Dogs V Parra.....*Spoilers*

[Geo]

I'm Hoping Parra to win to see what happens to Hayne - its the NRL's integrity on the line

Who cares about integrity, i think it would be a tragedy if Hayne was suspended. The biggest game of the year needs the games best player. Sydney needs him.

What a load of crap….you can't be serious.....are you pushing for a job on the NRL board........

Penalty sufficient....bull.......If he doesn't get 3 weeks it's a deadset joke........

Argh....just saw it again on replay......his knee came into direct contact with Goodwin's head.......what's your defence for that......I'm Jarred Hayne.......

 

[anderson_silva]

if hayne and keating dont get suspended it lays the platform for some dirty tactics next year and in the grand final

 

[innsaneink]

Keatings was nothing, a guy sticks an arm out to fand, they get tangkled up, it happens.
Ask Bryce what he thinks of the Hayne knees to the head, it was worse than Gibbs' and what he get, three weeks?

 

[anderson_silva]

Keatings was nothing, a guy sticks an arm out to fand, they get tangkled up, it happens.
Ask Bryce what he thinks of the Hayne knees to the head, it was worse than Gibbs' and what he get, three weeks?

keating grabbed the arm and cranked it back, if smith was suspended last year for his tackle then so should these 2.

 

[innsaneink]

Yes I saw it too champ…no point arguing

 

[king_sirro]

I'm Hoping Parra to win to see what happens to Hayne - its the NRL's integrity on the line

Who cares about integrity, i think it would be a tragedy if Hayne was suspended. The biggest game of the year needs the games best player. Sydney needs him.

What a load of crap….you can't be serious.....are you pushing for a job on the NRL board........

Penalty sufficient....bull.......If he doesn't get 3 weeks it's a deadset joke........

Argh....just saw it again on replay......his knee came into direct contact with Goodwin's head.......what's your defence for that......I'm Jarred Hayne.......

All i know is that i want Parra to win and i want the best players playing. In my opinion Gibbs should not have been suspended and Hayne shouldnt either.

 

[king_sirro]

Keatings was nothing, a guy sticks an arm out to fand, they get tangkled up, it happens.
Ask Bryce what he thinks of the Hayne knees to the head, it was worse than Gibbs' and what he get, three weeks?

Agree.
Keatings was just one of those things. He shouldnt even have been a penalty.

 

[innsaneink]

Love to see Parra win the whole damned thing, might be enough to send golden over the gap once and for all

 

[Geo]

What a load of crap….you can't be serious.....are you pushing for a job on the NRL board........

Penalty sufficient....bull.......If he doesn't get 3 weeks it's a deadset joke........

Argh....just saw it again on replay......his knee came into direct contact with Goodwin's head.......what's your defence for that......I'm Jarred Hayne.......

All i know is that i want Parra to win and i want the best players playing. In my opinion Gibbs should not have been suspended and Hayne shouldnt either.

Okay…so it doesn't matter that he committed an illegal act........He shouldn't be suspended cause he's a gun player......The gun players should play........that's dangerous ground your stepping on there Sirro......

FTR...I dont think Gibbs deserved a Grade 2 either but he got it .......the precedent has been set........but I bet you get your wish.......It will be downgraded take the early plea and be free to play.......What's a Grand Final if the Face of the NRL can't play.......

 

[shiretiger]

Hayne to get at least 3 weeks…...his knees were worse than Gibbs IMHO.....

 

[Marshall_magic]

I just can't see them suspending Hayne.

Probably thought the same thing about Cam Smith last year

 

[Rorko]

he slid in to and the knees were bad should be cited but prob no suspension. Gibbs was an idiot burt had scored and gibbs comes over and knees him in the back deserved to be suspended for being a tool

 

[diedpretty]

I'm Hoping Parra to win to see what happens to Hayne - its the NRL's integrity on the line

Who cares about integrity, i think it would be a tragedy if Hayne was suspended. The biggest game of the year needs the games best player. Sydney needs him.

Your kidding aren't you - Did you cry for Cameron Smith last year - he led with his knees at Goodwins head - i don't care if it was JC - if they don't suspend him the NRL is a joke.

 

[RatedRKO]

he slid in to and the knees were bad should be cited but prob no suspension. Gibbs was an idiot burt had scored and gibbs comes over and knees him in the back deserved to be suspended for being a tool

The player had the ball down and had scored the try before Haynes knee came in. Should be the same punishment, if not worse for attacking the head.

 

[RatedRKO]

Cant seem to edit my post, but heres a photo.


 

[red_dogg]

there saying if its classed as a grade 1 the prick gets off with no carryover points which is a joke, cause i remember him coming in late and hitting a couple of our boys late, the one that sticks out is ellis. not to mention other games for instances where if it was bryce gibbs doing the same thing he would of been sighted.
storm will cry poor if they win tonight and hayne is alloud to play.

 

[king_sirro]

he slid in to and the knees were bad should be cited but prob no suspension. Gibbs was an idiot burt had scored and gibbs comes over and knees him in the back deserved to be suspended for being a tool

The player had the ball down and had scored the try before Haynes knee came in. Should be the same punishment, if not worse for attacking the head.

Cameron Smith is a constant dog who deliberately did what he did and he deserved everything he got.

And if u and Geo look carefully, i actually said Hayne should be suspended due to the fact Gibbs was, but its my belief neither should be.

I dont care what anyone says, as a footy fan i want to see how the games new superstar handles the biggest game of all.
\
\
**FREE JARRYD HAYNE** :righton:

 

[Danos]

I thought it was a joke when Gibbs got suspended for this. It'll be a joke too if Hayne does, but the precedent has been set. So we'll see what happens..

 

[king_sirro]

Yeh, the precedent has been set, thats the problem. Actually, political correctness is the problem, and i hate political correctness, its un-australian. :slight_smile:

 

[RatedRKO]

he slid in to and the knees were bad should be cited but prob no suspension. Gibbs was an idiot burt had scored and gibbs comes over and knees him in the back deserved to be suspended for being a tool

And if u and Geo look carefully, i actually said Hayne should be suspended due to the fact Gibbs was, but its my belief neither should be.

I agree 100%, but the NRL have screwed themselves over now.