MELBOURNE STORM SALARY CAP RORTS

Not questioning Deloittes, just the information which will be opened up to them. Frank Stanton is an employee of both Deloittes and News, so go figure…

I also see Hartigan terminated the 'other' Directors to ensure no legal action is continued. Wonder if this would of happened if News didn't own 1/2 the NRL? (News would of sued the are off them)

Looks like the only battle left will be the issue of pay-cuts and the Player Managers having their accreditation torn up...
 
@westTAHger said:
they are fielding an illegal team.
so if they win a game, it has been done illegally.
they can control who makes top 8 or not.
why let them play at all, until they are under the salary cap?

:imp: :smiling_imp: :imp: :smiling_imp: :imp:
As 1 Meatloaf sung: "You took the words right out of my mouth!!!"
 
Gallop slams Storm
15/07/2010 3:05 PM
Adam Lucius
Sportal

NRL boss David Gallop has labelled the extent of Melbourne's salary cap cheating as 'damning in the extreme', saying the stunning findings of an independent forensic investigation fully vindicates the decision to strip the club of two premierships and deny it competition points this season.

Just three hours after News Limited chief executive John Hartigan revealed a report from accounting firm Deloitte had found the Storm rorted the salary cap to the tune of $3.17m over five years, Gallop defended his organisation's handling of the affair and took a swipe at those responsible for the systematic cheating.

"The disclosures by the Storm's owner (News Ltd) this morning were damning in the extreme," he said.

"It’s time for everyone to face the facts and focus on the club's future."

"Fact one - Melbourne Storm systematically breached the salary cap and they are well and truly over it today."

"Fact two - The NRL issued its penalties on the basis of breaches that the club and (chairman) Dr (Rob) Moodie openly admitted to."

"Dr Moodie, on behalf of his board, publicly accepted the penalties imposed (on April 22)."

"Fact three – The fact that the breaches go beyond even those admissions is an indictment on the directors who were overseeing the club and a chairman who signed statutory declarations that the club was complying with the salary cap."

"Fact four - The true victims of the cheating are not only Storm fans and the innocent parties at the club, but the other fifteen clubs and their fans who lost the chance to compete fairly for players."

"Fact five - There is a future for Melbourne Storm and we are keen to work with the club’s new management to do all that can be done within the rules to make it a successful one."

Gallop added the NRL remain 100 per cent convinced that the penalties imposed on Melbourne when the salary cap breaches first came to light were 'appropriate' despite the extent of the cheating now being much larger than first thought.

He also took aim at former Storm chairman Moodie, sacked this week by News Ltd, and the ex-directors who have launched legal action against the NRL over those penalties.

"Let me address some of the nonsense emanating from Dr Moodie and his team in recent days," Gallop said.

"To say that they are the only ones interested in the Storm's future and of putting the ‘N’ in the NRL is PR-driven rubbish designed to smother the facts."

"Their back-flip on their acceptance of the penalties has caused great damage and slowed down the club's progress towards successfully getting back on track."
 
@westTAHger said:
they are fielding an illegal team.
so if they win a game, it has been done illegally.
they can control who makes top 8 or not.
why let them play at all, until they are under the salary cap?

All true, but they will play - TV deals tie the NRL to providing 8 games a week (excluding byes).

I liked the idea of having the appropriate value of players being selected at random to sit the week out, and reserves or 'juniors' taking their place.
 
@westTAHger said:
they are fielding an illegal team.
so if they win a game, it has been done illegally.
they can control who makes top 8 or not.
why let them play at all, until they are under the salary cap?

This is 100% correct.

The only action the NRL should of done is Terminate them from the Competition.

Why didn't this happen???
 
@Tiger Watto said:
Not questioning Deloittes, just the information which will be opened up to them. Frank Stanton is an employee of both Deloittes and News, so go figure…

I also see Hartigan terminated the 'other' Directors to ensure no legal action is continued. Wonder if this would of happened if News didn't own 1/2 the NRL? (News would of sued the are off them)

Looks like the only battle left will be the issue of pay-cuts and the Player Managers having their accreditation torn up...

They were terminated for refusing to cooperate with the investigation and for failing to meet due diligence requirements as Directors under Corporate law!

Moodie is a grade-A dunce and fraud!
 
13 Players… That's a whole team...

Cronk & Inglis have been asked to return their money :smiley:

There is no solution here, other than expulsion...
 
@Tiger Watto said:
@westTAHger said:
they are fielding an illegal team.
so if they win a game, it has been done illegally.
they can control who makes top 8 or not.
why let them play at all, until they are under the salary cap?

This is 100% correct.

The only action the NRL should of done is Terminate them from the Competition.

Why didn't this happen???

Because the NRL are under contract to Fox Sports and channel 9 to show 8 games per week.
By terminating the Storm for the year, that would make it a 7 game weekend and a breach of contract by the NRL.

In my opinion they had no choice but to do what they had to do.
 
Anyone saying the Storm should have been kicked out of the comp this year hasn't thought through their suggestion.

The NRL are obliged to have 8 games per week (excluding the bye weeks).

The draw is so that not all teams play everyone else twice, so giving byes instead of playing would stuff things up further.

Bringing in a makeshift team such as the Central Coast Bears to take their place would not help because there is no way they could get up to be competitive with no notice.

What we have is making the best of a bad situation…
 
@Juro said:
Anyone saying the Storm should have been kicked out of the comp this year hasn't thought through their suggestion.

The NRL are obliged to have 8 games per week (excluding the bye weeks).

The draw is so that not all teams play everyone else twice, so giving byes instead of playing would stuff things up further.

Bringing in a makeshift team such as the Central Coast Bears to take their place would not help because there is no way they could get up to be competitive with no notice.

What we have is making the best of a bad situation…

Completely agree Juro.

Also, there were already teams that had played the over capped Melbourne before the breach was found out. So it would have been completely unfair to those teams if Melbourne were forced to restructure the team in any way… or drop out.

Which is the same reason why they couldn't drop necessary players and then start playing for points.

The NRL came up with the only solution possible. They have received a drumming, but I think the way they handled it was very well thought through.
 
I find it interesting that Israel Folau has never been mentioned.

I wonder if that is why he left the Storm. Maybe he, or someone advising him, smelt a rat and didn't want to be part of it. If so he certainly gains in stature.
 
My idea would be clear the player ranks out and start them from scratch like a new franchise, and have the nrl grade the contracts they offer, so they don't offer 100 000 for inglis etc.
 
Watching the Warrior v Storm game and sore a banner in the crowd:

"The Worlds Most Expensive Wooden Spoon"

:laughing: :laughing: :laughing:
 
Back
Top