Luke Brooks - Mega Thread

@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523111) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523109) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523092) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523091) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523088) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523087) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523084) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523083) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523080) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523079) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523077) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523074) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523072) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523070) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523066) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523064) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523061) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523060) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523055) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523053) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523049) said:
It’s not like we can go out and sign Cleary or Reynolds. Where we are as a club, we’d only be getting a player of the same calibre. Everyone wants to punt him, but no one wants to offer a replacement whose gonna charge us into the finals.

Keep up mate...

Captain Jack is the man.
But you've got a problem with that too.

"He hasn't even put the jersey on yet."

7 Hastings
6 AD

Don't just make things up to justify your argument ... you spent that whole other thread explaining why he shouldn't be captain and now you claim no one's offered the replacement.

Whilst AD is out..
Peachy, Madden, Young Tyrone.

But you know it’s not going to happen. Wish for it all you like, but we both know who the 7 will be.



@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523055) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523053) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523049) said:
It’s not like we can go out and sign Cleary or Reynolds. Where we are as a club, we’d only be getting a player of the same calibre. Everyone wants to punt him, but no one wants to offer a replacement whose gonna charge us into the finals.

Keep up mate...

Captain Jack is the man.
But you've got a problem with that too.

"He hasn't even put the jersey on yet."

7 Hastings
6 AD

Don't just make things up to justify your argument ... you spent that whole other thread explaining why he shouldn't be captain and now you claim no one's offered the replacement.

Whilst AD is out..
Peachy, Madden, Young Tyrone.

But you know it’s not going to happen. Wish for it all you like, but we both know who the 7 will be.

So the conversation is over.

We've put up with the same trash for so long and selection committee in @GNR4LIFE has spoken.

Pot meet kettle.
Dead horse meet stick.

??

Achievements, everyday

Well, no Sheens did when he confirmed Hastings was training at 6.

He also said AD is a 6 ...

Whatever will we do !?

Where's the Nofo thread ?
Can we discuss how he's a woeful winger that can't even run the right direction ?

As I just said, the goal posts are constantly being moved in relation to Brooks. First it was he wasn’t gonna be here next year, then he wasn’t gonna be the halfback round 1. Now we’re at the stage where he’ll be gone when AD is back. What will it be when AD returns to in the centres?

Are you being blatantly ignorant or is it just your character? MY opinion is hoping the decision is made on form. Don't know why you're making it in to something else?

You can run away from that fact if you like, but that’s what’s been happening with the Brooks discussion since the last round against the Dogs.

We'll see. I don't understand your love for mediocrity. Are you happy with the our position year after year? Club needs change. Hastings is change.

I could understand if we’d just signed Cleary or Reynolds or if people were saying that’s who the answer to our problems was. Hastings is going sideways.

Nofo legit goes side ways every game.
You're going to love Hastings.

Only when he’s improving the position for the kick at goal

Troll levels hitting all new highs with a response like that.

That's almost 3 hours of effort today.
Well done.

That was quick wasn’t it. Almost as quick as Brooks pace. Quickest player in the team

Typical. Proof of your mindset

I stopped taking this discussion seriously 2 pages ago. It could be a good, healthy discussion, but it gets ruined cos some want to constantly take shots at others for things unrelated to what we are talking about.

Ok mate. Not worth it.

Yeah, if you have to just stick to footy, what’s the point.

Keep padding that post count brah.
Must matter to you.

That’s what we’re reduced to now, shaming post counts.

?
 
@tiger5150 said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523100) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523098) said:
@tiger5150 said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523097) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523095) said:
@tiger5150 said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523086) said:
Im losing track, one post calling for discussion, the next attacking GnR for discussion, one post flogging a dead horse, the next complaining about flogging a dead horse, often all from the same poster.

Man of my word though.

Have a good weekend Glenn.

Really? A man of your word?

I remember a man gave me his word, out of "respect" that they would remove my real name from the forum because I had had people dox me. I would think that a "man of their word" would keep their word and not intentionally do that.

Should I screenshot our private conversation and share it? Apparently thats OK if its done in proving Im not lying?

Go for it.

You asked me to remove a reply to some guy who mentioned your name and that was the extent of the conversation.

Two days in a row you've found it necessary to reply to me with some vague dig and it hasnt gone unnoticed.

I'd appreciate it if you would stop with the creepiness.

You would like me to stop my creepiness?

