Galloway needs to be moved along

[LaT]

Believe it or not Mckendry is on big dollars, he is one of the players Gus identified as taking up a huge slice of the cap. Almost guaranteed to be on much more then $300k.

Anyone who thinks Jason King, Bromwich, Merrin, Mannah, JWH are better props than Galloway are kidding themselves. Some others on that list might be line/judgement calls, some play different roles like impact/attack over workhorses (Tolman)

 

[bigsiro]

One of our better defenders. Moving into the Skando-like status so he should not be going anywhere.

I also kinda like the cult status he has. But just like Skando, Keith can be two dimensional. (IMO Keith is a better prop than Skando was).

Unless there is a much better option I wouldn't even think about dropping him.

 

[Justo]

Hahahaha. Cant believe this thread is into its 4th page.

Suggest those who dont like him drop him from your super coach side. Cos big Keiffy aint/shouldnt be going anywhere. Week in week out he does his job. More than we can say about a lot of other players. Maybe he gets injured because he's carrying a lot of the other players.

On a side note. But still talking forwards, we should never have let Fifita go. What a season he's started off having!!

 

[supercoach]

Hahahaha. Cant believe this thread is into its 4th page.

Suggest those who dont like him drop him from your super coach side. Cos big Keiffy aint/shouldnt be going anywhere. Week in week out he does his job. More than we can say about a lot of other players. Maybe he gets injured because he's carrying a lot of the other players.

On a side note. But still talking forwards, we should never have let Fifita go. What a season he's started off having!!

We didnt let him go–SHEENS let him go, just one of many hair brain calls the super coach made

 

[simonthetiger]

I'dlove Fifita back….heis gonna be awesome.

Stupid decision to shunt him.

 

[Frank_the_tank]

Wasnt the only dumb thing sheenius did.

 

[bonstonker]

what a disaster 2011 was.
blowing the semis
releasing gibbs and fifita
losing dwyer to injury
losing lui because of his stupidity
payten retiring
re-signing sheens
signing blair
taking back moltzen.

did i miss something.
where is cher when you need her.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

what a disaster 2011 was.
blowing the semis
releasing gibbs and fifita
losing dwyer to injury
losing lui because of his stupidity
payten retiring
re-signing sheens
signing blair
taking back moltzen.

**did i miss something.**
where is cher when you need her.

Lawrence's injury
Tuqiri losing his mojo for good
Benji being run down by a backrower

 

[LaT]

what a disaster 2011 was.
blowing the semis
releasing gibbs and fifita
losing dwyer to injury
losing lui because of his stupidity
payten retiring
re-signing sheens
signing blair
taking back moltzen.

**did i miss something.**
where is cher when you need her.

Yeah, Lawrence dislocated his hip and Lote began his downward spiral/injury list.

 

[Hbom]

Fifita is looking good, but remember when it was time to keep him the choice was to double his pay and most likely loose Woods and/or Groat. I think it was a fair call. Fifita could have gone either way become great or gone the way of Daine Laurie.

 

[bonstonker]

Fifita is looking good, but remember when it was time to keep him the choice was to double his pay and most likely loose Woods and/or Groat. I think it was a fair call. Fifita could have gone either way become great or gone the way of Daine Laurie.

we had already announced the extension of both woods and fifita.
sheens wanted to move gibbs to the sharks and they said give us fifita as well.
and before you know it,for the first time in wests tigers history we had quality depth at prop and we threw it away.

 

[tigerbenji]

Yep Sheens cost us dearly there with Gibbs & Fifita going to the Sharks.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Fifita is looking good, but remember when it was time to keep him the choice was to double his pay and most likely loose Woods and/or Groat. I think it was a fair call. Fifita could have gone either way become great or gone the way of Daine Laurie.

At the end of the day Sheens decided to let a guy with an x-factor over a guy who has yet to prove anything at fg level. I know i've been hard on Groat and everyone uses the excuse that he came into grade under difficult circumstances, but so has Buchanan and he's has looked 10 times the player Groat ever has

 

[Black_n_White]

Gibbs gave away too many penalties, the guy is a potato.

 

[simonthetiger]

Gibbs gave away too many penalties, the guy is a potato.

Agreed 2005-09,but he got his act together and is much better.

 

[Justo]

meh, you say potato I say potato.

Heighington played well on the weekend as well. So did Ryan. Actually all the tigers players seem to have blossumed after leaving the club. It's funny too, cos week by week, current team also seem to be playing better and happier. Are they all just climbing out of the Sheens hang over? New coaches and new desires. Looks that way to me.

 

[LaT]

Heighington playing well isn't surprising when he just joined a great forward pack, and has to face questions from Gallen when he doesn't aim up.

 

[red_dogg]

Top 10?? Really

Bromwich
Graham
Burgess
Tamou
Scott
Merrin
Woods
Tolman
Grant
Mannah
Hargreaves
King

That's 12 off the top of my head without giving much thought to it who are better then Galloway. Wonder how many of them are 300k a year players

u are a gee up…. i clearly dont see what u see in these front rowers compared to galloway.... he constantly gets over all these props wk in wk out and plays in a shite forward pack....

 

[red_dogg]

what a great idea….. lets get rid of the bloke who for the last 6-8 yrs at this club has played up front with either guys retiring or young kids getting blooded into first grade, he was setting up a good combination with gibbs till he was assholed out of the club and only by fluke has a 22 yr old kid next to him who has suprised everyone at the club with how good and ready he is. He has a backrow and bench who wouldnt get a starting spot in anyother NRL team And yet still constantly scores better stats then every frontrower he comes up again.
So Yeah lets get rid of him so he kills it at another club in a good pack, and buy a cheaper forward, so we can keep giving benji and farah all the cash they want....

 

[system]

Top 10?? Really

Bromwich
Graham
Burgess
Tamou
Scott
Merrin
Woods
Tolman
Grant
Mannah
Hargreaves
King

That's 12 off the top of my head without giving much thought to it who are better then Galloway. Wonder how many of them are 300k a year players

All bar Bromwch I'd say Gun

Agree

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_