TigersFan4Life
New member
- Joined
- Jul 13, 2009
- Messages
- 752
I don't like the McIntyre System and I know I'm not alone in feeling that way. My main gripe with it is that, compared to the AFL finals format it does not produce as many quality matchups, ie. games pitting the top four teams against each other. I also don't like how some teams have to wait until the final game of the first weekend has been played before finding out if they are safe or not. You should know immediately, win or lose, if you'll still be alive for the next week.
My format might look pretty outrageous at first but when you realise all the quality matches it produces I think it would be pretty exciting. It's a SIX-WEEK , twelve-game top-eight finals series, made possible by reducing the home & away season by two weeks to 24 rounds, during which each team plays 22 games. To add some extra intrigue, on the Monday after the season ends the NRL would hold a draw to determine the matchups for the opening weekend. Rather than the games automatically being 1v4, 2v3, 5v8 and 6v7, the draw would select one of eight possible schedules. These would be:
1\. 1v4 5v8, 2v3 6v7
2\. 1v4 6v7, 2v3 5v8
3\. 1v4 6v8, 2v3 5v7
4\. 1v4 5v7, 2v3 6v8
5\. 1v3 6v8, 2v4 5v7
6\. 1v3 5v7, 2v4 6v8
7\. 1v3 6v7, 2v4 5v8
8\. 1v3 5v8, 2v4 6v7
Okay, say for example matchup 3 is selected.
The matchups for WEEK ONE of the finals would be:
Game A: 6v8
Game B: 5v7
Game C: 2v3
Game D: 1v4
The losers of Game A and B are eliminated while the winners of Games C and D progress directly to week three. This is exactly how the AFL system works.
Moving on to WEEK TWO, the matchups would be:
Game E: Winner Game A v Loser Game D
Game F: Winner Game B v Loser Game C
The losers of these two games would be eliminated, leaving us with four teams going into week three. That's where my system changes from that of the AFL and actually resembles something like the old NSWRL top 5 system. In week three the winners of Games C and D play the winners of Games E and F. However, the week three games are not elimination matchups. The winners proceed to a Grand Final qualifier in week four while the losers clash in an elimination match in week four.
WEEK THREE matchups:
Game G: Winner Game C v Winner Game E
Game H: Winner Game D v Winner Game F
WEEK FOUR matchups:
Game I: Loser Game G v Loser Game H
Game J: Winner Game G v Winner Game H
The winner of Game J proceeds straight to the Grand Final. The winner of Game I plays the loser of Game J in week five. The loser of Game I is eliminated.
WEEK FIVE matchups:
Game K: Winner Game I v Loser Game J
The winner of Game K proceeds to the Grand Final, where they will play the winner of Game J.
WEEK SIX - GRAND FINAL
Game L: Winner Game J v Winner Game K
***
So, if all games were to be won by the higher-placed team, this is how they would proceed:
WEEK ONE
6v8
5v7
2v3
1v4
WEEK TWO
4v6
3v5
WEEK THREE
2v4
1v3
WEEK FOUR
3v4
1v2
WEEK FIVE
2v3
WEEK SIX
1v2
***
Looking at the various matchups it appears that the top teams have a pretty tough run. The 1st and 2nd placed teams would not play anyone outside of the top four. But isn't this what we want to see in the finals anyway? I don't know about you, but I don't find much intrigue or excitement in the prospect of 1v8 and 2v7 in that first week, even though some upsets have occured. during the finals I want to see the top teams smashing the hell out of each other, not dominating the ones who just scraped in. The bottom teams should have to fight it out amongst themselves to earn the right to take on the top teams.
My format might look pretty outrageous at first but when you realise all the quality matches it produces I think it would be pretty exciting. It's a SIX-WEEK , twelve-game top-eight finals series, made possible by reducing the home & away season by two weeks to 24 rounds, during which each team plays 22 games. To add some extra intrigue, on the Monday after the season ends the NRL would hold a draw to determine the matchups for the opening weekend. Rather than the games automatically being 1v4, 2v3, 5v8 and 6v7, the draw would select one of eight possible schedules. These would be:
1\. 1v4 5v8, 2v3 6v7
2\. 1v4 6v7, 2v3 5v8
3\. 1v4 6v8, 2v3 5v7
4\. 1v4 5v7, 2v3 6v8
5\. 1v3 6v8, 2v4 5v7
6\. 1v3 5v7, 2v4 6v8
7\. 1v3 6v7, 2v4 5v8
8\. 1v3 5v8, 2v4 6v7
Okay, say for example matchup 3 is selected.
The matchups for WEEK ONE of the finals would be:
Game A: 6v8
Game B: 5v7
Game C: 2v3
Game D: 1v4
The losers of Game A and B are eliminated while the winners of Games C and D progress directly to week three. This is exactly how the AFL system works.
Moving on to WEEK TWO, the matchups would be:
Game E: Winner Game A v Loser Game D
Game F: Winner Game B v Loser Game C
The losers of these two games would be eliminated, leaving us with four teams going into week three. That's where my system changes from that of the AFL and actually resembles something like the old NSWRL top 5 system. In week three the winners of Games C and D play the winners of Games E and F. However, the week three games are not elimination matchups. The winners proceed to a Grand Final qualifier in week four while the losers clash in an elimination match in week four.
WEEK THREE matchups:
Game G: Winner Game C v Winner Game E
Game H: Winner Game D v Winner Game F
WEEK FOUR matchups:
Game I: Loser Game G v Loser Game H
Game J: Winner Game G v Winner Game H
The winner of Game J proceeds straight to the Grand Final. The winner of Game I plays the loser of Game J in week five. The loser of Game I is eliminated.
WEEK FIVE matchups:
Game K: Winner Game I v Loser Game J
The winner of Game K proceeds to the Grand Final, where they will play the winner of Game J.
WEEK SIX - GRAND FINAL
Game L: Winner Game J v Winner Game K
***
So, if all games were to be won by the higher-placed team, this is how they would proceed:
WEEK ONE
6v8
5v7
2v3
1v4
WEEK TWO
4v6
3v5
WEEK THREE
2v4
1v3
WEEK FOUR
3v4
1v2
WEEK FIVE
2v3
WEEK SIX
1v2
***
Looking at the various matchups it appears that the top teams have a pretty tough run. The 1st and 2nd placed teams would not play anyone outside of the top four. But isn't this what we want to see in the finals anyway? I don't know about you, but I don't find much intrigue or excitement in the prospect of 1v8 and 2v7 in that first week, even though some upsets have occured. during the finals I want to see the top teams smashing the hell out of each other, not dominating the ones who just scraped in. The bottom teams should have to fight it out amongst themselves to earn the right to take on the top teams.