Mate......in a private message, I explained to you that I had been doxxed in RL, with people sharing a link that has links to my RL, my kids, my partner, my business with people attacking me online. For that reason, I asked you to remove a post that linked to my RL name. You stated "I'll respect 'ya" and removed the post.

Now in response to a harmless post, after I explain to you in a private message the very real reason I dont want my name posted here ......you post my name anyway. And ***I'm*** the creepy one.....righto.


You'd think some one who has been exposed to cyber bullying would be more mindful to others...

But no..

What are you trying to achieve with your posts, you're clearly targeting me and trying to hurt my feelings or upset me ? Good job.

Do you remember your old user name?
I do...
 
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523116) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523111) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523109) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523092) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523091) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523088) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523087) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523084) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523083) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523080) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523079) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523077) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523074) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523072) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523070) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523066) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523064) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523061) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523060) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523055) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523053) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523049) said:
It’s not like we can go out and sign Cleary or Reynolds. Where we are as a club, we’d only be getting a player of the same calibre. Everyone wants to punt him, but no one wants to offer a replacement whose gonna charge us into the finals.

Keep up mate...

Captain Jack is the man.
But you've got a problem with that too.

"He hasn't even put the jersey on yet."

7 Hastings
6 AD

Don't just make things up to justify your argument ... you spent that whole other thread explaining why he shouldn't be captain and now you claim no one's offered the replacement.

Whilst AD is out..
Peachy, Madden, Young Tyrone.

But you know it’s not going to happen. Wish for it all you like, but we both know who the 7 will be.



@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523055) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523053) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523049) said:
It’s not like we can go out and sign Cleary or Reynolds. Where we are as a club, we’d only be getting a player of the same calibre. Everyone wants to punt him, but no one wants to offer a replacement whose gonna charge us into the finals.

Keep up mate...

Captain Jack is the man.
But you've got a problem with that too.

"He hasn't even put the jersey on yet."

7 Hastings
6 AD

Don't just make things up to justify your argument ... you spent that whole other thread explaining why he shouldn't be captain and now you claim no one's offered the replacement.

Whilst AD is out..
Peachy, Madden, Young Tyrone.

But you know it’s not going to happen. Wish for it all you like, but we both know who the 7 will be.

So the conversation is over.

We've put up with the same trash for so long and selection committee in @GNR4LIFE has spoken.

Pot meet kettle.
Dead horse meet stick.

??

Achievements, everyday

Well, no Sheens did when he confirmed Hastings was training at 6.

He also said AD is a 6 ...

Whatever will we do !?

Where's the Nofo thread ?
Can we discuss how he's a woeful winger that can't even run the right direction ?

As I just said, the goal posts are constantly being moved in relation to Brooks. First it was he wasn’t gonna be here next year, then he wasn’t gonna be the halfback round 1. Now we’re at the stage where he’ll be gone when AD is back. What will it be when AD returns to in the centres?

Are you being blatantly ignorant or is it just your character? MY opinion is hoping the decision is made on form. Don't know why you're making it in to something else?

You can run away from that fact if you like, but that’s what’s been happening with the Brooks discussion since the last round against the Dogs.

We'll see. I don't understand your love for mediocrity. Are you happy with the our position year after year? Club needs change. Hastings is change.

I could understand if we’d just signed Cleary or Reynolds or if people were saying that’s who the answer to our problems was. Hastings is going sideways.

Nofo legit goes side ways every game.
You're going to love Hastings.

Only when he’s improving the position for the kick at goal

Troll levels hitting all new highs with a response like that.

That's almost 3 hours of effort today.
Well done.

That was quick wasn’t it. Almost as quick as Brooks pace. Quickest player in the team

Typical. Proof of your mindset

I stopped taking this discussion seriously 2 pages ago. It could be a good, healthy discussion, but it gets ruined cos some want to constantly take shots at others for things unrelated to what we are talking about.

Ok mate. Not worth it.

Yeah, if you have to just stick to footy, what’s the point.

Keep padding that post count brah.
Must matter to you.

That’s what we’re reduced to now, shaming post counts.

?

The fact it clearly gets under your skin is humorous to me. Just like the other one constantly referencing me saying I’d been here 10 years. You need to make what gets under your skin less obvious.
 
