Matt Lodge must pay $1.2m: US judge

Newtown

Well-known member
Matt Lodge must pay $1.2m: US Judge
By AAP

A New York judge has ordered Matthew Lodge to pay the victims of his Manhattan rampage $US1.234 million in damages.

US District Court Judge Kimba Wood's ruling against Lodge, in which he detailed the terror Lodge inflicted on German tourist Carolin Dekeyser, Manhattan couple Joseph Cartright and Ruth Fowler and their nine-year-old son, comes as the prop attempts to resurrect his NRL career.

The New York law firm representing the victims vowed to recoup every cent of the judge's order despite Lodge living in Australia. "We are looking at any and every method available to us to collect on this judgment including potentially garnishing his future wages," Renan Varghese, a senior associate at Wigdor LLP, told AAP on Thursday.

Lodge was arrested at gunpoint by NYPD officers in the early hours of October 16, 2015\. He was temporarily held in New York's infamous Rikers' Island jail complex until he was bailed out and his then NRL club, Wests Tigers, sacked him.

Lodge, 21, has been working to return to the NRL, linking with Queensland's second tier club Redcliffe Dolphins and this week receiving approval to train with the NRL's Brisbane Broncos. Lodge ignored the civil lawsuit, declining to testify at a hearing or hire a lawyer to mount a defence.

Ms Dekeyser, Mr Cartright and Ms Fowler provided harrowing testimony of the impact the 193cm tall Lodge has had on their lives. The incident began at about 4 am when Ms Dekeyser and a female friend were getting out of a taxi on Manhattan's Upper-West Side, Lodge followed them to an apartment building and yelled "he wanted to take them to Australia". Lodge also violently grabbed Ms Dekeyser by the shoulders "so that she could not escape". "Lodge followed and threatened Dekeyser, stating 'Do you think you're going to die? This is the night you're going to die'," Judge Kimba wrote in his ruling.

Mr Cartright, a resident of the building for more than 20 years, heard the women frantically ringing the intercom, went to the front door and "Lodge grabbed Cartright and made death threats". Lodge forced his way into Mr Cartright's apartment where Ms Fowler and their nine-year-old were sleeping and shouted, "My name is Matthew Lodge. I come in peace. Salaam Alaikum" and smashed furniture, plates and other items. Judge Wood wrote "Lodge put Cartright in a headlock, punched him several times in the head, and shoved him" and "approached the bathroom in which Fowler and her son were, attempted to gain entry, and punched the door, leaving a hole". The family was so terrified by the incident they had to move out of the apartment and their son, who during the incident told his mum "I'm too young to die", suffered from night terrors and had to see a child therapist.

Ms Dekeyser told the court she is "haunted by the fear" that Lodge might seek her out and "suffers from trouble sleeping, night terrors, nervousness, and anxiety" whenever she is in the dark.

Judge Wood's order includes $US525,000 to Mr Cartright, $US400,000 to Ms Fowler and $US250,000 to Ms Dekeyser for emotional distress and punitive damages.

"They are happy with the outcome but no amount of money is going to compensate them for what happened or could make up for what they experienced," Mr Varghese said. "They would gladly give up all of the money to take these events back."

The trio was upset in December when the judge in Lodge's New York criminal case opted against sentencing him to jail. After Lodge completed community service and received alcohol abuse and anger treatment Judge Kate Paek sentenced him to a conditional discharge.

© AAP 2017

Read more at http://www.9news.com.au/world/2017/03/31/08/27/matt-lodge-must-pay-1-2-mln-us-judge#DQAwykeiwzcdqHyp.99
 
@ said:
Good luck getting it out of him.

I know!

I don't for a minute support Lodge in any way, he should be kept away from the NRL permanently. He should have been jailed for what he did, or if mentally ill kept away until that was resolved.

But such a litigious culture in US, you are wronged by someone and only money can make some amends. Only money can begin to repair the damage, your honour. I'd be super surprised if they can do anything about this civil suit now that he's back in Australia. That's why Lodge didn't bother contesting it.

Bearing in mind he's not likely to take a trip to Vegas in his remaining lifetime.
 
He deserved jail time.
The boofhead was lucky no-one in the apartment complex put a Magnum round between his eyes.
Hope karma gets him in some way, shape or form.
Even if he is forced to pay the money, Mumma and Dadda will scrounge up the money for him. Sounds like he has been unaccountable his whole life from reports when this whole thing was current news.
 
Agree with both Jirskyr and FTB.

He's as lucky as he is stupid simply for the reason stated by FTB that no one put a hole in his head.

Those people are just as stupid thinking that he'll pay up. The bloke he flogged is probably entitled to compensation to cover his medicals.
 
@ said:
Agree with both Jirskyr and FTB.

He's as lucky as he is stupid simply for the reason stated by FTB that no one put a hole in his head.

Those people are just as stupid thinking that he'll pay up. The bloke he flogged is probably entitled to compensation to cover his medicals.

Easy solution

Every November 1st 3/4 of his contract goes to pay these people until they are paid off

People querying the monetary aspect of this just remember if he acts like a normal human being …...

