Finals week 1, 2025 discussion

[Tiger_Yoshi]

That game reminded me of the infamous Tigers loss versus the Roosters in 2010… maybe an even worse loss today …

The Raiders made some terrible errors to always make the Broncos think they were still in it …when up 28-12 and a man advantage should have been curtains …

I wonder if we get those two calls the Broncos got …the penalty for the field goal charge down and the overturn of the final try … I doubt it …

Gut wrenching loss that was in 2010

 

[Merlot]

Should have Just put it under the locks feet

im still disappointed

 

[Halbrowne61]

Walsh coming back on and making it all up to his teammates in that enormous 15-20 minutes was unreal.

Took the piss and drank it.

Yes, he’s a man reborn on the gold ! I believe Arabs do it everyday ( not drink toilet water but drink their own wee).

 

[Halbrowne61]

Agreed. No salary cap after Ivan, then having to get approval from Pascoe is one hell if an anvil.

Onya Madge, you’ve proved yourself to me, hamstrung by poor leadership at the top.

 

[Tom Shines]

im still disappointed

Gut wrenching loss that was in 2010

Yes it was a terrible loss …like the 1989 grand final and even the Warriors semi in 2011… all three should have been won by the Tigers …

I don’t think they would have won the premiership in 2011 though

 

[innsaneink]

Raiders home

Kiss of death haha

 

[Merlot]

Yes, he’s a man reborn on the gold ! I believe Arabs do it everyday ( not drink toilet water but drink their own wee).

they used to bathe WW1 wounds , in pregnant womans wizz ,

 

[mtd#2]

How many times have NSW won a Game 3 in Brisbane? How many times has NZL beaten Australia in any kind of tournament in the last 15 years? And isn’t the Broncos squad pretty much the same as the one from last year that came 12?

LOL try harder next time and put some actual thought into it.

There's nothing to think about? I made a statement about the quality of team he was coaching. You referenced a state of origin side and a national side - then compared it to the cellar dweller tigers..

Madge is great when he has the cattle...but he isn't a coach who can rebuild a team who isn't travelling so well.. tigers being the case in point..

Keep fighting that good fight. Batman forever

 

[mtd#2]

When do tickets for next week's games come on sale, anyone?

 

[oldschooltiger]

Great comparison...the tigers team he had vs nsw, NZ and broncos.. lol

The Broncos should be top 4 with the squad he has. Madge is a good coach if he has rep players. Madge is no good trying to turn a club around.

 

[Merlot]

Yes it was a terrible loss …like the 1989 grand final and even the Warriors semi in 2011… all three should have been won by the Tigers …

I don’t think they would have won the premiership in 2011 though

Club was building , it all fell away with lack of funds , and the board not listening to Sheens on how to build a club,

 

[tig_prmz]

Wow....good memory I vaguely recall that...not sure what game it was

I think it was disallowed because Benji punched Pearce while playing the ball

 

[GNR4LIFE]

I don’t dislike the Raiders, and if they come back and win it from here, it wouldn’t bother me. However. I’ve grown a bit of sick seeing Ricky carry on like a wanker on the sideline, every time they win this year. So it’s good to see him walk off a loser today. They have a right to feel shattered, but the two calls were a hundred per cent correct. Idk how you pick yourself up from that and against an in form side like the Sharks. They are in that game next week, up to their eye balls.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Will be interesting to see if the Broncos have any issues when the charges come out tomorrow. Carrigan and Walsh. Walsh was put on report, but I’d be surprised if they don’t look at the head butt. They need week off though. Haas was struggling most of the game, and Reynolds gets another week.

 

[Tom Shines]

I think we are heading for Penrith v Melbourne again …although both are weaker than last year …

 

[Merlot]

its more undecided than it normally is

 

[happy_tiger]

Will the NRL act on Walsh giving the crowd the bird when sent to the sin bin .....dumb question Happy

 

[Tucker]

Will the NRL act on Walsh giving the crowd the bird when sent to the sin bin .....dumb question Happy

I was thinking more about the headbutt and the shoulder to the face from Carrigan.

 

[Moh]

Will the NRL act on Walsh giving the crowd the bird when sent to the sin bin .....dumb question Happy

Jazz Tevaga did similar, to RTS instead of the crowd. Pretty sure that got no noise. Much different?

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Will the NRL act on Walsh giving the crowd the bird when sent to the sin bin .....dumb question Happy

He could be looking at 3-4 weeks. It’s striking.