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523119) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523116) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523111) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523109) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523092) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523091) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523088) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523087) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523084) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523083) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523080) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523079) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523077) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523074) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523072) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523070) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523066) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523064) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523061) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523060) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523055) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523053) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523049) said:
It’s not like we can go out and sign Cleary or Reynolds. Where we are as a club, we’d only be getting a player of the same calibre. Everyone wants to punt him, but no one wants to offer a replacement whose gonna charge us into the finals.

Keep up mate...

Captain Jack is the man.
But you've got a problem with that too.

"He hasn't even put the jersey on yet."

7 Hastings
6 AD

Don't just make things up to justify your argument ... you spent that whole other thread explaining why he shouldn't be captain and now you claim no one's offered the replacement.

Whilst AD is out..
Peachy, Madden, Young Tyrone.

But you know it’s not going to happen. Wish for it all you like, but we both know who the 7 will be.



@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523055) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523053) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523049) said:
It’s not like we can go out and sign Cleary or Reynolds. Where we are as a club, we’d only be getting a player of the same calibre. Everyone wants to punt him, but no one wants to offer a replacement whose gonna charge us into the finals.

Keep up mate...

Captain Jack is the man.
But you've got a problem with that too.

"He hasn't even put the jersey on yet."

7 Hastings
6 AD

Don't just make things up to justify your argument ... you spent that whole other thread explaining why he shouldn't be captain and now you claim no one's offered the replacement.

Whilst AD is out..
Peachy, Madden, Young Tyrone.

But you know it’s not going to happen. Wish for it all you like, but we both know who the 7 will be.

So the conversation is over.

We've put up with the same trash for so long and selection committee in @GNR4LIFE has spoken.

Pot meet kettle.
Dead horse meet stick.

??

Achievements, everyday

Well, no Sheens did when he confirmed Hastings was training at 6.

He also said AD is a 6 ...

Whatever will we do !?

Where's the Nofo thread ?
Can we discuss how he's a woeful winger that can't even run the right direction ?

As I just said, the goal posts are constantly being moved in relation to Brooks. First it was he wasn’t gonna be here next year, then he wasn’t gonna be the halfback round 1. Now we’re at the stage where he’ll be gone when AD is back. What will it be when AD returns to in the centres?

Are you being blatantly ignorant or is it just your character? MY opinion is hoping the decision is made on form. Don't know why you're making it in to something else?

You can run away from that fact if you like, but that’s what’s been happening with the Brooks discussion since the last round against the Dogs.

We'll see. I don't understand your love for mediocrity. Are you happy with the our position year after year? Club needs change. Hastings is change.

I could understand if we’d just signed Cleary or Reynolds or if people were saying that’s who the answer to our problems was. Hastings is going sideways.

Nofo legit goes side ways every game.
You're going to love Hastings.

Only when he’s improving the position for the kick at goal

Troll levels hitting all new highs with a response like that.

That's almost 3 hours of effort today.
Well done.

That was quick wasn’t it. Almost as quick as Brooks pace. Quickest player in the team

Typical. Proof of your mindset

I stopped taking this discussion seriously 2 pages ago. It could be a good, healthy discussion, but it gets ruined cos some want to constantly take shots at others for things unrelated to what we are talking about.

Ok mate. Not worth it.

Yeah, if you have to just stick to footy, what’s the point.

Keep padding that post count brah.
Must matter to you.

That’s what we’re reduced to now, shaming post counts.

?

The fact it gets clearly gets under your skin is humorous to me.

You have to mean something to me to bother me.
You're a flea.
I'm just stating facts.
 
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523114) said:
@tiger5150 said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523097) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523095) said:
@tiger5150 said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523086) said:
Im losing track, one post calling for discussion, the next attacking GnR for discussion, one post flogging a dead horse, the next complaining about flogging a dead horse, often all from the same poster.

Man of my word though.

Have a good weekend Glenn.

Really? A man of your word?

I remember a man gave me his word, out of "respect" that they would remove my real name from the forum because I had had people dox me. I would think that a "man of their word" would keep their word and not intentionally do that.

Should I screenshot our private conversation and share it? Apparently thats OK if its done in proving Im not lying?

Wondering when you were going to chime in.
No one cares who you are in the real world.
No one's trying to ruin your life bro.
You shared your name on here.
Leave it at that.

When did I share my name on here? I didnt.

My RL facebook profile with links to my partner, kids and business was posted on here. I have had people contact in RL. There was a poster of me shared on Discord. After that people thought it was clever to call me my RL name, coincidentally only the Discord bro's.

