Josh Addo Carr ...Petition To Stay

[Regan]

Up until the year 2000 i was a West and Balmain supporter and from then i have supporter the West Tigers and its been hard at times but i go to games buy the jersey spend my hard earned money to follow the team but it makes me angry letting go JAC the club is so stupid i am sick of it so i am writing here to let everyone know I want JAC to stay i dont care what the West Tigers management have to do get on bended knee keep this kid The West Tigers have taken so much from me for a very long time my emotions take a battering its so hard at times to love some think that causes you so much pain i am near the end so i ask my fellow West Tiger supporter do you want JAC to stay or lose another talented kid the West Tigers you owe me this keep him

A contract is easy to break in the game today

 

[happy_tiger]

He's a winger

He's played what 4 games ??

Yep lets lose it

 

[wonka]

All he has to do is go down there threaten to take Bellamy out to the car park for fisticuffs & get his contract ripped up.

 

[teddy23]

He's a winger

He's played what 4 games ??

Yep lets lose it

Tbf he has proven to be a star in the future, at least he's an instant success unlike others (cough Broses)

He's gone, that's it we can't do anything about it. Let's now plan ahead instead of looking back!

 

[Regan]

He's a winger

He's played what 4 games ??

Yep lets lose it

Its not just about Carr ..Te Maire Martin should still be here ….Also letting go Martin Taupau he was on the cheap this year ...Marika Koroibete......Blake Austin...Nathan Brown...Andrew Fifita....Marion Seve.
Salesi Funaki.....

Just get sick of it and also James Tedesco can not believe how he got treated just stupid

 

[happy_tiger]

He's a winger

He's played what 4 games ??

Yep lets lose it

Tbf he has proven to be a star in the future, at least he's an instant success unlike others (cough Broses)

He's gone, that's it we can't do anything about it. Let's now plan ahead instead of looking back!

But its the same theme as so many other Tigers players

Potential ,Potential ,Potential

We need more than Potential we have potential coming out of our foofer valve

We need hard heads to guide the potential round the park , not more potential that just gets lost whenever things get too hard

 

[Milky]

We offered him a competitive offer mate, he didn't want to stay, simple as that.

 

[Regan]

He's a winger

He's played what 4 games ??

Yep lets lose it

\
\
And what about James Tedesco this time will they let him go again hes played 63 NRL games never played for Australia or Origin whats he worth this time will they offer him unders again maybe $500k and let him go to East for $650k

 

[Regan]

We offered him a competitive offer mate, he didn't want to stay, simple as that.

He wanted to stay thats the sad part

 

[happy_tiger]

He's a winger

He's played what 4 games ??

Yep lets lose it

Tbf he has proven to be a star in the future, at least he's an instant success unlike others (cough Broses)

He's gone, that's it we can't do anything about it. Let's now plan ahead instead of looking back!

But its the same theme as so many other Tigers players

Potential ,Potential ,Potential

We need more than Potential we have potential coming out of our foofer valve

We need hard heads to guide the potential round the park , not more potential that just gets lost whenever things get too hard

 

[Guest]

Petition won't mean a thing if he doesn't want to stay in the first place. He has signed. Time to move on and plan for the future…Oh wait, this is the Wests Tigers!

 

[Eddie]

I tend to agree with happy.

4 game player.

Potential, could be very good but could be found out.

Hes gone, onc the team cant make the finals I would put him back to reserves.

 

[tiga4eva]

So,does he continue to get picked,or do we give someone like Chance Peni a crack and put JAC back in the Reggies?

 

[NJLM78]

People might feel disappointed that JAC is leaving. But he is more than capable of deciding that is where he wants to go. He is doing what is best for him. Good luck to him. In recent weeks Aloiai, Lawrence, MCK have all decided to stay as they feel for what is best for them and their career. JAC leaving opens the door for another young winger to get his chance. I would rather see the Tigers focus their attention on keeping players like ET and Tedesco for many seasons to come.

 

[Geo]

Rally's are more effective…. 😱pen_mouth:

 

[Regan]

He's a winger

He's played what 4 games ??

Yep lets lose it

Tbf he has proven to be a star in the future, at least he's an instant success unlike others (cough Broses)

He's gone, that's it we can't do anything about it. Let's now plan ahead instead of looking back!

But its the same theme as so many other Tigers players

Potential ,Potential ,Potential

We need more than Potential we have potential coming out of our foofer valve

We need hard heads to guide the potential round the park , not more potential that just gets lost whenever things get too hard

A winger is not the guy that leads you around the park… can you name a better winger at West Tigers who wanted 120k stay next year and 180k the year after or any winger in the NRL thats better then JAC

 

[tigermac88]

We offered him a competitive offer mate, he didn't want to stay, simple as that.

milky thats bull s***, we offered him a competitive offer, we only came to the party after he signed, he wanted to stay but was told to look elsewhere then when he did they changed there minds.

Is it JAC telling us or Pascoe telling us he was offered a competitive contract?

 

[tigermac88]

So,does he continue to get picked,or do we give someone like Chance Peni a crack and put JAC back in the Reggies?

This season is a another write off unless a miracle occurs so I wouldn't help develop him one bit. He should be 18th man for reggies and someone else should get their chance.

 

[happy_tiger]

He's a winger

He's played what 4 games ??

Yep lets lose it

Tbf he has proven to be a star in the future, at least he's an instant success unlike others (cough Broses)

He's gone, that's it we can't do anything about it. Let's now plan ahead instead of looking back!

But its the same theme as so many other Tigers players

Potential ,Potential ,Potential

We need more than Potential we have potential coming out of our foofer valve

We need hard heads to guide the potential round the park , not more potential that just gets lost whenever things get too hard

A winger is not the guy that leads you around the park… can you name a better winger at West Tigers who wanted 120k stay next year and 180k the year after or any winger in the NRL thats better then JAC

But if you don't have decent players inside him it wouldn't matter if we had Eric Grothe senior and Taniella Tuiaki on each wing , do you understand that ??

 

[Fordy20]

While it was dumb of the club to let him and MCK languish in NSW Cup when our right edge was so poor, it was smart of the club not to get into a bidding war to keep JAC when he signed with the Storm. He can't have wanted to stay too badly otherwise he would have taken our offer and taken advantage of the cooling off period in the Storm contract.