Match Day Officials

[system]

Shayne Hayne & Chris James

Sideline Officials: Steve Carrall & Ricky McFarlane

Video Referee: Steve Clark

 

[Jazza]

Chris who?

Looks like we've copped one of the new refs after last weekends parra/souths debacle.

 

[innsaneink]

Yay…a rookster to throw missiles at

 

[alien]

Shane Hayne the Pain! This is terrible news!

Steve Clarke video ref is terrible too.

 

[Staks]

Why can't we have Badger every week !!

 

[TigerRock]

shayne hayne is improving doesnt blow the pee out of it anymore, and chris james from what i've seen is pretty good, pretty fair.

 

[PYMBLEPETE]

I will take Shayne Hayne every game; he is a vastly improved referee and generally referees based on a common sense approach.

 

[hybrid_tiger]

As long as it's not that utter dimwit Maxwell I'm happy.

 

[Geo]

Awesome….Kevin Shayne hasn't been to bad lately so he's due....James Hmmmm wasn't he the grand final ref who dudded the 20's last year.....

I was really hoping for Maxwell.....

 

[senexx]

**Shane Hayne Stats**
Penrith 24 games
Penrith Won 9 Lost 15
37.5% success rate
2 wins @ Home, 5 Losses
7 wins Away, 10 losses

Wests Tigers
29 games
Tigers won 13, Lost 16
Success Rate 44.83%
At home 6-6 win/loss
Away 7 wins, 10 losses

Penrith at Home under Hayne 28.57% success
Tigers Away under Hayne 41.18% success

 

[Geo]

OK what is the Tigers away stats at Cua under Hayne?

Maxwell…100% success

 

[Eye_Of_Wests_Tigers]

Don't mind Kevin Shayne Hayne, although sometimes he does blow his whistle to much. Better than bloody Maxwell or Archer…

 

[jackyg]

IMHO, with the exception of maxwell and cummins the refereeing is generally not as bad as people say. no referee is perfect but they're not that bad either.

 

[prattenpark]

Not too concerned about the refs this week - no Maxwell, YAY!

BEst thing i've read though is that they have dropped the stupid new interpretation of the advantage rule - must gain 10 metres in attack for their to be an advantage - which resulted in that farcical Bulldog play at the SFS last Friday where the only acceptable advantage would have been a try. Have gone back to the previous interpretation that leaves it up to each ref to determine if there has been an advantage.

 

[dacoots_tiger]

Thats good news. Ridiculous rule. commensense prevails

 

[joe_s_magpies]

Thank god no Maxwell this week. I could not stand to have him for another game.

 

[triserratops]

they are all maggots!!!!

 

[supercoach]

I will take The man with the tan any day. Anyone barring Maxwell and Archer, both ego driven and over rated.

 

[sunshine_coast_tiger]

I will take The man with the tan any day. Anyone barring Maxwell and Archer, both ego driven and over rated.

Agree 100%. Hope Sheens has had a meeting with Finch to try and ensure Maxwell never refs us again, we can only live in hope :wink:

 

[Aladinsane]

The Wests Tigers Management hs made a official request to not get Maxwell to ref a Wests Tigfers game again this seasonm as they feel he is still "Gun shy" after the fan tackling incident