I specifically told Demps I didnt want my RL name here because I had been doxxed in RL and he deleted a post because of it. But for some reason now its cool to continually post my real name?

You think thats all ok and cool?
 
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523121) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523119) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523116) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523111) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523109) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523092) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523091) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523088) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523087) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523084) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523083) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523080) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523079) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523077) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523074) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523072) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523070) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523066) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523064) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523061) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523060) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523055) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523053) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523049) said:
It’s not like we can go out and sign Cleary or Reynolds. Where we are as a club, we’d only be getting a player of the same calibre. Everyone wants to punt him, but no one wants to offer a replacement whose gonna charge us into the finals.

Keep up mate...

Captain Jack is the man.
But you've got a problem with that too.

"He hasn't even put the jersey on yet."

7 Hastings
6 AD

Don't just make things up to justify your argument ... you spent that whole other thread explaining why he shouldn't be captain and now you claim no one's offered the replacement.

Whilst AD is out..
Peachy, Madden, Young Tyrone.

But you know it’s not going to happen. Wish for it all you like, but we both know who the 7 will be.



@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523055) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523053) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523049) said:
It’s not like we can go out and sign Cleary or Reynolds. Where we are as a club, we’d only be getting a player of the same calibre. Everyone wants to punt him, but no one wants to offer a replacement whose gonna charge us into the finals.

Keep up mate...

Captain Jack is the man.
But you've got a problem with that too.

"He hasn't even put the jersey on yet."

7 Hastings
6 AD

Don't just make things up to justify your argument ... you spent that whole other thread explaining why he shouldn't be captain and now you claim no one's offered the replacement.

Whilst AD is out..
Peachy, Madden, Young Tyrone.

But you know it’s not going to happen. Wish for it all you like, but we both know who the 7 will be.

So the conversation is over.

We've put up with the same trash for so long and selection committee in @GNR4LIFE has spoken.

Pot meet kettle.
Dead horse meet stick.

??

Achievements, everyday

Well, no Sheens did when he confirmed Hastings was training at 6.

He also said AD is a 6 ...

Whatever will we do !?

Where's the Nofo thread ?
Can we discuss how he's a woeful winger that can't even run the right direction ?

As I just said, the goal posts are constantly being moved in relation to Brooks. First it was he wasn’t gonna be here next year, then he wasn’t gonna be the halfback round 1. Now we’re at the stage where he’ll be gone when AD is back. What will it be when AD returns to in the centres?

Are you being blatantly ignorant or is it just your character? MY opinion is hoping the decision is made on form. Don't know why you're making it in to something else?

You can run away from that fact if you like, but that’s what’s been happening with the Brooks discussion since the last round against the Dogs.

We'll see. I don't understand your love for mediocrity. Are you happy with the our position year after year? Club needs change. Hastings is change.

I could understand if we’d just signed Cleary or Reynolds or if people were saying that’s who the answer to our problems was. Hastings is going sideways.

Nofo legit goes side ways every game.
You're going to love Hastings.

Only when he’s improving the position for the kick at goal

Troll levels hitting all new highs with a response like that.

That's almost 3 hours of effort today.
Well done.

That was quick wasn’t it. Almost as quick as Brooks pace. Quickest player in the team

Typical. Proof of your mindset

I stopped taking this discussion seriously 2 pages ago. It could be a good, healthy discussion, but it gets ruined cos some want to constantly take shots at others for things unrelated to what we are talking about.

Ok mate. Not worth it.

Yeah, if you have to just stick to footy, what’s the point.

Keep padding that post count brah.
Must matter to you.

That’s what we’re reduced to now, shaming post counts.

?

The fact it gets clearly gets under your skin is humorous to me.

You have to mean something to me to bother me.
You're a flea.
I'm just stating facts.

Mate, if I was that irreverent you’d ignore me, but you don’t. You however are just about there for me which means you aren’t important enough to even acknowledge. I’m sure I’ll still read you taking shots at me to others, however I won’t even think about you from this point on.
 
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523052) said:
@earl said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523051) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523047) said:
@earl said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523046) said:
@hank37w said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523005) said:
>What difference does it make if the guy that steers the team around has a #6 or a #7 on his back?

Nothing. I'm not worried about Brooks being an organizing halfback. To answer the poll question to me it depends on how he performs but it's a stupid poll because he will be our starting 7 unless something drastic happens like injuries.

