Memo To Mitch and Luke
- Thread starter Jux
- Start date
stevetiger
New member
@Milky said:
This is pretty funny. I don't think that Brooks or Robbie are state cup players though.
Harvey
Well-known member
@Milky said:
You are showing almost as much generosity as JT. 1/2 of these are Ron Massey cup players.
MacDougall
New member
Brooks and Moses have the skill to be that good, they are just at a club with a losing culture, surrounded by plodder forwards that get dominated through the middle by any team with size and aggression and years of coaches showing no accountability to poor performances by wielding the selection axe.
If Moses was the six at the Cowboys, he'd be carving up good and proper. If Brooks was the half at the Sharks, he'd be carving up good and proper.
We expect them to dominate, we expect too much. They are talented young players that are being toxified by a terrible club. They should both leave.
If Moses was the six at the Cowboys, he'd be carving up good and proper. If Brooks was the half at the Sharks, he'd be carving up good and proper.
We expect them to dominate, we expect too much. They are talented young players that are being toxified by a terrible club. They should both leave.
MacDougall
New member
Thurston himself would be sucking behind this pack.
Harvey
Well-known member
@MacDougall said:
They were ordinary last night. Lawrence stood up. Grant & Halatau injured, the rest were MIA.
its about time everyone on this forum realize that its not brooks and moses fault, yes there not playing great football, but lets put the blame where it belongs our FORWARD PACK IS CRAP and even if we had JT and cronk as our 1/2s they too would stuggle. club needs to clean out are so call forwards and get some real forwards.
tigermac88
New member
@Jux said:
Milford (and maybe Hunt) is the only one in this list worth that money. The rest I wouldn't be forking out $800k for
Masterton
Well-known member
@bp tiger said:
True, but they've still have to make tackles.
At 0-0 last night brooks came off the line looking for an intercept and the raiders scored their 1st try.
You can't blame the forwards there, our halves would look better in a good side…..but they still have glaring problems in their play. If they develop???? they could be decent players 2-3 years from now. But they are not worth $600k a year each ATM.
The only thing that both IMO are very smart about is that both have been holding off on their contracts because they probably realize that their careers are probably more enhanced playing elsewhere.....even on less money.
For example, Terry Lamb was a great player and he was a star in a terrible Wests team in the 80's. He moved to the bulldogs and the rest is history. Had he stayed at Wests back then.....I think mentally and physically he would have just been crushed in a team copping a flogging week in week out.
You can't blame the forwards there, our halves would look better in a good side…..but they still have glaring problems in their play. If they develop???? they could be decent players 2-3 years from now. But they are not worth $600k a year each ATM.
The only thing that both IMO are very smart about is that both have been holding off on their contracts because they probably realize that their careers are probably more enhanced playing elsewhere.....even on less money.
For example, Terry Lamb was a great player and he was a star in a terrible Wests team in the 80's. He moved to the bulldogs and the rest is history. Had he stayed at Wests back then.....I think mentally and physically he would have just been crushed in a team copping a flogging week in week out.
Before the game stareted, Fox were showing the usual warm ups.
Now im not a Farah fan at all, but he was partnered with someone I don't remember and they belting shoulders and chest against each other and it looked very solid indeed. They then cut to Brooks and his partner. They were barely touching and looked very disinterested. Supports the rumour that Brooks is a terrible trainer and not prepared to do the hard yards.
Looked like he was either lazy, or thinking of another team he wants to be with. It wasnt a good look. I wonder if anyone else noticed? It certainly reflected how they were playing an hour later
Now im not a Farah fan at all, but he was partnered with someone I don't remember and they belting shoulders and chest against each other and it looked very solid indeed. They then cut to Brooks and his partner. They were barely touching and looked very disinterested. Supports the rumour that Brooks is a terrible trainer and not prepared to do the hard yards.
Looked like he was either lazy, or thinking of another team he wants to be with. It wasnt a good look. I wonder if anyone else noticed? It certainly reflected how they were playing an hour later
WestsSupporter
New member
My memo to the Broses twins:
If you continue to hold the club ransom, while spitting up that rubbish football, you'll quickly become unpopular figures at the club.
If you continue to hold the club ransom, while spitting up that rubbish football, you'll quickly become unpopular figures at the club.
Harvey
Well-known member
@Swordy said:
He was partnered with Tedesco
stevetiger
New member
@Harvey said:
That sort of ends the whole point being made within that post.
I think Brooks really put in against Canberra. He was running fast and hard and he gave it a shot. He needs a lot of work to become a polished NRL player but I think on the right money he deserves much more of a go.
stevetiger
New member
@hobbo2803 said:
That is a bit harsh, He has had an ordinary year. I'm starting to see something there with him though but he needs a lot of work.
Our spine really needs a lot of work. Tedesco is a weapon but he needs to be utilised better and he needs some support.
