Kevin Walters
- Thread starter Telltails
- Start date
Gary_Bakerloo
New member
Well, he didn't do that much to be honest. I mean Smith picked the team for him.
momo_amp_medo
Well-known member
@ said:
Ye right!
jirskyr
Well-known member
Easy to be humble when your juggernaut winning team wins again and you get to keep your job for 2018.
I'm sure he's a nice bloke, but coaching the QLD SOO for the last 10 years has been a fairly breezy ride, whether it's Mick Hagan or Cam Smith writes up your battle plans.
I'm sure he's a nice bloke, but coaching the QLD SOO for the last 10 years has been a fairly breezy ride, whether it's Mick Hagan or Cam Smith writes up your battle plans.
gallagher
Well-known member
Very ballsy of him to take on that role after what Mal had produced. He deserves the accolades of his achievement in winning two series in a row.
People trying to diminish his accomplishment are a bit sad if you ask me.
People trying to diminish his accomplishment are a bit sad if you ask me.
Walters was probably under more pressure…given team selections...deserves credit for the series wins ...
VanillaThunder
New member
@ said:
Fair call I think. It's easy to trot out the record and the spine (and rightly so), but Walters should be commended for the selections from game 2 onwards given the whole loyalty shtick of the last decade. Definitely had Smith's fingerprints on Glasby and Munster, but otherwise it was a big move.
Laurie has free reign to lose as many as he wants as long as the Queensland spine is in tact, Kev had to walk in and win and he did.
Dont forget, Kev had the balls to ban 6 players from last years series who were good chances to play and stood by his convictions, still steering the squad to victory.
This year he played game 1 without Thurston, Slater, Scott, Ingliss, got spanked and made hard decisions again axing long time servants of the team to bring in new blood for game 2\. Game 3 the squad sans Thurston, Boyd, Scott and Ingliss totally outplayed very good opposition with brilliant tactical play.
Kev did real well.
This year he played game 1 without Thurston, Slater, Scott, Ingliss, got spanked and made hard decisions again axing long time servants of the team to bring in new blood for game 2\. Game 3 the squad sans Thurston, Boyd, Scott and Ingliss totally outplayed very good opposition with brilliant tactical play.
Kev did real well.
The_Old_Fox
Active member
@ said:
Agree stryker, on top of that he did his homework on game 3 and capitalised an advantage on the blues who thought it was going to be another grind like 1 and 2 .. The blues had no plan B at all..Queensland came out and hit us with everything bar the kitchen sink. Too good!!!
jirskyr
Well-known member
@ said:
I personally don't think you can congratulate Kevvie for picking a better side Game 2, when they clearly picked the wrong side for Game 1 and were demolished for it. It's like being saluted for fixing a leak in the pipe you accidentally chopped with your shovel.
The QLD axings for Game 2 weren't hard decisions at all; personally awkward ones maybe, but guys like Myles, Thaiday, Lilyman, O'Neill - there was no argument from anyone anywhere that they had to go. They made the ACB mistake of picking blokes from loyalty and not form.
Much more easily accomplished too when you have blokes like Coen Hess, Gav Cooper and Jarrod Wallace to call up and such a reliable Storm spine to direct them around.
A better example of a hard decision would have been stopping Boyd Cordner playing injured last night, because he was clearly sub-par and some key and uncharacteristic errors cost NSW dearly.
Nothing specifically against Walters, I like him quite a lot for a QLDer at this time of year, but I do reckon a lot of coaching types could take QLD to a series win with the squad, dominance and mental advantage they have.
Its been well documented that Kev was over ruled for game 1 selections and that game 2 and 3 were his sides. He even joked about it with Locky after the game in the sheds. So he fixed the leak in the pipe that someone else hit with the shovel and he used the correct connectors, most of which were banned from use the year previous by him. Get it now?
jirskyr
Well-known member
@ said:
Sounds like spin to me. So who was to blame for the first team selected and were they also cut from the QLD Origin process?
Or put it another way, what does it say when the coach gets overruled in his team selection?
Byron_Bay_Fan
New member
@ said:
Stryker, you never striker me as the guy who believed in wrongs being righted then peaches and cream endings - shows I am still learning.
Tiger_Watto
New member
Not a fan of him, but he got the result.
But to say anyone could coach that team is simply rubbish. He has to contend with alot of ego's, powerbrokers and past players before he even gets to the team. That was no easy squad to manage either with so much new talent coming through.
Being a coach for rep teams has little to do with tactics, and more to do with preparation. Kev prepared Qld for game 3 perfectly and the players executed a perfect game plan.
Judging by some of the flaws of NSW on Wednesday, I'd say their preparation was simply poor. To go into a SOO match with no objective to shut down the best #9 in the game was laughable. Followed by not having a Plan B to gain meters if Qld bash your Props out of the game, Daley should be sacked!
But to say anyone could coach that team is simply rubbish. He has to contend with alot of ego's, powerbrokers and past players before he even gets to the team. That was no easy squad to manage either with so much new talent coming through.
Being a coach for rep teams has little to do with tactics, and more to do with preparation. Kev prepared Qld for game 3 perfectly and the players executed a perfect game plan.
Judging by some of the flaws of NSW on Wednesday, I'd say their preparation was simply poor. To go into a SOO match with no objective to shut down the best #9 in the game was laughable. Followed by not having a Plan B to gain meters if Qld bash your Props out of the game, Daley should be sacked!
andrew 474
New member
Not a fan of his but again got the job done , we had a good roster but simply played dumb and got out played from the start , they were beaten 10 minutes into the game it was only going to be buy how much .
Dump Daley , Bring in Andrew Johns , you could see his anger and frustration in game 2 , he could see what we needed to do and he would have got that message to the players ,
Dump Daley , Bring in Andrew Johns , you could see his anger and frustration in game 2 , he could see what we needed to do and he would have got that message to the players ,
851
Well-known member
@ said:
Absolutely Daley should go, the no accountability for the game 2 choke was the sealer for me, just sweep it under the rug and move on, Daley whilst a great player is a poor coach, and if NSW hope to win sometime soon he is first to go.
There are a number of players who need the axe as well, but a decent coach would know that, as a true Weststigers supporter, I say there is always next year, we live in hope.