I'm 100% confident Madge will drop Brooks if the team is better off without him in the team.

That’s all well and good, but he has no one to drop him for.

Not right now and I don't think so in the past either but Hastings and Doueihi are going to be gunning for halves spots. If they are all fit it's 3 players into 2 positions. Maybe whoever doesn't get the spot slots somewhere else into the team but I can't see that lasting unless we are winning.

It'll be interesting how it all turns out next season. Does Brooks kill it and prove the doubters wrong ? Does Hasting show he is a quality NRL player ? Can Doueihi get his game together in the halves or does he slot into the team somewhere else ?

It seems a given by some that Hastings will be the one who outplays Brooks and Brooks is the one whose under pressure once AD gets back (if AD even comes back into the halves). I’m not as convinced.

It's not that simple. All of them need to prove themselves. I'm missing the footy.

My opinion based predominantly on hope is that Hastings and Doueihi get the halves spot. I have nothing against Brooks but to me is an average NRL half. Hopefully we do better than that.
 
@earl said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523125) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523052) said:
@earl said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523051) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523047) said:
@earl said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523046) said:
@hank37w said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523005) said:
>What difference does it make if the guy that steers the team around has a #6 or a #7 on his back?

Nothing. I'm not worried about Brooks being an organizing halfback. To answer the poll question to me it depends on how he performs but it's a stupid poll because he will be our starting 7 unless something drastic happens like injuries.

I'm 100% confident Madge will drop Brooks if the team is better off without him in the team.

That’s all well and good, but he has no one to drop him for.

Not right now and I don't think so in the past either but Hastings and Doueihi are going to be gunning for halves spots. If they are all fit it's 3 players into 2 positions. Maybe whoever doesn't get the spot slots somewhere else into the team but I can't see that lasting unless we are winning.

It'll be interesting how it all turns out next season. Does Brooks kill it and prove the doubters wrong ? Does Hasting show he is a quality NRL player ? Can Doueihi get his game together in the halves or does he slot into the team somewhere else ?

It seems a given by some that Hastings will be the one who outplays Brooks and Brooks is the one whose under pressure once AD gets back (if AD even comes back into the halves). I’m not as convinced.

It's not that simple. All of them need to prove themselves. I'm missing the footy.

My opinion based predominantly on hope is that Hastings and Doueihi get the halves spot. I have nothing against Brooks but to me is an average NRL half. Hopefully we do better than that.


Earl I respect your footy knowledge, but Adam will need a lot of improvement to make it in the halves.
 
@earl said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523125) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523052) said:
@earl said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523051) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523047) said:
@earl said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523046) said:
@hank37w said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523005) said:
>What difference does it make if the guy that steers the team around has a #6 or a #7 on his back?

Nothing. I'm not worried about Brooks being an organizing halfback. To answer the poll question to me it depends on how he performs but it's a stupid poll because he will be our starting 7 unless something drastic happens like injuries.

I'm 100% confident Madge will drop Brooks if the team is better off without him in the team.

That’s all well and good, but he has no one to drop him for.

Not right now and I don't think so in the past either but Hastings and Doueihi are going to be gunning for halves spots. If they are all fit it's 3 players into 2 positions. Maybe whoever doesn't get the spot slots somewhere else into the team but I can't see that lasting unless we are winning.

It'll be interesting how it all turns out next season. Does Brooks kill it and prove the doubters wrong ? Does Hasting show he is a quality NRL player ? Can Doueihi get his game together in the halves or does he slot into the team somewhere else ?

It seems a given by some that Hastings will be the one who outplays Brooks and Brooks is the one whose under pressure once AD gets back (if AD even comes back into the halves). I’m not as convinced.

It's not that simple. All of them need to prove themselves. I'm missing the footy.

My opinion based predominantly on hope is that Hastings and Doueihi get the halves spot. I have nothing against Brooks but to me is an average NRL half. Hopefully we do better than that.

Mate, we can’t have footy discussion breaking out here.
 
@tiger5150 said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523122) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523114) said:
@tiger5150 said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523097) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523095) said:
@tiger5150 said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523086) said:
Im losing track, one post calling for discussion, the next attacking GnR for discussion, one post flogging a dead horse, the next complaining about flogging a dead horse, often all from the same poster.

Man of my word though.

Have a good weekend Glenn.

Really? A man of your word?

I remember a man gave me his word, out of "respect" that they would remove my real name from the forum because I had had people dox me. I would think that a "man of their word" would keep their word and not intentionally do that.

