Live game thread - Tigers V Cowboys

[TieDye]

I thought Reynolds played ok .

So he threw the ball to a prop - and it was an error?


He threw it to a prop *on the last tackle* and yes that is an error. He got lucky that time, he did it again late in the game and possibly cost us a try.

Gee, there must be a lot of DH's making errors. I think Grant must have made 23 errors then.


I doubt Grant will ever pass it to a prop on the last. He is a good footballer.

I think, just think mind you that you could have a set against JR.

You won't give him credit for anything.


I listed a long list of errors that he made. Do you dispute any of them? Which of his errors should I give him credit for?

How about whilst you are giving credit you give me credit, I publicly praised Reynolds for his game against Canberra. He played well. Against Cowboys, he didnt. I dont understand all the butthurt here for Reynolds? Why does he need such defending?

I already told you.... He passed to a front rower and he scored. He made the decision and it worked. You say he was lucky.

When Grant did the same thing for Aloiai - I noticed you didn't say he was lucky.

That is not giving him credit in my eyes.

I don't care at this point if he played well or didn't against xyz or Cows.

There is no butthurt (as you call it) - rip him apart all you like, but give credit when it is due, which in this instance, you didn't.

I have acknowledged that he gets his TA but there is no getting away from the fact that REynolds screwed up. He passed it to a prop ***ON THE LAST TACKLE***, it was a mistake (that he repeated later), Brooks was calling for it and Garner was pointing at Douiehi and REynolds passed it to a flat footed Musgrove who had defenders in front of him so yes Reynolds was VERY LUCKY that it didnt end up with a handover like later in the match, but yes it resulted in a try thank god and he gets his TA.

When Grant set Aloiai, he ran at a retreating defence, drew a man, put Aloiai through a massive hole ***AND IT WASNT THE LAST TACKLE!!!!!*** . I give Grant credit for that because it was great play.

I thought Reynolds played ok .

So he threw the ball to a prop - and it was an error?


He threw it to a prop *on the last tackle* and yes that is an error. He got lucky that time, he did it again late in the game and possibly cost us a try.

Gee, there must be a lot of DH's making errors. I think Grant must have made 23 errors then.


I doubt Grant will ever pass it to a prop on the last. He is a good footballer.

I think, just think mind you that you could have a set against JR.

You won't give him credit for anything.


I listed a long list of errors that he made. Do you dispute any of them? Which of his errors should I give him credit for?

How about whilst you are giving credit you give me credit, I publicly praised Reynolds for his game against Canberra. He played well. Against Cowboys, he didnt. I dont understand all the butthurt here for Reynolds? Why does he need such defending?

I already told you.... He passed to a front rower and he scored. He made the decision and it worked. You say he was lucky.

When Grant did the same thing for Aloiai - I noticed you didn't say he was lucky.

That is not giving him credit in my eyes.

I don't care at this point if he played well or didn't against xyz or Cows.

There is no butthurt (as you call it) - rip him apart all you like, but give credit when it is due, which in this instance, you didn't.

I have acknowledged that he gets his TA but there is no getting away from the fact that REynolds screwed up. He passed it to a prop ***ON THE LAST TACKLE***, it was a mistake (that he repeated later), Brooks was calling for it and Garner was pointing at Douiehi and REynolds passed it to a flat footed Musgrove who had defenders in front of him so yes Reynolds was VERY LUCKY that it didnt end up with a handover like later in the match, but yes it resulted in a try thank god and he gets his TA.

When Grant set Aloiai, he ran at a retreating defence, drew a man, put Aloiai through a massive hole ***AND IT WASNT THE LAST TACKLE!!!!!*** . I give Grant credit for that because it was great play.

Ok Chief. Let's forget it.

I thought you may be a big man and admit you were wrong.

However I was wrong for thinking that.


Well big guy.....show me where Im wrong and I'm more than happy to make a correction.

Remember credit where credit is due big man.

As I said... Forget it.

You just do not understand what I am getting at. All good.

Carry on.


Its impossible to not understand what you are getting at. You want me to credit Reynolds "where credit is due". I have already credited him with the Try Assist for the first try but as I said it was clearly an error and thank god we got the try. He had a poor game. Other than the try assist, what should I be giving him credit for? Getting to the game on time?