When in Rome ........
 
@ said:
@ said:
Agree with both Jirskyr and FTB.

He's as lucky as he is stupid simply for the reason stated by FTB that no one put a hole in his head.

Those people are just as stupid thinking that he'll pay up. The bloke he flogged is probably entitled to compensation to cover his medicals.

Easy solution

Every November 1st 3/4 of his contract goes to pay these people until they are paid off

People querying the monetary aspect of this just remember if he acts like a normal human being …...

When in Rome ........

Except it is a US ruling. His efforts over there have nothing to do with the Australian judicial system (although my knowledge of inter-country rulings between friendly nations are admittedly limited.)

He should have been gaoled for his efforts, not sued.
 
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
Agree with both Jirskyr and FTB.

He's as lucky as he is stupid simply for the reason stated by FTB that no one put a hole in his head.

Those people are just as stupid thinking that he'll pay up. The bloke he flogged is probably entitled to compensation to cover his medicals.

Easy solution

Every November 1st 3/4 of his contract goes to pay these people until they are paid off

People querying the monetary aspect of this just remember if he acts like a normal human being …...

When in Rome ........

Except it is a US ruling. His efforts over there have nothing to do with the Australian judicial system (although my knowledge of inter-country rulings between friendly nations are admittedly limited.)

He should have been gaoled for his efforts, not sued.

Someone get him loaded and load him on a one way ticket to the US :smiling_imp:

I understand what you are saying , I just don't know we overcomplicate the judicial system CB
 
@ said:
@ said:
Agree with both Jirskyr and FTB.

He's as lucky as he is stupid simply for the reason stated by FTB that no one put a hole in his head.

Those people are just as stupid thinking that he'll pay up. The bloke he flogged is probably entitled to compensation to cover his medicals.

Easy solution

Every November 1st 3/4 of his contract goes to pay these people until they are paid off

People querying the monetary aspect of this just remember if he acts like a normal human being …...

When in Rome ........

That's the point he's not in Rome, he's in Roma.

I'm happy for Americans to go for the cash-grab, make it a law, take all the money from all the criminals and let it compensate the victims and fund the jails.

But that's not how it works. It's a civil matter, you need to have the money or the pro-bono agreement to have the lawyer in the first place. Lodge clearly has mental and/or emotional problems and the US solution is to lock him up for a bit, then have the victims pursue him for money.

But of course no amount of money is sufficient compensation they say… they are happy w $1.2M but that's not going to undo what he did. Oh $25M? Maybe that undoes some of it. $50M? Well maybe I can forget for 50.

You get my point. Lodge should be punished but I don't like how American society promotes hitting the criminal wallet as part of justice. What about the folks from poor backgrounds , who aren't adequately supported by society and are disadvantaged and underprivileged? Do you go after those people too? Or just the stupid well-off kids?
 
What a joke, load of hearsay. If the victims claim to be so "terrorised" and in "shock", then how do they remember so picture perfect what occurred that night?

Lodge did the wrong thing, he isn't in the right no matter how you view the situation.

Though suing him for 1million+? Hope he doesn't pay it.
 
The tags on the news article are Matt Lodge and wests tigers…

Why aren't Wayne Bennett Brisbane Broncos also tags for the article? The are the flogs trying to get him back in the NRL???
 
@ said:
What a joke, load of hearsay. If the victims claim to be so "terrorised" and in "shock", then how do they remember so picture perfect what occurred that night?

Lodge did the wrong thing, he isn't in the right no matter how you view the situation.

Though suing him for 1million+? Hope he doesn't pay it.

If you don't want American justice don't do crime in America

Its BS you hide behind the Australian flag

Its like the Bali 9 ,Schapelle Corby people screaming that the death penalty life sentence is wrong

You know what happens if you break the law in other countries
 
@ said:
What a joke, load of hearsay. If the victims claim to be so "terrorised" and in "shock", then how do they remember so picture perfect what occurred that night?

Lodge did the wrong thing, he isn't in the right no matter how you view the situation.

Though suing him for 1million+? Hope he doesn't pay it.

From experience when victims are terrorised and in shock they are very much more likely to remember for the rest of their lives what happened that night.
 
@ said:
@ said:
What a joke, load of hearsay. If the victims claim to be so "terrorised" and in "shock", then how do they remember so picture perfect what occurred that night?

Lodge did the wrong thing, he isn't in the right no matter how you view the situation.

Though suing him for 1million+? Hope he doesn't pay it.

If you don't want American justice don't do crime in America

Its BS you hide behind the Australian flag

Its like the Bali 9 ,Schapelle Corby people screaming that the death penalty life sentence is wrong

You know what happens if you break the law in other countries

Aye but happy there is a difference between criminal law and civil law. The money is part of a civil suit.

Milky is totally off the rails though, it's not a joke, the victims have every right to be still shocked and terrorised, I would remember and experience for a long time any such assault on my privacy and person. Some people remember things very clearly in tense moments, that's no issue.
 

Members online

Back
Top