Should I screenshot our private conversation and share it? Apparently thats OK if its done in proving Im not lying?

Wondering when you were going to chime in.
No one cares who you are in the real world.
No one's trying to ruin your life bro.
You shared your name on here.
Leave it at that.

When did I share my name on here? I didnt.

My RL facebook profile with links to my partner, kids and business was posted on here. I have had people contact in RL. There was a poster of me shared on Discord. After that people thought it was clever to call me my RL name, coincidentally only the Discord bro's.

I specifically told Demps I didnt want my RL name here because I had been doxxed in RL and he deleted a post because of it. But for some reason now its cool to continually post my real name?

You think thats all ok and cool?

Weren't you glenntiger?
I'm on Discord and as far as i know no one has ever shared any personal info about anyone.
It's the same as here except we talk shit about each other and the tigers. No moderation and that hasn't been a problem. No one causing shit. Like an afternoon at the pub
 
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523123) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523121) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523119) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523116) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523111) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523109) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523092) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523091) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523088) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523087) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523084) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523083) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523080) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523079) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523077) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523074) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523072) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523070) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523066) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523064) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523061) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523060) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523055) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523053) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523049) said:
It’s not like we can go out and sign Cleary or Reynolds. Where we are as a club, we’d only be getting a player of the same calibre. Everyone wants to punt him, but no one wants to offer a replacement whose gonna charge us into the finals.

Keep up mate...

Captain Jack is the man.
But you've got a problem with that too.

"He hasn't even put the jersey on yet."

7 Hastings
6 AD

Don't just make things up to justify your argument ... you spent that whole other thread explaining why he shouldn't be captain and now you claim no one's offered the replacement.

Whilst AD is out..
Peachy, Madden, Young Tyrone.

But you know it’s not going to happen. Wish for it all you like, but we both know who the 7 will be.



@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523055) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523053) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523049) said:
It’s not like we can go out and sign Cleary or Reynolds. Where we are as a club, we’d only be getting a player of the same calibre. Everyone wants to punt him, but no one wants to offer a replacement whose gonna charge us into the finals.

Keep up mate...

Captain Jack is the man.
But you've got a problem with that too.

"He hasn't even put the jersey on yet."

7 Hastings
6 AD

Don't just make things up to justify your argument ... you spent that whole other thread explaining why he shouldn't be captain and now you claim no one's offered the replacement.

Whilst AD is out..
Peachy, Madden, Young Tyrone.

But you know it’s not going to happen. Wish for it all you like, but we both know who the 7 will be.

So the conversation is over.

We've put up with the same trash for so long and selection committee in @GNR4LIFE has spoken.

Pot meet kettle.
Dead horse meet stick.

??

Achievements, everyday

Well, no Sheens did when he confirmed Hastings was training at 6.

He also said AD is a 6 ...

Whatever will we do !?

Where's the Nofo thread ?
Can we discuss how he's a woeful winger that can't even run the right direction ?

As I just said, the goal posts are constantly being moved in relation to Brooks. First it was he wasn’t gonna be here next year, then he wasn’t gonna be the halfback round 1. Now we’re at the stage where he’ll be gone when AD is back. What will it be when AD returns to in the centres?

Are you being blatantly ignorant or is it just your character? MY opinion is hoping the decision is made on form. Don't know why you're making it in to something else?

You can run away from that fact if you like, but that’s what’s been happening with the Brooks discussion since the last round against the Dogs.

We'll see. I don't understand your love for mediocrity. Are you happy with the our position year after year? Club needs change. Hastings is change.

I could understand if we’d just signed Cleary or Reynolds or if people were saying that’s who the answer to our problems was. Hastings is going sideways.

Nofo legit goes side ways every game.
You're going to love Hastings.

Only when he’s improving the position for the kick at goal

Troll levels hitting all new highs with a response like that.

That's almost 3 hours of effort today.
Well done.

That was quick wasn’t it. Almost as quick as Brooks pace. Quickest player in the team

Typical. Proof of your mindset

I stopped taking this discussion seriously 2 pages ago. It could be a good, healthy discussion, but it gets ruined cos some want to constantly take shots at others for things unrelated to what we are talking about.

Ok mate. Not worth it.

Yeah, if you have to just stick to footy, what’s the point.

Keep padding that post count brah.
Must matter to you.