This exchange has me stumped. All I've done is list a shopping list of JR's errors during the game and you ride in like a white knight to defend his honour. Ive said he had a good game against Canberra, rubbish against Cowboys.

This forum is a discussion forum to discuss aspects of the game and the players. If you want to have a proper discussion, it has to be in good faith. Even in this thread, TrueTiger and I had a robust exchange but on both sides it was in good faith and I think good discussion came out of it, we have different opinions but that makes the world go around. There are MANY people here I have had strong disagreements with and with exception of one person so far, I have always come out of it with respect for the other person and their point of view. This is because the discussion is in good faith on both parties.

When you pull that "I'm not talking to you and I thought you were a big man" pre-pubescent rubbish, for me all good faith is evaporated and there is zero possibility of sensible, interesting or adult discussion.

Carry on Big Man.

Well I was going to try to explain till I got to the last paragraph. So forget it.


I picture you with your arms crossed and holding your breath

I picture you shutting up... right?

 

[Tiger5150]

I thought Reynolds played ok .

So he threw the ball to a prop - and it was an error?


He threw it to a prop *on the last tackle* and yes that is an error. He got lucky that time, he did it again late in the game and possibly cost us a try.

Gee, there must be a lot of DH's making errors. I think Grant must have made 23 errors then.


I doubt Grant will ever pass it to a prop on the last. He is a good footballer.

I think, just think mind you that you could have a set against JR.

You won't give him credit for anything.


I listed a long list of errors that he made. Do you dispute any of them? Which of his errors should I give him credit for?

How about whilst you are giving credit you give me credit, I publicly praised Reynolds for his game against Canberra. He played well. Against Cowboys, he didnt. I dont understand all the butthurt here for Reynolds? Why does he need such defending?

I already told you.... He passed to a front rower and he scored. He made the decision and it worked. You say he was lucky.

When Grant did the same thing for Aloiai - I noticed you didn't say he was lucky.

That is not giving him credit in my eyes.

I don't care at this point if he played well or didn't against xyz or Cows.

There is no butthurt (as you call it) - rip him apart all you like, but give credit when it is due, which in this instance, you didn't.

I have acknowledged that he gets his TA but there is no getting away from the fact that REynolds screwed up. He passed it to a prop ***ON THE LAST TACKLE***, it was a mistake (that he repeated later), Brooks was calling for it and Garner was pointing at Douiehi and REynolds passed it to a flat footed Musgrove who had defenders in front of him so yes Reynolds was VERY LUCKY that it didnt end up with a handover like later in the match, but yes it resulted in a try thank god and he gets his TA.

When Grant set Aloiai, he ran at a retreating defence, drew a man, put Aloiai through a massive hole ***AND IT WASNT THE LAST TACKLE!!!!!*** . I give Grant credit for that because it was great play.

I thought Reynolds played ok .

So he threw the ball to a prop - and it was an error?


He threw it to a prop *on the last tackle* and yes that is an error. He got lucky that time, he did it again late in the game and possibly cost us a try.

Gee, there must be a lot of DH's making errors. I think Grant must have made 23 errors then.


I doubt Grant will ever pass it to a prop on the last. He is a good footballer.

I think, just think mind you that you could have a set against JR.

You won't give him credit for anything.


I listed a long list of errors that he made. Do you dispute any of them? Which of his errors should I give him credit for?

How about whilst you are giving credit you give me credit, I publicly praised Reynolds for his game against Canberra. He played well. Against Cowboys, he didnt. I dont understand all the butthurt here for Reynolds? Why does he need such defending?

I already told you.... He passed to a front rower and he scored. He made the decision and it worked. You say he was lucky.

When Grant did the same thing for Aloiai - I noticed you didn't say he was lucky.

That is not giving him credit in my eyes.

I don't care at this point if he played well or didn't against xyz or Cows.

There is no butthurt (as you call it) - rip him apart all you like, but give credit when it is due, which in this instance, you didn't.

