great role model for me,” Fainu said.
“He was one of the players I looked up to when I was younger.
“He’s like one of the boys. He has his standards that he wants to drive.
“But he is also easygoing. It really is like talking to an older brother because he has been through the game. He knows what you are feeling or going through as players.”
One of Marshall’s biggest philosophies is letting his younger players to be confident in their own games.
“He’s always told me to just back myself,” Fainu said.
“Be confident and don’t backtrack if you see something — take it. Don’t overthink; the more you overthink as a halfback, the more you end up in your own head.”
Earlier this year, a dossier was handed to the Tigers outlining reasons why Marshall couldn’t coach. Now, the evidence points in the opposite direction.
Here is our dossier on why Marshall can.
CLEARED OUT A WOODEN SPOON ROSTER
Marshall has been ruthless in reshaping the squad, moving on players who failed to meet his standards. High-profile departures include David Nofaluma, John Bateman, David Klemmer, Isaiah Papali’i, and Jayden Sullivan. When next year begins, only eight players will have remained from their 2023 squad.
ABILITY TO RECRUIT TALENT
Marshall has excelled in recruitment, bringing premiership winners Jarome Luai and Sunia Turuva to the club, along with Terrell and Taylan May, Royce Hunt, and Jack Bird. His recruitment drive continues next year, with Kai Pearce-Paul, Maverik Geyer, and rising stars Javon Andrews and Ethan Roberts set to join in 2026.
Jarome Luai loves playing for Benji Marshall. Picture: Mark Metcalfe/Getty Images
ABILITY TO RETAIN TALENT
While critics have focused on the loss of promising juniors Lachlan Galvin and Talynn Da Silva, it hasn’t stopped other players from re-committing. Recent re-signings include Adam Doueihi, Starford Toa, Koroisau, Sione Fainu, and Alex Seyfarth. Jarome Luai has also given a verbal commitment to remain at the club, and extensions for the May brothers are reportedly close.
REJUVENATING A BROKEN TEAM
After a seven-game losing streak threatened to derail the Tigers’ season, Marshall steered the club to four wins from their past six games, including a famous victory over the Roosters. The turnaround has reignited hope and silenced talk of a fourth consecutive wooden spoon.
Marshall didn’t let the Lachlan Galvin saga define his side’s season. Picture: Tom Parrish
MOST WINS SINCE 2019
With three games remaining, Marshall has led the Tigers to their best position since 2019, when they finished on 24 points — equal to eighth-placed Cronulla, who made the finals on points differential. Marshall’s men currently sit on 24 points, surpassing the achievements of Michael Maguire and Tim Sheens, and are one win away from tying Ivan Cleary’s 2018 tally with the club.
BUILT QUALITY DEPTH
The Tigers now boast enviable depth, with grand final players and premiership winners in Brent Naden and Charlie Staines waiting in reserve grade. Marshall has created a squad where the likes of Bird and Royce Hunt can be dropped to lower grades. Youngsters Heath Mason, Luke Laulilii and Kit Laulilii are also in the NSW Cup.
There’s a feeling of hope among Tigers fans. Photo: Tom Parrish
EARNED PLAYERS’ LOYALTY
Marshall has fostered a culture where players want to play for their coach—a quality missing from the Tigers for years. When Galvin questioned Marshall’s coaching abilities, players rallied behind their coach, stamping out poor behaviour and reinforcing their commitment to his leadership. Marshall’s journey as a coach is far from over, but his players’ belief in him—and the results he’s delivering — suggest he’s on the path to success.