tigermaniac
Well-known member
Name 4 players in no particular order of who should go.
Moltzen
Blair
Tuqiri
Ayshford
\
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
Moltzen
Blair
Tuqiri
Ayshford
\
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
If you were in charge of a clean out ........
- Thread starter tigermaniac
- Start date
If I was in chagre
Out
Ryan -Keeping Utai and Tuqiri for one yr with Nofoaluma and Koroibete to be our starting wingers in 2014/2013
Heghington - We already have a heap of backrowers and hieghington offers no bench impact
Ayshford - Was a glaring weakness in defence and dint offer much in attack
Humble - Iosefa is a better hooker, Moltzen a better reserve half and FB as is Sironen and Anansta
In
Kite - We were short in the front row more then any other area in 2012
Masoe - As above
A Centre - With lawrence starting centre and reddy and simona in NSW cup - we need another centre because Ayshford isnt up to it and costs too much to keep
In general I would do exactly what the club is doing as for your 4 above - Blair shouldnt go , Tuqirir will provide great guidance for the young wingers and only a 1 yr contract unlike Beua who would need 3 and would hold back our star juniors, Moltzen gives up depth all across the bacline - a utility back (can play FB, HB, FE, Centre) who was our top tryscorer and top linebreaks is a greaty reserve for any team at a lowish cost
Out
Ryan -Keeping Utai and Tuqiri for one yr with Nofoaluma and Koroibete to be our starting wingers in 2014/2013
Heghington - We already have a heap of backrowers and hieghington offers no bench impact
Ayshford - Was a glaring weakness in defence and dint offer much in attack
Humble - Iosefa is a better hooker, Moltzen a better reserve half and FB as is Sironen and Anansta
In
Kite - We were short in the front row more then any other area in 2012
Masoe - As above
A Centre - With lawrence starting centre and reddy and simona in NSW cup - we need another centre because Ayshford isnt up to it and costs too much to keep
In general I would do exactly what the club is doing as for your 4 above - Blair shouldnt go , Tuqirir will provide great guidance for the young wingers and only a 1 yr contract unlike Beua who would need 3 and would hold back our star juniors, Moltzen gives up depth all across the bacline - a utility back (can play FB, HB, FE, Centre) who was our top tryscorer and top linebreaks is a greaty reserve for any team at a lowish cost
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
Moltzen
Groat
Reddy
Lote
Groat
Reddy
Lote
Moltz ( although was top tryscorer top linebraker we can turn Tedesco into something more)
Lote ( have good wingers coming through aswell aswell as Beau being consistent if he was staying instead)
Humble (although is utile, what he offers is limited. Not needed)
Ayshford ( I like him, but is expensive, more loss than gain with the money we pay him and what else we could do with it)
Lote ( have good wingers coming through aswell aswell as Beau being consistent if he was staying instead)
Humble (although is utile, what he offers is limited. Not needed)
Ayshford ( I like him, but is expensive, more loss than gain with the money we pay him and what else we could do with it)
As much as id hate to say it theres not one player they have let go id have kept. i reckon they should punt ayshford, lots, utai, humble and moltz as well. Id keep blair he was ordinary but did we play him right, probably not, did he feel part of the boyz club or was partially isolated since they signed him and let gibbs and fafita go.
On side note id love to have gibbs back he was always the first one in to protect a bro
On side note id love to have gibbs back he was always the first one in to protect a bro
@GNR4LIFE said:
Too much pressure on a 20 year old prop these days to come in and be consistant 1st graders,it just doesnt always happens just cause it happens to someone else
though to answer the question its probley easier to say who i would keep and it would be Woods/KG/Sironen/Tedesco/Korobetie and Fulton the rest i couldnt care less if they go or stay
Tigersmurf
Well-known member
How do we know what Ayshford is on? I have no idea but how expensive could he be? $200K, is chicken feed in todays player market.
Same with Humble. Given his creativity I would have thought he was worth keeping. How much could he be on?
I am glad other people make these hard decisions. I look at the squad individually and I don't want to loose too many, but deep down I know they need to go.
Moors
Lote
Heighnington
Iosefa
Reddy
Moltzen
Take Moltzen our of the equation and the make up of the team looks a lot less complicated - although I don't hate Moltz like others on here I just don't think his skill set suit the positions we need to cover.
Same with Humble. Given his creativity I would have thought he was worth keeping. How much could he be on?
I am glad other people make these hard decisions. I look at the squad individually and I don't want to loose too many, but deep down I know they need to go.
Moors
Lote
Heighnington
Iosefa
Reddy
Moltzen
Take Moltzen our of the equation and the make up of the team looks a lot less complicated - although I don't hate Moltz like others on here I just don't think his skill set suit the positions we need to cover.
brett_empire
New member
Adam Blair
Lote
Adam Blair
Utai
Adam Blair
Iosefa
Adam Blair
Groat
I know a lot of you guys like Utai, yes he runs harder then anyone in our team, but he's getting old, is horrible under the high ball, isn't fast enough and has little skill. surely there are numerous better options to play wing in the lower grades ? give John Grant a run, or throw chisolm on the wing, something…
Wish we still had Mullaney and Ryan. A promising young back rower, local junior who looks to be more then capable in 1st grade, but we only found out once he went too Parra.