I have acknowledged that he gets his TA but there is no getting away from the fact that REynolds screwed up. He passed it to a prop ***ON THE LAST TACKLE***, it was a mistake (that he repeated later), Brooks was calling for it and Garner was pointing at Douiehi and REynolds passed it to a flat footed Musgrove who had defenders in front of him so yes Reynolds was VERY LUCKY that it didnt end up with a handover like later in the match, but yes it resulted in a try thank god and he gets his TA.

When Grant set Aloiai, he ran at a retreating defence, drew a man, put Aloiai through a massive hole ***AND IT WASNT THE LAST TACKLE!!!!!*** . I give Grant credit for that because it was great play.

Ok Chief. Let's forget it.

I thought you may be a big man and admit you were wrong.

However I was wrong for thinking that.


Well big guy.....show me where Im wrong and I'm more than happy to make a correction.

Remember credit where credit is due big man.

As I said... Forget it.

You just do not understand what I am getting at. All good.

Carry on.


Its impossible to not understand what you are getting at. You want me to credit Reynolds "where credit is due". I have already credited him with the Try Assist for the first try but as I said it was clearly an error and thank god we got the try. He had a poor game. Other than the try assist, what should I be giving him credit for? Getting to the game on time?

This exchange has me stumped. All I've done is list a shopping list of JR's errors during the game and you ride in like a white knight to defend his honour. Ive said he had a good game against Canberra, rubbish against Cowboys.

This forum is a discussion forum to discuss aspects of the game and the players. If you want to have a proper discussion, it has to be in good faith. Even in this thread, TrueTiger and I had a robust exchange but on both sides it was in good faith and I think good discussion came out of it, we have different opinions but that makes the world go around. There are MANY people here I have had strong disagreements with and with exception of one person so far, I have always come out of it with respect for the other person and their point of view. This is because the discussion is in good faith on both parties.

When you pull that "I'm not talking to you and I thought you were a big man" pre-pubescent rubbish, for me all good faith is evaporated and there is zero possibility of sensible, interesting or adult discussion.

Carry on Big Man.

Well I was going to try to explain till I got to the last paragraph. So forget it.


I picture you with your arms crossed and holding your breath

I picture you shutting up... right?

Sorry mate.....and you are?

 

[TieDye]

I thought Reynolds played ok .

So he threw the ball to a prop - and it was an error?


He threw it to a prop *on the last tackle* and yes that is an error. He got lucky that time, he did it again late in the game and possibly cost us a try.

Gee, there must be a lot of DH's making errors. I think Grant must have made 23 errors then.


I doubt Grant will ever pass it to a prop on the last. He is a good footballer.

I think, just think mind you that you could have a set against JR.

You won't give him credit for anything.


I listed a long list of errors that he made. Do you dispute any of them? Which of his errors should I give him credit for?

How about whilst you are giving credit you give me credit, I publicly praised Reynolds for his game against Canberra. He played well. Against Cowboys, he didnt. I dont understand all the butthurt here for Reynolds? Why does he need such defending?

I already told you.... He passed to a front rower and he scored. He made the decision and it worked. You say he was lucky.

When Grant did the same thing for Aloiai - I noticed you didn't say he was lucky.

That is not giving him credit in my eyes.

I don't care at this point if he played well or didn't against xyz or Cows.

There is no butthurt (as you call it) - rip him apart all you like, but give credit when it is due, which in this instance, you didn't.

I have acknowledged that he gets his TA but there is no getting away from the fact that REynolds screwed up. He passed it to a prop ***ON THE LAST TACKLE***, it was a mistake (that he repeated later), Brooks was calling for it and Garner was pointing at Douiehi and REynolds passed it to a flat footed Musgrove who had defenders in front of him so yes Reynolds was VERY LUCKY that it didnt end up with a handover like later in the match, but yes it resulted in a try thank god and he gets his TA.

When Grant set Aloiai, he ran at a retreating defence, drew a man, put Aloiai through a massive hole ***AND IT WASNT THE LAST TACKLE!!!!!*** . I give Grant credit for that because it was great play.

I thought Reynolds played ok .

So he threw the ball to a prop - and it was an error?


He threw it to a prop *on the last tackle* and yes that is an error. He got lucky that time, he did it again late in the game and possibly cost us a try.

Gee, there must be a lot of DH's making errors. I think Grant must have made 23 errors then.


I doubt Grant will ever pass it to a prop on the last. He is a good footballer.

I think, just think mind you that you could have a set against JR.

You won't give him credit for anything.


I listed a long list of errors that he made. Do you dispute any of them? Which of his errors should I give him credit for?

How about whilst you are giving credit you give me credit, I publicly praised Reynolds for his game against Canberra. He played well. Against Cowboys, he didnt. I dont understand all the butthurt here for Reynolds? Why does he need such defending?

I already told you.... He passed to a front rower and he scored. He made the decision and it worked. You say he was lucky.

When Grant did the same thing for Aloiai - I noticed you didn't say he was lucky.

That is not giving him credit in my eyes.

I don't care at this point if he played well or didn't against xyz or Cows.

There is no butthurt (as you call it) - rip him apart all you like, but give credit when it is due, which in this instance, you didn't.

I have acknowledged that he gets his TA but there is no getting away from the fact that REynolds screwed up. He passed it to a prop ***ON THE LAST TACKLE***, it was a mistake (that he repeated later), Brooks was calling for it and Garner was pointing at Douiehi and REynolds passed it to a flat footed Musgrove who had defenders in front of him so yes Reynolds was VERY LUCKY that it didnt end up with a handover like later in the match, but yes it resulted in a try thank god and he gets his TA.

When Grant set Aloiai, he ran at a retreating defence, drew a man, put Aloiai through a massive hole ***AND IT WASNT THE LAST TACKLE!!!!!*** . I give Grant credit for that because it was great play.

Ok Chief. Let's forget it.

I thought you may be a big man and admit you were wrong.

However I was wrong for thinking that.


Well big guy.....show me where Im wrong and I'm more than happy to make a correction.

Remember credit where credit is due big man.

As I said... Forget it.

You just do not understand what I am getting at. All good.

Carry on.


Its impossible to not understand what you are getting at. You want me to credit Reynolds "where credit is due". I have already credited him with the Try Assist for the first try but as I said it was clearly an error and thank god we got the try. He had a poor game. Other than the try assist, what should I be giving him credit for? Getting to the game on time?

This exchange has me stumped. All I've done is list a shopping list of JR's errors during the game and you ride in like a white knight to defend his honour. Ive said he had a good game against Canberra, rubbish against Cowboys.

This forum is a discussion forum to discuss aspects of the game and the players. If you want to have a proper discussion, it has to be in good faith. Even in this thread, TrueTiger and I had a robust exchange but on both sides it was in good faith and I think good discussion came out of it, we have different opinions but that makes the world go around. There are MANY people here I have had strong disagreements with and with exception of one person so far, I have always come out of it with respect for the other person and their point of view. This is because the discussion is in good faith on both parties.

When you pull that "I'm not talking to you and I thought you were a big man" pre-pubescent rubbish, for me all good faith is evaporated and there is zero possibility of sensible, interesting or adult discussion.

Carry on Big Man.

Well I was going to try to explain till I got to the last paragraph. So forget it.


I picture you with your arms crossed and holding your breath

I picture you shutting up... right?


Sorry mate.....and you are?

The sheriff round these parts, pal

 

[Tiger5150]

I thought Reynolds played ok .

So he threw the ball to a prop - and it was an error?


He threw it to a prop *on the last tackle* and yes that is an error. He got lucky that time, he did it again late in the game and possibly cost us a try.

Gee, there must be a lot of DH's making errors. I think Grant must have made 23 errors then.


I doubt Grant will ever pass it to a prop on the last. He is a good footballer.

I think, just think mind you that you could have a set against JR.

You won't give him credit for anything.


I listed a long list of errors that he made. Do you dispute any of them? Which of his errors should I give him credit for?

How about whilst you are giving credit you give me credit, I publicly praised Reynolds for his game against Canberra. He played well. Against Cowboys, he didnt. I dont understand all the butthurt here for Reynolds? Why does he need such defending?

I already told you.... He passed to a front rower and he scored. He made the decision and it worked. You say he was lucky.

When Grant did the same thing for Aloiai - I noticed you didn't say he was lucky.

That is not giving him credit in my eyes.

I don't care at this point if he played well or didn't against xyz or Cows.

