Has Benji overtaken Robbie?

[tigergirlz]

Cheers Paris - well said

 

[TIGER]

Gee its amazing how excited people get over 1 pass, i mean he had a average game at best. Imagine if he was the one who put the kick in for Ellis to score. He'd be front page news and this forum would erupt.
And if you watch the play again he had no option to pass anywhere else because Williams had rushed out of the line to take the deep runner and made the decision for him which could of very well been pulled up for a forward pass, and if so i wonder if this tread would exist?
I can't believe all this best player in the game talk, he had his best season last year i agree but we didn't make the semis and most of his good games were at the back end of the season when we where required to win every game and he had no real pressure on him or the team.
In saying all this he is making less errors and throwing less wild passes but I'd like to see him be get his hands on the ball more and take on the defense.

 

[Blake93]

Gee its amazing how excited people get over 1 pass, i mean he had a average game at best. Imagine if he was the one who put the kick in for Ellis to score. He'd be front page news and this forum would erupt.
And if you watch the play again he had no option to pass anywhere else because Williams had rushed out of the line to take the deep runner and made the decision for him which could of very well been pulled up for a forward pass, and if so i wonder if this tread would exist?
I can't believe all this best player in the game talk, he had his best season last year i agree but we didn't make the semis and most of his good games were at the back end of the season when we where required to win every game and he had no real pressure on him or the team.
In saying all this he is making less errors and throwing less wild passes but I'd like to see him be get his hands on the ball more and take on the defense.

agree 100%

 

[Balmain_Tiger]

he deserves co captaincy at least

 

[tiger05]

Gee its amazing how excited people get over 1 pass, i mean he had a average game at best. Imagine if he was the one who put the kick in for Ellis to score. He'd be front page news and this forum would erupt.
And if you watch the play again he had no option to pass anywhere else because Williams had rushed out of the line to take the deep runner and made the decision for him which could of very well been pulled up for a forward pass, and if so i wonder if this tread would exist?
I can't believe all this best player in the game talk, he had his best season last year i agree but we didn't make the semis and most of his good games were at the back end of the season when we where required to win every game and he had no real pressure on him or the team.
In saying all this he is making less errors and throwing less wild passes but I'd like to see him be get his hands on the ball more and take on the defense.

agree 100%

You two cannot be serious.

Isn't it great that they both play for the Wests Tigers!! Please don't turn it into a competition between them.

I'm guilty of this mainly because imo Robbie is simply not up to scratch atm and he hasn't been for a while whereas Marshall has been killing them. That plus posts like the ones above get me going.

Hopefully Robbie turns it around. He needs to focus on playing dummy half. If Benji keeps going like he has been and comes up with a couple of absolute blinders in the finals he probably deserves to be named the best player in the game. Firstly though he has to continue playing at the level he has been.

 

[Guest]

Benji has a points lead on Robbie so far this season…although it's early days yet. I just hope we see both players dominate this season, any Tigers success depends on it.

 

[towntiger]

Benji was our best today. Gee the bloke tries hard. Sure he might make a mistake but he puts in so much he is destined to make one every noe and then. Benji is clearly a better player than Robbie

 

[alien]

I think Benji has improved his defence and is now smarter in attack than what he used to be. I think Farah has stayed around the same. I think Farah was better but now Benji has caught up and is about the same. I'm glad we have both in our team. Just remember that even the best players in the world have bad games every now and then.

 

[Year_of_the_Tiger]

If the first two games of the season count, YES. Hope Robbie picks up soon.