Ironic

Eddie

New member
One of our wingers from this season was helping win the game for the opposition last night (Koro)

Whilst we fielded a back rower on the wing, and a 34 year old with a dodgy hammy.

Only at this club.
 
maybe you should tell WT staff…

Players get injured....

therefore depth is important......

Dont sell players mid season just to be nice guys.
 
Koro was in our top 25, releasing him no doubt was partly driven by the need to create room because of injuries early in the season.

We then go on to injure more and more of our backs. Unfortunate, but explainable.
 
i think it is inexcusable when we were in contention for the top 8

Potter conceeded it was to give him a better opportunity. did not mention anything about cap.

I think it is very poor and not for the first time it has bitten us.

Not saying Koro makes all the diff, however boy oh boy he would be our best outside back available right now
 
@Eddie said:
i think it is inexcusable when we were in contention for the top 8

Potter conceeded it was to give him a better opportunity. did not mention anything about cap.

I think it is very poor and not for the first time it has bitten us.

Not saying Koro makes all the diff, however boy oh boy he would be our best outside back available right now

If we were in contention for the 8, wouldn't it make sense in the face of injuries to release an outside back (at a time when we had enough) to bring in a player for a position we were struggling to cover?

It seems obvious that if we have blown through our 2nd tier cap already by this point, then by mid season it was probably already on the mind of the coaches. You have to remember that you can't release a player to another club after June 30th deadline.

As bad of a club as we are in terms of contracts and what not, it really does take a huge jump to believe that even we would simply release a player based purely on a good karma reward.
 
Put any of our blokes in a great team and most of their shortcoming can be covered for….in a poor team theyre just highlited and exposed

Clubs dont like to admit theyre at cap limit.....no need to generate bad news when we have it by the bucketload already
 
@innsaneink said:
Put any of our blokes in a great team and most of their shortcoming can be covered for….in a poor team theyre just highlited and exposed

This is very true but I think I take a different lesson to this from you. Dont sell Koro, fix our structure.

Whilst our defensive structure remains poor it doesnt matter who you have on the edges we will struggle.

For example, over the last few years we are the only team that repeatedly fails to protect our wingers on bombs. Every other team has protected this and we give the other team a saloon passage.

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
Agree ST
Dont get me wrong, I was hoping they would work in his deficiencies….anyone could see he was worth more than chucking in the too hard basket.

There must be more to it....I wonder if Lote leaving had any affect in this, he goes to another club with another Fijian winger (whos leaving them next year) Cap issues too I suspect but geez you start at the bottom when making room.
 
@LaT said:
@Eddie said:
i think it is inexcusable when we were in contention for the top 8

Potter conceeded it was to give him a better opportunity. did not mention anything about cap.

I think it is very poor and not for the first time it has bitten us.

Not saying Koro makes all the diff, however boy oh boy he would be our best outside back available right now

If we were in contention for the 8, wouldn't it make sense in the face of injuries to release an outside back (at a time when we had enough) to bring in a player for a position we were struggling to cover?

It seems obvious that if we have blown through our 2nd tier cap already by this point, then by mid season it was probably already on the mind of the coaches. You have to remember that you can't release a player to another club after June 30th deadline.

As bad of a club as we are in terms of contracts and what not, it really does take a huge jump to believe that even we would simply release a player based purely on a good karma reward.

Your argument makes no sense. If it were correct, who is the player who has been brought in to cover a position we were struggling in?

I dont claim to know the reason he was released, but I would think it is more likely linked to retaining Tedesco than anything else.
 
@Eddie said:
i think it is inexcusable when we were in contention for the top 8

Potter conceeded it was to give him a better opportunity. did not mention anything about cap.

I think it is very poor and not for the first time it has bitten us.

Not saying Koro makes all the diff, however boy oh boy he would be our best outside back available right now

Mayer mentioned the cap.

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
It was funny when he threw a pass from left to right and looked a bit awkward, and someone in the crowd near me shouted out "That's why we got rid of you, Koro! 'Cause you can't pass!" and then ten seconds later, Smith shifted the attack back to Koro's wing and he scored, LOL.
 
Cap problems are rubbish. The club caused cap problems by purchasing Halatau and Lulia - both players the club simply didnt need. Dene, as much I love the bloke simply doesnt offer anything a young backrower offers. Lulia has all Koro's flaws without his upside. Our club is run by idiots.

Hindisght is a rubbish excuse too. The decision was criticised at the time.

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
Halatau, Richards and Lulia were bought in as short term solutions why the kids came through, in my mind a sensible strategy.
They didn't want to spend big dollars, but wanted experience.
 
@Goose said:
Halatau, Richards and Lulia were bought in as short term solutions why the kids came through, in my mind a sensible strategy.
They didn't want to spend big dollars, but wanted experience.

So the strategy to develop kids has resulted in one of our most talented kids leaving. Yes very sensible strategy.

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
Storm to Koro ..we will pay you more and you play NRL each week …
Tigers to Koro we know your not getting much but you might get 4 to 6 games this season then wait another season until Richards retires then if we have nothing better you get the start in 2016.
Koro to Tigers get stuffed see ya .....yes the club is brain dead ! No the club did the right thing unfortunately he could of been used a bit more well fellas that's life.
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top