Eaney meaney miney NO

[tiger_tigers]

definately out of his depth .. lui not Far behind him .. didnt they want to win tonight ,,, were they happy to run 3rd ?…
they played the second half in second gear ......

 

[Tiger_heart]

Not sure about that, given the pressure I thought he played OK….Lui, on the other hand, :smiling_imp: :smiling_imp: :smiling_imp:

 

[innsaneink]

Great title.
They had poor games, it happens
Lui was spotted, Meeneys a rookie in a high pressure game in a crucial possy.

 

[travis_bickle]

Meaney is still a better option than Ryan at FB.

 

[king_sirro]

Bit harsh. Ive never been a fan of Meaney but i thought he was very good in the first half. In the 2nd he had a bad knock on from dummy half and he spilt a bomb. He also took a good bomb later which showed character. He runs harder and more effective than Ryan. I would give him another chance.

 

[tiger_tigers]

the rise from reggies to nrl is to big an ask for todays players ….second tier is 10 miles off the big time and it showed tonight ....sheensie must have thought so , because he punted meaney and put ryan back to fullack ....

 

[Balmain_Tiger]

cry me a river princess

 

[MacDougall]

Mataka was pretty crap too.

 

[Balmain_Bug]

Meaney > State Cup

Lost us the game tonight. Did some good things but it was too hard of a game for him to come into.

If McKinnon is no good I'd go Mitch Brown or Pritchard at fullback.

 

[prattenpark]

i thought he was ok considering he was only bought in a day or two ago. lui was ok too, but made a poor choice at the end with that kick - am a lui fan, but am afraid he needs another year to two to mature - can take the wrong option under pressure - but so did Farah when he made that break.
tonight was always gonna be a really tough assignment, injuries, short turn around. i thought they showed character to hang in the first half despite dropping so much ball and then come back into it in the 2nd.

No worse than third. i'm happy with that

 

[cunno]

He wasn't on his own in the mistakes department, it must have been tough to be blooded in this game, having said that it was an opportunity to take, I wouldn't write him off though.

 

[Adrian]

Has had 4 training sessions with the squad all year. One day this week

Bad miss on the bomb and bad knock on from dummy half but even Farah did that tonight

 

[Blake93]

PLEASE SHEENS! LEAVE BROWN AT FULLBACK!

 

[Geo]

Meaney State Cup

Lost us the game tonight. Did some good things but it was too hard of a game for him to come into.

If McKinnon is no good I'd go Mitch Brown or Pritchard at fullback.

Rubbish…..

the game was lost on the back of poor completions in the first half....

and Anyone bagging Lui is simply has an agenda...

Brown was a great replacement for Lawry why would you move him...

 

[Muffstar]

Can excuse Meaney, but Lui and Dwyer were far worse.

 

[alistair]

Yep - Brown looks by far the best option, even if all other players were fit frankly, including McKinnon.

 

[king_sirro]

Meaney State Cup

Lost us the game tonight. Did some good things but it was too hard of a game for him to come into.

If McKinnon is no good I'd go Mitch Brown or Pritchard at fullback.

How did Meaney cost us the game?

Farah started the rot with a terrible knockon, then Dywer dropped 3 balls in a row. Beau didnt number up and let Gorden score. Robbie kicked on the first tackle when we had them on the rack….............so.............tell me how Meaney cost us the win over these guys? And i dont even like Meaney

 

[Balmain_Tiger]

scapegoat for rd 26….

 

[Adrian]

Luis defence was rubbish Geo.

Dwyer should have been yanked far earlier

 

[Tiger_heart]

Meaney State Cup

Lost us the game tonight. Did some good things but it was too hard of a game for him to come into.

If McKinnon is no good I'd go Mitch Brown or Pritchard at fullback.

Rubbish…..

the game was lost on the back of poor completions in the first half....

Anyone bagging Lui is simply has an agenda...

I think Lui for as long as he is in the team will always divide opinions…