That’s what we’re reduced to now, shaming post counts.

?

The fact it gets clearly gets under your skin is humorous to me.

You have to mean something to me to bother me.
You're a flea.
I'm just stating facts.

Mate, if I was that irreverent you’d ignore me, but you don’t. You however are just about there for me which means you aren’t important enough to even acknowledge. I’m sure I’ll still read you taking shots at me to others, however I won’t even think about you from this point on.

Sad
 
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523131) said:
@twentyforty said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523124) said:
I’ll be very disappointed if Brooks leaves after this season.

What would we talk about haha?

Probably go win a grand final with a team like the Knights or something.

Imagine @GNR4LIFE then...
"I told you meat heads !!"
 
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523133) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523131) said:
@twentyforty said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523124) said:
I’ll be very disappointed if Brooks leaves after this season.

What would we talk about haha?

Probably go win a grand final with a team like the Knights or something.

Imagine @GNR4LIFE then...
"I told you meat heads !!"

I wouldn’t be here. I’d be wearing red and blue
 
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523135) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523133) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523131) said:
@twentyforty said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523124) said:
I’ll be very disappointed if Brooks leaves after this season.

What would we talk about haha?

Probably go win a grand final with a team like the Knights or something.

Imagine @GNR4LIFE then...
"I told you meat heads !!"

I wouldn’t be here. I’d be wearing red and blue

You can't do that.

Not after your 10 years of dedication and commitment.
 
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523137) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523135) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523133) said:
@pj said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523131) said:
@twentyforty said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523124) said:
I’ll be very disappointed if Brooks leaves after this season.

What would we talk about haha?

Probably go win a grand final with a team like the Knights or something.

Imagine @GNR4LIFE then...
"I told you meat heads !!"

I wouldn’t be here. I’d be wearing red and blue

You can't do that.

Not after your 10 years of dedication and commitment.

Well no, I mean, Noffa is still here.
 
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523117) said:
@tiger5150 said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523100) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523098) said:
@tiger5150 said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523097) said:
@demps said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523095) said:
@tiger5150 said in [Luke Brooks Yes Or No](/post/1523086) said:
Im losing track, one post calling for discussion, the next attacking GnR for discussion, one post flogging a dead horse, the next complaining about flogging a dead horse, often all from the same poster.

Man of my word though.

Have a good weekend Glenn.

Really? A man of your word?

I remember a man gave me his word, out of "respect" that they would remove my real name from the forum because I had had people dox me. I would think that a "man of their word" would keep their word and not intentionally do that.

Should I screenshot our private conversation and share it? Apparently thats OK if its done in proving Im not lying?

Go for it.

You asked me to remove a reply to some guy who mentioned your name and that was the extent of the conversation.

Two days in a row you've found it necessary to reply to me with some vague dig and it hasnt gone unnoticed.

I'd appreciate it if you would stop with the creepiness.

You would like me to stop my creepiness?

Mate......in a private message, I explained to you that I had been doxxed in RL, with people sharing a link that has links to my RL, my kids, my partner, my business with people attacking me online. For that reason, I asked you to remove a post that linked to my RL name. You stated "I'll respect 'ya" and removed the post.

Now in response to a harmless post, after I explain to you in a private message the very real reason I dont want my name posted here ......you post my name anyway. And ***I'm*** the creepy one.....righto.


You'd think some one who has been exposed to cyber bullying would be more mindful to others...

But no..

No, I would think that once I had explained to you in a private conversation, that I had been doxxed, from THIS FORUM, with RL repurcussions and for that reason I dont want my RL name posted, and you agreed with me.......that you then wouldnt go ahead and post my real name.


What are you trying to achieve with your posts, you're clearly targeting me and trying to hurt my feelings or upset me ? Good job.

Demps......what exactly were you trying to achieve, by posting my real name, after I had previously explained to you that I didnt want my real name posted here because I had been doxxed in this forum with the RL repercussions? What was the purpose of that? I can think of two reasons...to upset me or to promote further RL doxxing. Which was it?

FWIW I genuinely arent trying to hurt your feelings or upset you. My post in this thread was a light hearted post that this thread (including your posts) are a circular argument about everything and its true.

Do you remember your old user name?
I do...

I'd genuinely dont. I lost it in one of the migrations and couldnt log in with my password/email combination. I have had this discussion with someone else that there was a poster here whose username is the same as my first name but it wasnt me.
 
Back
Top