Joel Reddy

@Curaeus said:
If the rumours turn out to be true that Ivan Cleary has already done a deal with the Warriors, I would imagine the struggling team the Mole is on about, would be us!
Click to expand...

Warriors haven't signed Cleary, he wants to go there but his family doesn't.
 
I try to remain positive about all WT signings, but Reddy would be a terrible decision unless he's 2nd tier. I'd rather Lovett in the centres. No offence to Reddy who is a tryer, but he'd have to be the slowest outside back in the comp.
 
@goldcoast tiger said:
I was going to say "they're kidding" , but on second thought, it's probably just what we should expect
We can't be too badly off for money if we can waste it on him.
Click to expand...

With the money they wasted on Ballin and Reddy they could of had a go at getting Dylan Walker,
but no they prefer to waste money on burnt out has beens.
No wonder the club is at the bottom of the ladder.
 
@bathursttiger said:
@goldcoast tiger said:
I was going to say "they're kidding" , but on second thought, it's probably just what we should expect
We can't be too badly off for money if we can waste it on him.

With the money they wasted on Ballin and Reddy they could of had a go at getting Dylan Walker,
but no they prefer to waste money on burnt out has beens.
No wonder the club is at the bottom of the ladder.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

They barely paid a cent for Ballin, and Reddy would be on close to minimum. Yeah, that's a lot of money to throw at Walker.
 
i would take milone any day over reddy, the guy has been terrible for 4 years

But the Son of Rocket is a Premiership winning player from the very recent past, I thought we were to signing up Bryson Goodwin at one stage, the club may as well go after Lote Tuquiri as well, another player who left us to win a comp, BTW another of our former players to win a Premiership at $ouff$ is unsigned for next year, but of course we have plenty of depth in the back row don't we!.
 
@GoldXR50Leroy said:
i would take milone any day over reddy, the guy has been terrible for 4 years
Click to expand...

But the Son of Rocket is a Premiership winning player from the very recent past, I thought we were to signing up Bryson Goodwin at one stage, the club may as well go after Lote Tuquiri as well, another player who left us to win a comp, BTW another of our former players to win a Premiership at $ouff$ is unsigned for next year, but of course we have plenty of depth in the back row don't we!.

Ben Teo?
 
@Milky said:
@GoldXR50Leroy said:
i would take milone any day over reddy, the guy has been terrible for 4 years

But the Son of Rocket is a Premiership winning player from the very recent past, I thought we were to signing up Bryson Goodwin at one stage, the club may as well go after Lote Tuquiri as well, another player who left us to win a comp, BTW another of our former players to win a Premiership at $ouff$ is unsigned for next year, but of course we have plenty of depth in the back row don't we!.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Ben Teo?

Ben Te'o is correct young man, Uncle Rusty over at $ouff$ wanted him but can't possibly squeeze him under the $alary cap now that they've signed the 2014 Churchill Medal Winner!.
 
@Flippedy said:
Don't need him, Ado-Carr is gonna be a star! You heard it here first :sunglasses:
Click to expand...

I second that motion. Carr is a gun.
We have Nofo, Hunt, Carr, Naqama that can cover wing.
We need 2 front rowers and a rep level back rower.

Problem is we are like the fat kid no one wants to play on our team
 
Reddy could be our answer.

Worth a million to the Tigers I think?

But would he have a million to pay us to put him in the team.

Time to take up lawn bowls Joel.
 
Rather than going backwards signing Reddy, we should try for Peter Hiku, who looks like being moved on now Walker is going to Manly. I really rate this guy - maybe Ballin, Chee Kam and Littlejohn can have a word in his ear :mrgreen:
 
I don't remember Reddy being bad for us. I remember him being quite good.

He has sucked hard at Souths though. So it's a no from me.

We have pretty good depth in the outside backs now anyways. Loads of signings there in Hunt, Ado-Carr, Rankin + existing depth in Rowe, Milone, Hoeter, Seve, Heleta, Karwhin et al.

Would be a mystifying signing.
 
@GNR4LIFE said:
@bathursttiger said:
@goldcoast tiger said:
I was going to say "they're kidding" , but on second thought, it's probably just what we should expect
We can't be too badly off for money if we can waste it on him.

With the money they wasted on Ballin and Reddy they could of had a go at getting Dylan Walker,
but no they prefer to waste money on burnt out has beens.
No wonder the club is at the bottom of the ladder.

They barely paid a cent for Ballin, and Reddy would be on close to minimum. Yeah, that's a lot of money to throw at Walker.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

What was Ballins contract GNR?
 
Reddy can shine in a really strong team…....we are not that type of team though.......we should stick with our young guys.....I would not bother with Reddy at any price.
 
lol if he was signed it'd be because of his professionalism, not his ability. Please, calm down if you're worried about cost or his position. He'd be on peanuts and might crack the team during SOO IF we had injuries.

We have the youngest team in the comp and these kids need mentors. Considering he's played 3-4 years longer than most would have expected, I'd say his mental approach to the game must be v. good. Could be valuable if he was to share it with such a young team.

And please, stop w the Ballin nonsense :deadhorse: Manly are paying most of his salary. We have a new major sponsor for the first time in forever, admin that aren't afraid to make hard decisions and a promising group of youngsters. It'll be looking rosy in 2017-2018.
 
@WTDiehard said:
Reddy can shine in a really strong team…....we are not that type of team though.......we should stick with our young guys.....I would not bother with Reddy at any price.
Click to expand...

Shine in a strong team?

He played for souths the last 2 years and was consistently their worst player!

The guy is just plain terrible.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 3,832 (members: 33, guests: 3,799)
Back
Top