Heino try

[Tiger_heart]

It probably doesn't matter in the context of the outcome but what do people feel, it looked like a try to me, despite the opinion of the "expert" commentators on 9…

 

[stryker]

Hard one..I thought it was a knock on but you really couldnt prove it.

 

[Snowy]

It looked like a try to me he didn't seem to touch the ball. But the experts….on nine seemed to think he did. Still devo we should have won that game!!!!!!

 

[Defiant]

I couldnt see an actual touch from heigno,

 

[stryker]

I wouldnt go off what the commentators said….it seemed they all had good money on the Titans

 

[angeman]

as it is a QLD live game the commentators have to love the queensland team. can't stand it.

 

[tiger_tigers]

i thought it was a try simply by rhinos reaction…but when these dopes slow thw play down to 100th of a milisecond you can find an argument for every try ....case in point was their first try . in slo mo i could see two knock ons ..... the pink ladies should have more of a go and call it as they see it ... yeah sure theyll still get some wrong ,, but thats the nature of rugby league ......

 

[innsaneink]

I initially thought heighno knocked the bal down, the more replays I watched though changed my opinion.

I wouldnt go off what the commentators said….it seemed they all had good money on the Titans

Haha yeh it sounded that way to me too

 

[barra]

Try. Thought if anything Heighno's hand brushed the defender's hand not the ball.

 

[mike]

Try. Thought if anything Heighno's hand brushed the defender's hand not the ball.

Me too

 

[happy_tiger]

Depended what angle you looked at The front on you thought no try but the side on looked like a try Benefit of the doubt was a good call

 

[NEDKELLY]

Try from my Recliner Lounge Chair! After a squillion replays I could NOT see a Heighnington fingernail touch the footy! I agree that the commentators had the Titans going for some dosh.
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
1

 

[Juro]

At first glance, I thought no try, but on seeing the replay I didn't see anything conclusive that he knocked on. So a benefit of the doubt call was the way to go.

 

[benjibrotown]

No try.. Knocked on.

 

[Spartan117]

100% Legit

 

[kill_em_all_tigers]

No try.. Knocked on.

im curious what size & type of tv you watched it on?

The video ref tv's have recently been upgraded as it was shown that thier previously smaller tv's were making it difficult to see what really was happening compared with large flat screens.

Im sure the commentators are also watching replays on small screen's.

i thought it was nearly (95% in favour) conclusive evidence showing heino's hand hitting the titans hand while sitting nice & close to a big crystal clear flat screen.

I then couldn't believe Vossy' lack of understanding on the sunday roast why it was BOD.
Heino's hand was millimeters from the ball, maybe a hair on his hand touched it, maybe a long finger nail. However there was no clear evidence of this happening thererfore BOD Try.
They are so dumb sometimes.

 

[magpiecol]

Try.