Lote
Adam Blair
Utai
Adam Blair
Iosefa
Adam Blair
Groat
I know a lot of you guys like Utai, yes he runs harder then anyone in our team, but he's getting old, is horrible under the high ball, isn't fast enough and has little skill. surely there are numerous better options to play wing in the lower grades ? give John Grant a run, or throw chisolm on the wing, something…
Wish we still had Mullaney and Ryan. A promising young back rower, local junior who looks to be more then capable in 1st grade, but we only found out once he went too Parra.
Glen_McWilliams
New member
I'd get rid of the bloke who refills the hand towels in the gents under the Latchem Robinson Stand. Always puts them in backwards so if you take one about 25 come tumbling out.
Tuiaki4life
New member
Out
Agree with Ryan and Heighnington. If Beau wasn't on te footy show we wouldn't give a shhh, Heighnington is a champion but will delay the progression of some 20's coming through.
Ayshford, Moltzen, Tuquiri, Humble, Reddy.
SHEENS & HUMPTY.
In
We can't axe everyone.
Benji and Robbie will flourish under a new coach, I just hope they stick around to find out?
After all the BS is done with we can come out the other side with a brand new spanker of a side.
I got for one am excited with the prospect of Tedesco and Sironen coming back. Koroibete to excel and Anasta will provide the cool head we've been missing.
Happy Days? lol
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
Agree with Ryan and Heighnington. If Beau wasn't on te footy show we wouldn't give a shhh, Heighnington is a champion but will delay the progression of some 20's coming through.
Ayshford, Moltzen, Tuquiri, Humble, Reddy.
SHEENS & HUMPTY.
In
We can't axe everyone.
Benji and Robbie will flourish under a new coach, I just hope they stick around to find out?
After all the BS is done with we can come out the other side with a brand new spanker of a side.
I got for one am excited with the prospect of Tedesco and Sironen coming back. Koroibete to excel and Anasta will provide the cool head we've been missing.
Happy Days? lol
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
tigerbenji
Well-known member
First off i like Beau & Heighno but one was told he wouldnt be signed after next year & decided to go, Beau had a three year contract to sign but got the dirts that his mate was going so he went. As i said they have given us plenty but they were the ones who decided to go so thanks for the memories boys. Two others i would let go are Humble & Reddy, thats my four.
Marshall_magic
New member
Out (along with who has been cut already)
Moltzen
Reddy
Ayshford
Heighington
Lote
\
\
I believe we are stuck with Blair, not worth paying half his contract for him to go elsewhere, and nobody will take him on unless we pay something in that vicinity. I'd also hold onto Humble as a depth option
shopping list
halfback: look for a cheaper option, a guy not in first grade on a 1 year deal, see how he goes
props: two of, 1 veteran who can provide some guidance to the youngsters and another who is mid 20s
centre: regular starter, may need to fork out a bit on this one, not a Jamie Lyon or a Josh Morris, but still need a decent player
centre/winger: again, probably look at a 1 year option here and you'd probably be more a depth player than a regular
team
1\. Tedesco
2\. Marika
3.
4\. Lawrence
5\. Utai
6\. Marshall
7\. halfback
8\. Woods
9\. Farah
10\. Galloway
11\. Fulton
12\. Blair
13\. Anasta
14\. Thompson
15\. Pettybourne
16\. Murdoch
17\. Prop
18\. Humble
19\. winger/centre
20\. Nofoaluma
21\. Miller
22\. Iosefa
23\. prop
24\. Buchannon
25\. Sironen
Moltzen
Reddy
Ayshford
Heighington
Lote
\
\
I believe we are stuck with Blair, not worth paying half his contract for him to go elsewhere, and nobody will take him on unless we pay something in that vicinity. I'd also hold onto Humble as a depth option
shopping list
halfback: look for a cheaper option, a guy not in first grade on a 1 year deal, see how he goes
props: two of, 1 veteran who can provide some guidance to the youngsters and another who is mid 20s
centre: regular starter, may need to fork out a bit on this one, not a Jamie Lyon or a Josh Morris, but still need a decent player
centre/winger: again, probably look at a 1 year option here and you'd probably be more a depth player than a regular
team
1\. Tedesco
2\. Marika
3.
4\. Lawrence
5\. Utai
6\. Marshall
7\. halfback
8\. Woods
9\. Farah
10\. Galloway
11\. Fulton
12\. Blair
13\. Anasta
14\. Thompson
15\. Pettybourne
16\. Murdoch
17\. Prop
18\. Humble
19\. winger/centre
20\. Nofoaluma
21\. Miller
22\. Iosefa
23\. prop
24\. Buchannon
25\. Sironen
@boonboon said:
Mate I like your thinking, Blair hasn't been used right so can't crucify him for doing what the coach ha asked!
Remember through the year sheens was saying he is doing exactly why he wants him to do!!!
But Moltzen has been a let down this season and in my opinion needs to be a bench utility! As he does not specialise in any pos
Iosefa has been quite impressive and wouldn't mind him been given a bit more fg game time!
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
happy_tiger
Well-known member
@phil1986 said:
Bit harsh on Royce
Only just got back and he needs time to train all off season to get it right
He doesn't need all this pressure and what happens if he leaves again :unamused:
