@the_patriot said in [If you could start Over](/post/1320714) said:
@strongee said in [If you could start Over](/post/1320713) said:
@the_patriot said in [If you could start Over](/post/1320610) said:
@strongee said in [If you could start Over](/post/1319789) said:
Look , I hate to break it to everyone , but this year is the first year where we didn’t just sign average players , who would compete for 20 of 24 games for a win loss of 11 and 13 . **What we did do , is sign a whole bunch of 19-21 year olds , and watch them nurture together . Most of those guys , you’re Lauries , AD and Simpkin of the world are in key positions . It is now a waiting game .** Really our season for real starts this week . Many of us knew we would lose both these games , not to the extent that we did , but hey , as long as we get rid of BJ , we should have at least a feeling of trust that we arnt going to bleed 30 points before we even get started. As for the rest , I dunno , it’s going to be a bumpy ride , and there is going to be some bodies left on the side of the ride as we drive along . BJ is the first , Brooks needs to fix his kicking game pronto , and some of the middles and edges need to start looking over thier shoulder , as we do have Simpkins and Blore to come in and take a couple of jobs .
**The team that played on Sunday will not be the one that finishes the season.**
Most rebuilds need a full tear down , then build up . I’m praying that won’t happen to us , but I’m no longer confident . But really our first test as to where we are is this week . We played 2 teams with years worth of continuity , and we got torched . It’s a bit of a bull crap draw , but what can you do . I would have preferred to ease into the season and build confidence , even if it is false .
Great post. Probably the best post of the week.
It really is a waiting game now. The recruitment has been very good. Exactly what was needed. As was fixing the junior pathways etc.
The foundation has been set but unfortunately it might be a case of two steps back one step forward for a little while.
The depth we have acquired is also very good.
The issue was always going to be the halves.
As for the OP's question if i could start over id have a young half back much more ready for NRL than Jock Madden. Thats all, the rest is ok.
The halfback issue , is an industry wide one . Canberra went to the UK, the roosters got lucky , and poached the sneaky glue guy to the Souths premiership , who got into a biff with the owner on a booze trip , Souths kept the other half of that equation and stuck him with a guy , who spent the first 26 years of his life floating in reserve grade purgatory, and Melbourne just manufactured one , like they did the time before that.
After that every single other team has huge question marks over the bloke wearing the number 7 , including manly . What’s DCE win record without a gun fullback ? Stewart before turbo .
I dont do the every club has issues thing.
If you want to make the 8 you need a good half or 5/8. Very rarely are there exceptions. Most teams in this comp have a quality half on their books.
We have a bottom 5 halfback and an unproven 5/8 who may provide some hope.
I completely disagree with that statement .
Penrith - Cleary . Serviceable half . He’s definitely not in the Thurston , Cronk Johns Class , but the clear number 1 half , which proves what I’m saying .
Canberra- Williams - Does a good job of steering the team around , but you rarely see him , so once again a step below the previous generation
Roosters- Keary- The most skill full half in the game .
Eels - Moses - a Cadbury chocolate , melts when the heat is on . But a very strong personality , not afraid to tell players like BJ they are fat and lazy.
Knights - Pearce - I watched him the last 2 weeks and honestly his kicking game was worse than brooks . He was bailed out by individual brilliance , by players like Safiti and Best .
Sharks - Townsend - he could play 5 games and you wouldn’t even know he was out there . Yet his team still wins , which I don’t know what that says .
Titans-Taylor/ Fogarty - ask a titans fan thier opinion of these guys. Fogarty is like bully Walters for us .
Warriors - Harris Tavita- I’m yet to see him really do anything . His kicking game sux , in the fact he looks like he can’t kick it 30m and kicks with the wrong foot . Once again bailed out by the elite talent around him.
Dragons - Hunt- seriously he’s on 1.2 mil and spent the better part of the last 2 years wearing the 9 . He’s not an elite half .
Cowboys - Morgan - you think we lack direction ? The cowboys are in a world of hurt with him.
Manly - DCE- what has he won , without turbo or Stewart playing with him ? I bet his win % is like 30 %. He’s a myth .
Dogs - Flanno- still a kid , but early signs are he could go the way of brooks , if they don’t surround him with quality and start winning , I can see his ego just being bruised beyond repair .
Brisbane - Croft - LOL this guy must have nude photos of Brisbanes GM, because how he’s in first grade is unbelievable.
Storm - Hughes - mate the storm are such a smart club , they decide to invest Around a bloke who will tell everyone to eat crap , and do what he says , rather than the guy who ticks all the right half boxes . Just a smart club .
Souths - Reynolds . Mr consistency , never lets you down . He might not have the extreme highs of other players , but I wish the parallel universe happened where he chose us over Souths , which was in play early in his career.
Tigers - Brooks - I just feel sorry for him . He looks like we messed him up in the head . I think I back him so strongly because I feel guilty that we , the tigers club , ruined a kid who has more potential than the lot of those guys above him . If he came up in the roosters jersey , he would be the player that we all thought he should be . Which is a huge indictment on our club .
By my count that’s 11 clubs with ??? All around their 7 . There’s a real lack of talent at the moment.
We just arnt developing them anymore . Or the structures these kids are taught are all wrong and ruin them .