Heamasi Makasini #303

I'm not a footy coach and never will be, but why would you drop the bloke back to reserves?

To work on a few unlucky mistakes?

He has had his fair share of embarrassing moments so far, but also his fair share of good things that don't stick in your memory quite so much.

For mine, the odd dropped ball and brain explosion under fatigue and pressure are the short-term cost you pay for putting a young fella in who is barely out of school but has a lot of upside.

It's different to someone like Skelton who is nearly 28 years old and should have brain-farts mostly ironed out of his game.
Because the week to week grind can be enormous on young developing players
Load management and take the pressure off him...give him.a.few weeks.with no.pressure at all in reggies...like annual leave, come back refreshed
 
A player should always be expecting the ball. If he wasnt expecting it, then thats a Makasini problem, not a Bula one.

Throwing a pass a metre before the line is generally when the best opportunities present themselves if the runner is in the correct spot.

It wasnt a hospital pass. Therefore, the blame sits with Makasini; he should have caught it.
Was ut a meter off their line or our line
No ones explained this howler to me...but i agree you should always expect the ball...or expect the unexpected
 
Was ut a meter off their line or our line
No ones explained this howler to me...but i agree you should always expect the ball...or expect the unexpected
It was a kick return Ink.

Bula looked very ginger when he received the ball but instead of passing to Makasini right away he ran like he was going to make the return himself, then passed to Makasini a couple of metres before the kick chase line.

Both players at fault really
 
Agreed.

Makasini had to be dropped. Benji needed to be consistent and has been. Well done to him.


I am not to worried about the dropped ball that's a mental thing I was more worried about being caught out of position a few times


For a young kid he's doing amazing I just think it's concentration for the full 80 minutes give him a rest let him relax his body and mind then pump him again for a few weeks then give him another rest buid him up make him stronger for a successful career not just burn him out in a season or two
 
A player should always be expecting the ball. If he wasnt expecting it, then thats a Makasini problem, not a Bula one.

Throwing a pass a metre before the line is generally when the best opportunities present themselves if the runner is in the correct spot.

It wasnt a hospital pass. Therefore, the blame sits with Makasini; he should have caught it.
I have to disagree I’m afraid. If Bula wasn’t worried about his shoulder he doesn’t throw the pass. He was clearly avoiding contact. There was nothing on. To my observation Makasini was moving into position to take the first dummy half run just like had happened after every other kick. Sure you could say he should have still caught it and after the week before he should expect ridiculous passes to be thrown at him but Bula isn’t innocent here IMO.
 
Makasini had a good stint in first grade as an 18 year old. He will be back and firing. Has a lot to work on but has all the tools. It’s the right decision didn’t think Benji would make it tbh. Correct call.
 
It was a kick return Ink.

Bula looked very ginger when he received the ball but instead of passing to Makasini right away he ran like he was going to make the return himself, then passed to Makasini a couple of metres before the kick chase line.

Both players at fault really
Thanks BD
 
I have to disagree I’m afraid. If Bula wasn’t worried about his shoulder he doesn’t throw the pass. He was clearly avoiding contact. There was nothing on. To my observation Makasini was moving into position to take the first dummy half run just like had happened after every other kick. Sure you could say he should have still caught it and after the week before he should expect ridiculous passes to be thrown at him but Bula isn’t innocent here IMO.
There was potentially something on.
Excuse the drawing but red line represents bulas run. The white circles are the broncos defenders and the yellow circle is taylan may. If you watch this passage of play, there is a chance of makasini using his body weight to knock over mariner and create some space down that left side for taylan may who is jogging back on side.


And the other photo - there is no excuse for not catching that ball. They werent rushing up to put a hit on him.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20260421_230722_Gallery.jpg
    Screenshot_20260421_230722_Gallery.jpg
    270 KB · Views: 7
  • Screenshot_20260421_231129_Gallery.jpg
    Screenshot_20260421_231129_Gallery.jpg
    222.5 KB · Views: 7
Definitely should've been dropped, but he was also definitely deserving of his spot in round 1.

Preseason wasn't that long ago.

He killed it: So much so everyone was saying give him rookie of the year already.

He's going to be a very, very good player.

I think it seems he was given a lot of grace to start playing well, but I also think a young kid with his clear potential should get a couple more games to try to click.

Right decision, right time, but did earn his spot.
 
It wasnt just the dropped balls. We lost momentum when he tapped the ball off the mark for the set restart.

 I reckon he was simply overwhelmed toward the end... playing last years premiers with the game on the line, up against staggs and mariner...

He'll bounce back.
 
It wasnt just the dropped balls. We lost momentum when he tapped the ball off the mark for the set restart.

 I reckon he was simply overwhelmed toward the end... playing last years premiers with the game on the line, up against staggs and mariner...

He'll bounce back.

I think he was mentally fatigued rather than overwhelmed. You could see it in his runs. He just didn’t go with aggression as well.
The kid will be back and has a huge future.
 

Members online

Back
Top