Miller
- Thread starter mtd
- Start date
bonstonker
New member
still not seeing it.
Joel Helmes
Well-known member
The jury is still out imo.
@bonstonker said:
Why dont you take the same attitude with Miller as youre prepared to do with Tedesco?
just start him and let him grow.
if we are going to rebuild you have to start right here right now.
I know theyre both green, I know Teddy shows a huge amount of potential, more than most rookies coming thru…..how long does Miller get? How long do we persist?
When we conced defeat in his development if it occurs at all, its back to square one
Me - Im prepared to give him a season, another off season and hopefully midway thru 2014 hes starting to really control games.
G
Guest
Guest
He should be persisted with for now IMO. Defensively he looks stronger than last year, he just needs to gradually start controlling more of the play and Benji needs to sit back and wait a bit. If Miller doesn't aim up, then I'd be giving serious consideration to partnering Benji and Sirro again.
bonstonker
New member
@innsaneink said:
teddy has already shown he has the tools and miller hasn't.
that's all i'm looking for.
i saw it early with lui,and why i was prepared to stick with him while he matured.unfortunately off the field he didn't.which was my biggest concern with him starting the 2011 season.
moltzen it was obvious he didn't have the tools in the halves,and the reason i said early on he was the most over rated player in this squad in 2009,especially the myth about his ball playing ability.
i'm not asking him to control games,just show me something that gives me confidence that all of our attack doesn't revolve around farah and benji 100% of the time.
right now i'm not seeing it.
Its hard to argue with your point - tools- …...but I can see potential, I know thats no guarantee....but I know with patience persistence and faith what were not seeing can be produced eventually.....much like Lui's defence eventually improved
Hard for a rookie half behind a pack that gets dominated more often than not
Hard for a rookie half behind a pack that gets dominated more often than not
S
system
Guest
@bonstonker said:
I don't see it either. How many games are we prepared to lose to find out he isn't the right choice.
_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
Who do you suggest then, guest?
S
system
Guest
@1974semifinal said:
I'm afraid I have to agree with you . The bigger packs are going to dominate us.
_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
i said it last year molzten was not the answer at 1/2 and i will say it again miller is not the answer was terrible in attack, his defence is good but he is so predicable in attack and just seems to do things so slowly that the other side has no descions to make in defence.
i dont know the answer but he is not it.
i dont know the answer but he is not it.
Tiger_Watto
New member
The day this kid grabs Marshall by the jumper and drags him to where he wants him, is the day we will realise we have a Halfback… Until he is prepared to take charge, his career at the Tigers will be stiffeled.
I believe this kid can be something...
Fire Up Milky... Dont let your career be determined by other players!
I believe this kid can be something...
Fire Up Milky... Dont let your career be determined by other players!
simonthetiger
New member
I thought he went ok.
Bit premature to be writing him off.
Bit premature to be writing him off.
snowleopard
New member
@Tiger Watto said:
Agree 100% Watto. Watching the game Miller on Saturday night live and then on replay he has no chance with Robbie or Benji running the show and if he doesn't make a statement will go no where fast. When he was running the show in NYC he developed a great partnership with Koro and together he set up and Koro scored many tries. Not once have I seen him be given or take the opportunity to work with Koro so far. Why? Cause if you watch Benji he determines where the ball is going to go after 3 hit ups and the crosses over to try and control the play. Until Potter tells Benji (and Robbie for that matter) to let Miller have a go in his own right ..nothing will ever change.
Saturnalia
Well-known member
Needs time to develop and cement his role with Benji and Robbie.
Once the spine and Potter figure out exactly what the plan is (and i'm not convinced there is a plan), We'll see everyone settle and the machine will work much more fluidly.
Then again I know nothing about coaching so who knows.
Once the spine and Potter figure out exactly what the plan is (and i'm not convinced there is a plan), We'll see everyone settle and the machine will work much more fluidly.
Then again I know nothing about coaching so who knows.
1974semifinal
New member
@Sataris said:
yes . it was only the first real/type game , but it looked a bit Sheens like. Maybe because it was Farah and Benji still running the show and no one too sure what show was on..I see Benji can still manage to find the man when he kicks.
#7 is cursed. Will this forum ever agree on our 7? Not since Scott Prince really. Lui had potentially for our love and support then he had to go and Jake the Mus his mrs. Least he had mongrel (albeit off the field). As long as we move forward. Give Miller a go there, at least half a season (thats what Lui had). I just dont want to see us go backwards, Motlzen had his crack, he was no good. He's now looking like losing the fullback spot too. Wonder if he wishes he went to dragons. I do.
Staff online
-
DempsModerator