I think the issue is Sheens

[Mighty_Tiger]

No, but I thought that this weekend when they showed the coaches box and Tim was standing in the back ground next to Robbie who was grinning like a Cheshire Cat, but Benji was all game face.
It looks like they are getting ready for asap take over from Benji.

It's been very very clear for a while now Benji is calling the shots on game day this and next season is basically for them to learn as much as they can hands off with Sheens supporting by doing the heavy media lifting taking the heat off them.

Sheens is managing a very very tough situation very well IMO.
Putting early seasons results aside the dynamics of our club at the best of times is dramatic whilst having to bring a rookie up to speed coaching wise is just next level. Have zero doubts the mental/physical effort would be extremely high whilst having to also build a brand new roster and bring kids onto the journey.

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

This week is the best example of the fact Wests Tigers coaches are fighting with both arms tied behind their back. When Benji came in Sheens said Benji was told that the club would not sign anyone he didn’t want for 2025. His first priority was to secure a better player in the halves with the much publicised pursuit of Munster, Moses, Pearce and even Johnson. Plan E was Josh Schuster which looks to have also failed (thank god). It’s in the news today that the club is even struggling with their plan F, Luke Brooks. You couldn’t make this stuff up. 😂

The man who shoots every coach down is Justin Pascoe, wish he would go close deals at Burger King or something.

I actually think Macca & Lee are the big issues here.

When Macca was here previously his recruitment sucked, if you annoyed him as a youngster you were punted despite how good you were, when he was at the Bulldogs they recruited even worse under his watch which is saying something.

Lee just has zero footy idea it's clear with his bursts that he is more focused on his profile than the actual club & has zero trust in those to do his job.

I'm hoping things to change over the next 6-12mths with Fulton leading the charge (he is a real recruitment operator) especially if results are changing. Hartigan was the real deal and was a scape goat of poor management here.

Regarding the recruit offers:

Munster was never coming, he was never leaving Storm.
Moses was never coming given how bad Brooks (his best mate) was copping it & how bad we started
Pearce was never coming mid season, why leave France & success to come last in Sydney
Johnson was never going to pack his family up again for 2yrs & then go back home again after COVID
Schuster was never a discussion, Manly weren't letting him go this year anyway.

Brooks, Sheens loves but reality is he has been absolutely hammered so why stay and be unhappy without clear support plan around him? His family LOVES the club and he is a Wests Tigers through and through but without support and with Api having a MO for 25 why stay.

It's interesting that our most high profile half in our clubs history who takes over the coaching reigns will struggle to have any halves on the books for 24 let alone 25 (who knows what happens to AD also).

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

I’ve listened to this three times but I’m not feeling well and my concentration levels are low right now. What exactly is Tim complaining about? Something to do with Luciano being offside?

Joffa try and Stef run away.
Ref boss said incorrect call was made on the Joffa try, didn't address the Stef run.

 

[bathursttiger1]

Sheen’s always said that he was going to play the long game, it takes time to get a new squad playing in sync.

 

[Yossarian]

Joffa try and Stef run away.
Ref boss said incorrect call was made on the Joffa try, didn't address the Stef run.

Thanks! I got the joffa thing, I’m not that crook! When was the Stef run? I’ll go and take another look.

 

[Fade.To.Black]

I’ve listened to this three times but I’m not feeling well and my concentration levels are low right now. What exactly is Tim complaining about? Something to do with Luciano being offside?

Yep, Leilua being offside on the kick for his try. Among other bad decisions.
He had a fair point.

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

Thanks! I got the joffa thing, I’m not that crook! When was the Stef run? I’ll go and take another look.

2nd half he ran about 50mtrs and it was called back.

 

[Yossarian]

Thanks MT! I think I recall now, started on our line got over halfway. I thought at the time it was a tough call.

 

[Bigscreentv]

I think Sheens still has a big say in the direction of the team though. Benji just coaches it.

 

[Snidest 0]

Anyone who really thinks Tim is not coaching this team and Benji is calling the shots are seriously delusional!!

Just go to a training session and see how hands on Tim is with the players as individuals (as he always has been)!!

Benji is learning the ins and outs of game-day coaching by running the sideline comms - but Tim is the overseer and primary tactician!