My mum and dad came from the country, Batlow and moved to the big smoke, Enmore. They were mad Western Suburbs Magpie followers (don’t know why they didn’t follow Newtown). Took me to many games at Pratten Park and the SCG. I could rattle off all the names of all the Western Suburbs players (Kelly, Diamond, Parish, Pittard, Ferguson, McGuiness, Meany, Mowbray et al) much to the amusement of my uncles and aunties who were Souths followers. I started playing, or should I say pretending, at a very young age
In 1966 we moved to North Ryde, part of the Balmain district for junior football. Spent many years playing in the district, usually in the year above my age. We still followed the Western Suburbs Magpies and went to many games at Lidcombe etc. Favourite team to beat was of course Manly.
I loved the scrums, and the actual contest for the ball, although they could deteriorate into a heaving lump of flesh. Halves had to put the ball into the middle of the scrum, not the second row. Hookers were actually hookers and used their feet to hook the ball back and out to their side of the scrum. Forwards could push the other team off the ball. The play-the-ball was a one-on-one scrum, I liked how the marker was able to contest for the ball.
Game day was great, if you came early it was three games for the price of one. There was a clear path for players to make it to first grade and you could see their progression or regression. If you had a bad game in first grade you could be dropped to reserve grade the next week, but you would still be wearing the same colours and the team had the same name.
There was no wrestle. The Wrestle has killed the flow of the game and has also led to very serious injury (eg McKinnon). It should be outlawed, the refs have failed dismally here. The tackle type, ie dominate, that the refs call is just a load of bulldust.
There were fewer interruptions without the bunker and with one ref. You just took the bad refs calls with the good but the game flowed. The calls really havn't gotten any better, the blame has just shifted to the bunker with only the occasional benifit.
I absolutely hate the refs “coaching” the teams. If the players don’t know the rules or can’t follow them, then penalise them. They’ll soon learn. The refs should just shut up and ref the game.
The players over the years have managed to show increasing disrespect for the refs. I cannot think of any other sport, maybe others can, were the players can argue with the ref the way Rugby League players can and get away with it. It is something that has crept into the game and should be stamped out.
I also cannot think of any other sport, again others may, where the last person who touches the ball before it goes out of play is not called as the team who last touched the ball. If you don’t "play at the ball" in Rugby League, which is very subjective I must say, you are deamed as not touching the ball and the other team is punished. Huh? That’s a dumb rule.
I miss the punch ups. The b***h slapping that is allowed now is laughable. Bring back the Biff. Some of the things players get away with today would be stopped in its tracks by a good left hook by an enforcer aka Noel Kelly style.
This has sort of turned out to be what I hate post so I’ll stop. But I do miss the flow of the game, it is now very stop-start and heading towards NFL territory.
@mike said:
Your posts are always well thought out and composed.
From memory I haven't noticed you rubbishing anyone, even though you may be in complete disagreement with their view.
Well now, I am in complete disagreement with your view re
"I miss the punch-ups" and "bring back the biff".
I doubt very much that you really do want to see violence in the form of punch ups and biffo reintroduced to our game.
I feel, there is enough violence in our game as it is now, and in the world generally without wanting more violence.
Women fighting in the isle for toilet paper in Woolies for goodness sake.
With all the work that has gone into controlling violence from parents on the sideline at young peoples matches at suburban grounds, bringing back the biff would be setting a very bad example for the dumb cluck parents of those young kids.
Aren't we supposed to grow up to be decent people due to the
good and caring examples our parents taught us?