Harrigan schools refs on obstruction

krissy

Well-known member
Harrigan schools refs on obstruction

By James MacSmith

21:25 AEST Mon Aug 20 2012

Referees coach Bill Harrigan has given NRL match officials a crash course in the workings of the obstruction rule after admitting to a number of crucial refereeing blunders on the weekend.

After a review of round 24, Harrigan said on Monday that video referee Sean Hampstead's highly controversial decision to award Canterbury's Johnathan Wright a 74th minute try against Wests Tigers was wrong because of illegal use of a decoy runner.

"It shouldn't have (been awarded), we made a mistake there, got it wrong," Harrigan said.

"But I would like to say from the word go that you can run around your own player in some instance on a football field but in this instance it was wrong."

In an official video posted on the NRL website Harrigan attempted to clarify to fans, players and coaches alike how the obstruction rule will be policed in the final two rounds of the premiership and during the finals series.

Harrigan said he had called an emergency meeting of his entire refereeing squad in an attempt to ensure refereeing controversy does not overshadow the NRL's key end of season games.

"I'm not happy that I have to come out at this end of the season and admit that we have made mistakes," Harrigan told NRL.com

"Today I have had all the referees and the video referees sit down and we have gone through a lot of our obstruction calls.

"We have worked hard to get clarity in what we are doing so there will be no confusion, when we go into round 25 and 26 and then on into the semi-finals, between the referees and video referees.

"We all know what we are doing, that was the objective of today, to make sure we do the work so that when we walked out of that room today we all knew exactly where we all stood when it came to block runners and obstruction plays and that we go out there and we try to get it right."

Harrigan maintained his referees had made the correct decision on the weekend's other main point of contention regarding obstruction - a 59th minute try to Gold Coast's Steve Michaels in their win over Parramatta.

"That was given a try, that was correct," Harrigan said.

However the former grand final whistleblower did admit to another error - accepting that video referee Paul Simpkins' decision to award a 37th minute four-pointer to Melbourne's Sisa Waqa in the Storm's defeat of Brisbane was the incorrect call because the winger had knocked the ball on.

"Unfortunately we got that one wrong as well," Harrigan said.
 
This shld of been done a long time ago what good does tht do for us now the damage has already been done!!
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
 
Refs on the field should be given some leeway, but there are no excuses for errors by a video ref.
Cost us the game and also Farah's injury.
 
I reckon in circumstances like this when they so obviously got it wrong, have admitted it was a wrong call and that it changed the outcome of the game compensation should be given to the team that was wronged, 2 competition points IMHO.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
 
@ambostu said:
I reckon in circumstances like this when they so obviously got it wrong, have admitted it was a wrong call and that it changed the outcome of the game compensation should be given to the team that was wronged, 2 competition points IMHO.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

When this happens someone pinch me, I'll be dreaming
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
 
STOP BLOODY INTERPRETING IT OVER AND OVER AND OVER AND OVER AND OVER AND OVER AND OVER AGAIN .

how hard is this.. dont run around your own player, and if you do.. dont take advatage of it. END OF STORY.
 
Teams can be docked 2 point for having an extra player on the field (regardless of involvement) yet a incorrect ref decision that costs the team the game and get no compensation. Go figure.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
 
If he had sorted this out during the SOO and admited they got it wrong then we would not be in this position now.
 
Too little too late Bill. Your refereese probably cost us the season. You see Bill if your refereese knew the rules before last week we win the game in normal time get the two points and Farah doesnt get a broken hand as there is no extra time. An absolutly catastrophic blunder as far as our season goes. I keep hearing how one day a poor descision will cost someone a grand final. Well bill never mind grand finals your blokes incompetance may have just cost our blokes a shot at the finals and thats worse in my view.
 
@tig_prmz said:
STOP BLOODY INTERPRETING IT OVER AND OVER AND OVER AND OVER AND OVER AND OVER AND OVER AGAIN .

how hard is this.. dont run around your own player, and if you do.. dont take advatage of it. END OF STORY.

Thats it exactly… the refs have made the rule too damn complicated that now even they don't know whats going on.
Bring it back to the old shepard rule & everyone will be sweet as nut!
 
Can you guys stop with these posts please it just kills me it happened and it is time to get over it and focus on this weeks game, we are not getting the two points or farah back.
 
Time for some separation of powers and for referees to stop making the rules and only apply them…
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top