Marion Seve

We haven't seen him at full pace because he can't get to it. He NEVER turns and chases, even blairy yesterday chased down any warrior running away to score. Lawrence watches and jogs because he can't run.
Forget his speed, decision making is no good. Him going for an intercept on our line instead of staying with his winger. He didn't trust brooks inside him which is his fault, all players know you defend from the inside so stay on ur man Lawrence!
The ridiculous drop ball in the in goal area for the fishiahis (spelling) try…. Poor errors by a bloke who is suppose to be our gun centre!
He has been like this since the hip injury. Time is up happy

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
 
you know what, why dont we just drop the whole FG team and see how the holden cup players go! sounds like a great idea.

one week and people want seve and satherwaite in FG…
 
😱pen_mouth: they should give MR T a go can't be any rawer than Radradra lookat him go. Could also alternate as forward or impact player. Can't see why he dont get a shot. Only needs to run over top of opposition.
 
@pHyR3 said:
you know what, why dont we just drop the whole FG team and see how the holden cup players go! sounds like a great idea.

one week and people want seve and satherwaite in FG…
Click to expand...

Lawrence has struggled terribly since his hip injury unfortunately.. Yesterday's loss just highlights how off the pace he is.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
 
Tedesco struggled with his comeback from injury last year, looked slow with little or no footwork.

He seems to be going ok now.
 
Tedesco also came back and played with a broken bone in his hip, was still better than Lawrence.

We all pray we will see Chris get back to even a shade of what he once was, unfortunately though its not just his body possibly hindering him, but also seems to have lost the ability to read the game as well.
 
@happy tiger said:
Everyone realises that Rowdy played wing for 55 minutes and had a part time centre beside him right ??

Rowdy hasn't played wing since at least 2008 or possibly 2009

Soon as he went to the wing he was lost

He hadn't made a bad call in defence all season

Some of the comments are just astounding

I've been one of Rowdy's harshest critics but you have to be fair Again I will ask the question ,when has anyone seen Rowdy at full speed or had an opportunity to be at full speed in 2014
Click to expand...

I'm with you. Not sure why Rowdy is getting lambasted for yesterday. I watched the game again this morning and concentrated on Rowdy because I thought I had missed something. I realised I hadn't. He didn't do much wrong at all, except for the spilled ball that led to a try.

Made some strong tough hit ups.

Sure he is not as quick as he was at 17 but he still has a lot to offer. Would love to see our halves unlock our backline with some open space.
 
Rowdy was always one of my faves (and still is), but the time has come. I'm not the only one to see how terrible he is in defence and accelerating off the mark. I understand he needs time coming back from a pretty bad injury but he's been banged up a few times now and doesn't seem to be able to get back to being the player we love. Hard decision. Nothing would make me happier to see him in a Blues jumper. I hope he gets there again but maybe a few weeks in State Cup might give him that confidence. From his twitter feed and judging by Potter's comments, he killed it in pre-season.
 
@Pyjamaztehboss said:
Rowdy was always one of my faves (and still is), but the time has come. I'm not the only one to see how terrible he is in defence and accelerating off the mark. I understand he needs time coming back from a pretty bad injury but he's been banged up a few times now and doesn't seem to be able to get back to being the player we love. Hard decision. Nothing would make me happier to see him in a Blues jumper. I hope he gets there again but maybe a few weeks in State Cup might give him that confidence. From his twitter feed and judging by Potter's comments, he killed it in pre-season.
Click to expand...

I feel you're right in everything you've said. Because from all reports Rowdy is such a good kid his poor form from 2012-14 has been overlooked while we've all hooked into Blair,Benji etc. the decision we make on Rowdy next year will be second only to Benji in its importance.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
 
@tigerlogic said:
The ridiculous drop ball in the in goal area for the fishiahis (spelling) try…. Poor errors by a bloke who is suppose to be our gun centre!
_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
Click to expand...

Please, if you are hooking blokes for bad fumbles in this week's game, then you are starting next week with half a side. Everyone had a go, none worse than Robbie.
 
@pHyR3 said:
you know what, why dont we just drop the whole FG team and see how the holden cup players go! sounds like a great idea.

one week and people want seve and satherwaite in FG…
Click to expand...

It's been more like two seasons of poor form for Lawrence.
 
Rowdy needs to have more time off, probably in reserve grade to build up his confidence and speed. When he is ready, he can come back.
 
Happy nailed it, Lawrence was having a decent game until he was pushed to the wing.
Wing is now a specialist position, people love a scapegoat
 
@Newtown said:
@pHyR3 said:
you know what, why dont we just drop the whole FG team and see how the holden cup players go! sounds like a great idea.

one week and people want seve and satherwaite in FG…

It's been more like two seasons of poor form for Lawrence.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

2 seasons while playing injured most of the time.

he's been fine this season until he was placed out of position. give him another shot next week
 
@jirskyr said:
@tigerlogic said:
The ridiculous drop ball in the in goal area for the fishiahis (spelling) try…. Poor errors by a bloke who is suppose to be our gun centre!
_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_

Please, if you are hooking blokes for bad fumbles in this week's game, then you are starting next week with half a side. Everyone had a go, none worse than Robbie.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Robbie was shocking, Lawrence worse. I wouldn't hook someone for dropping it, but he alone was a cause for 3 tries, and my suggestion for hooking him is not based on losing one game, it's based in terrible performances last year and this

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
 
@Goose said:
Happy nailed it, Lawrence was having a decent game until he was pushed to the wing.
Wing is now a specialist position, people love a scapegoat
Click to expand...

Certainly did not lose because of Lawrence but he was poor

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
 
@tigerlogic said:
@Goose said:
Happy nailed it, Lawrence was having a decent game until he was pushed to the wing.
Wing is now a specialist position, people love a scapegoat

Certainly did not lose because of Lawrence but he was poor

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

And he was out of position TL
 
after watching Seve against the warriors he is not ready in an way for 1st grade, a very average performance on the weekend.
 
@bp tiger said:
after watching Seve against the warriors he is not ready in an way for 1st grade, a very average performance on the weekend.
Click to expand...

People severly underestimate the difference between the grades
 
@Goose said:
@bp tiger said:
after watching Seve against the warriors he is not ready in an way for 1st grade, a very average performance on the weekend.

People severly underestimate the difference between the grades
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

OFCOURSE he's not ready. My God he has had, what, 4 NYC games? give him time to develop for Christ Sake
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 292 (members: 13, guests: 279)
Back
Top