There is no butthurt (as you call it) - rip him apart all you like, but give credit when it is due, which in this instance, you didn't.

I have acknowledged that he gets his TA but there is no getting away from the fact that REynolds screwed up. He passed it to a prop ***ON THE LAST TACKLE***, it was a mistake (that he repeated later), Brooks was calling for it and Garner was pointing at Douiehi and REynolds passed it to a flat footed Musgrove who had defenders in front of him so yes Reynolds was VERY LUCKY that it didnt end up with a handover like later in the match, but yes it resulted in a try thank god and he gets his TA.

When Grant set Aloiai, he ran at a retreating defence, drew a man, put Aloiai through a massive hole ***AND IT WASNT THE LAST TACKLE!!!!!*** . I give Grant credit for that because it was great play.

I thought Reynolds played ok .

So he threw the ball to a prop - and it was an error?


He threw it to a prop *on the last tackle* and yes that is an error. He got lucky that time, he did it again late in the game and possibly cost us a try.

Gee, there must be a lot of DH's making errors. I think Grant must have made 23 errors then.


I doubt Grant will ever pass it to a prop on the last. He is a good footballer.

I think, just think mind you that you could have a set against JR.

You won't give him credit for anything.


I listed a long list of errors that he made. Do you dispute any of them? Which of his errors should I give him credit for?

How about whilst you are giving credit you give me credit, I publicly praised Reynolds for his game against Canberra. He played well. Against Cowboys, he didnt. I dont understand all the butthurt here for Reynolds? Why does he need such defending?

I already told you.... He passed to a front rower and he scored. He made the decision and it worked. You say he was lucky.

When Grant did the same thing for Aloiai - I noticed you didn't say he was lucky.

That is not giving him credit in my eyes.

I don't care at this point if he played well or didn't against xyz or Cows.

There is no butthurt (as you call it) - rip him apart all you like, but give credit when it is due, which in this instance, you didn't.

I have acknowledged that he gets his TA but there is no getting away from the fact that REynolds screwed up. He passed it to a prop ***ON THE LAST TACKLE***, it was a mistake (that he repeated later), Brooks was calling for it and Garner was pointing at Douiehi and REynolds passed it to a flat footed Musgrove who had defenders in front of him so yes Reynolds was VERY LUCKY that it didnt end up with a handover like later in the match, but yes it resulted in a try thank god and he gets his TA.

When Grant set Aloiai, he ran at a retreating defence, drew a man, put Aloiai through a massive hole ***AND IT WASNT THE LAST TACKLE!!!!!*** . I give Grant credit for that because it was great play.

Ok Chief. Let's forget it.

I thought you may be a big man and admit you were wrong.

However I was wrong for thinking that.


Well big guy.....show me where Im wrong and I'm more than happy to make a correction.

Remember credit where credit is due big man.

As I said... Forget it.

You just do not understand what I am getting at. All good.

Carry on.


Its impossible to not understand what you are getting at. You want me to credit Reynolds "where credit is due". I have already credited him with the Try Assist for the first try but as I said it was clearly an error and thank god we got the try. He had a poor game. Other than the try assist, what should I be giving him credit for? Getting to the game on time?

This exchange has me stumped. All I've done is list a shopping list of JR's errors during the game and you ride in like a white knight to defend his honour. Ive said he had a good game against Canberra, rubbish against Cowboys.

This forum is a discussion forum to discuss aspects of the game and the players. If you want to have a proper discussion, it has to be in good faith. Even in this thread, TrueTiger and I had a robust exchange but on both sides it was in good faith and I think good discussion came out of it, we have different opinions but that makes the world go around. There are MANY people here I have had strong disagreements with and with exception of one person so far, I have always come out of it with respect for the other person and their point of view. This is because the discussion is in good faith on both parties.

When you pull that "I'm not talking to you and I thought you were a big man" pre-pubescent rubbish, for me all good faith is evaporated and there is zero possibility of sensible, interesting or adult discussion.

Carry on Big Man.

Well I was going to try to explain till I got to the last paragraph. So forget it.


I picture you with your arms crossed and holding your breath

I picture you shutting up... right?


Sorry mate.....and you are?

The sheriff round these parts, pal

Like....a big man?

 

[Guest]

Idiots...