NRL All Stars. vs. Indigenous All Stars. (your team)

T

tiger91

New member
Just watching the 2010 All Stars game and it got me wondering -

If your were the only selector, who would be in your NRL All Stars team or if you follow the Indigenous side, your Indigenous All Stars Team?

NRL All Stars:

1\. Dugan (CAN)
2\. Nightingale (STI)
3\. Jennings (PEN)
4\. Shaun Kenny-Dowell (SYD)
5\. Vatuvei (WAR)
6\. Marshall (NZ capt.)
7\. Cronk (MELB)
8\. Scott/Tamou (COW)
9\. Smith (AUS capt.)
10\. Burgess (SOU)
11\. Ellis (WST)
12\. Blair (NZ vc)
13\. Gallen (AUS vc)

14\. Hayne (PAR)
15\. Gidley (NEW)
16\. Gibbs (CRO)
17\. Douglas (GCT)
18\. Gillett (BRI)
19\. Watmough (MAN)
20\. Hodgkinson (CBY)
\
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
Wow, just occurred to me that for the first time that I can remember our side will have three representatives (before anyone jumps on me, yes I know two are by default and it's hardly a rep game.)
 
Hi all before I put both my teams up do I remember hearing that Preston Campbell was playing this year even though he was retired ??
 
Happy Tiger, I havnt heard that but it wouldn't surprise me if he played. It's his creation after all.

And Cultured Bogan, it's very exciting to think that 3 WT players will be involved, but the actual "WT selected player" is who I'm keen to hear about. My money is on Ellis, but it was hard not to think of Lawrence, Aysford, Galloway and Farah when I was picking our player.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
I think Ellis will get the nod. All my mates who are supporters of other teams all hold him in high regard.
 
1 Slater
2 Vatuvei
3 Cooper
4 Lawrence
5 Dugan
6 Benji
7 DCE
8 Scott
9 Cam Smith
10 Burgess
11 Hindmarsh
12 Blair
13 Gallen
14 Ennis
15 Gidley
16 Lewis
17 Bailey
18 Pierce
19 Wallace
 
1\. Josh Dugan (Canberra)
2.Manu Vatuvei (Warriors)
3\. Michael Jennings (Panthers)
4\. Matt Cooper (Saints)
5\. Akuila Uate (Knights)
6\. Benji Marshall (New Zealand Captain)
7\. Cooper Cronk (Storm)
8\. Matt Scott (Cowboys)
9\. Cam Smith (Australian Captain)
10\. Sam Burgess (Souths)
11\. Adam Blair (New Zealand Vice-Cap)
12\. Gareth Ellis (Tigers)
13\. Paul Gallen (Australian Vice Captain)

14\. James Graham (Bulldogs)
15\. Luke Bailey (Titans)
16\. Anthony Watmough (Manly)
17\. Jarryd Hayne (Parramatta)

18\. Alex Glenn (Brisbane)
19\. Jeremy Smith (Cronulla)
20\. Anthony Minichello (Roosters)
 
Cmon Sheensy Farah for Australia vice captain and we have 4 players in the team.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
Lol Sabre.

That would definitely be something. Something I wouldn't mind seeing either, but I doubt we will.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
@benjibrotown said:
1\. Josh Dugan (Canberra)
2.Manu Vatuvei (Warriors)
3\. Michael Jennings (Panthers)
4\. Matt Cooper (Saints)
5\. Akuila Uate (Knights)
6\. Benji Marshall (New Zealand Captain)
7\. Cooper Cronk (Storm)
8\. Matt Scott (Cowboys)
9\. Cam Smith (Australian Captain)
10\. Sam Burgess (Souths)
11\. Adam Blair (New Zealand Vice-Cap)
12\. Gareth Ellis (Tigers)
13\. Paul Gallen (Australian Vice Captain)

14\. James Graham (Bulldogs)
15\. Luke Bailey (Titans)
16\. Anthony Watmough (Manly)
17\. Jarryd Hayne (Parramatta)

18\. Alex Glenn (Brisbane)
19\. Jeremy Smith (Cronulla)
20\. Anthony Minichello (Roosters)
Click to expand...

That would be my team, except I'd trade Alex Glenn for Matt Gillett and Minichello for Sam Perrett.
 
I thought they changed it to one from each club, benji, smith (who I assume is the new aus capt) and 2 coaches picks. That being said, my team

1\. Hayne (Parra)
2\. Vatuvei (Warriors)
3\. Jennings (Panthers)
4\. Lawrence (Tigers)
5\. Uate (Knights)
6\. Marshall (New Zealand)
7\. Cronk (Storm)
8\. Shillington (Raiders)
9\. Smith (Australia)
10\. McGuire (Broncos)
11\. Stewart (Sea Eagles)
12\. Burgess (Rabbitohs)
13\. Gallen (Sharks)

14\. Bird (Titans)
15\. Graham (Bulldogs)
16\. Nu'uasala (Roosters)
17\. Sims (Cowboys)
18\. Merrin (Dragons)

I tried to mix it up a little with some young blood, along with some experienced guys.

and whoever Wayne wants
 
what we need to do is organise a mass vote to get someone into the team - someone unexpected… using proxy connnections..
\
\
I propose perennial forum "Underdog"

Mitch F'N Brown.

ITS TIME TO JUMP ON THE BROWNWAGON!!!!!

We need to spam the vote and get Mitch Brown into the All Stars Squad....

WHOS WITH ME!!!!???
\
\
**crickets**
 
Do they allow tourists on the 4N to compete in this game?

Theyre always complaining about too much footy…doubt there'll be any Manly players either
 
I think the 4 Nations is over by the time the All Stars Clash comes around. 4N is over by early/mid december I think and by memory All stars is Febuary.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
@tiger91 said:
I think the 4 Nations is over by the time the All Stars Clash comes around. 4N is over by early/mid december I think and by memory All stars is Febuary.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
Click to expand...

Yeah I know that - but these guys do need a break of sorts
This is a mickey mouse game, leave it for the up & comers…
Give the rep stars a breather
 
@innsaneink said:
@tiger91 said:
I think the 4 Nations is over by the time the All Stars Clash comes around. 4N is over by early/mid december I think and by memory All stars is Febuary.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED

Yeah I know that - but these guys do need a break of sorts
This is a mickey mouse game, leave it for the up & comers…
Give the rep stars a breather
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Because of the unlimited interchange they don't spend to long on the field Ink
Who knows maybe a few of our main competitors for the premiership might lose a player for the season As long as they aren't Qlders as well
 
Ah sorry Insaneink, I misunderstood what you were getting at. I thought it was purely a question of timing the All Stars to coincide with the 4N.
\
\
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
assuming everyone is available, and the premise of 1 from each club, plus the captains this is my 18

1\. Slater (melbourne)
2 J Nightingale (Saints)
3 Shaun Kenny Dowell (Roosters)
4 Chris Lawrence (WT)
5 Jarryd Hayne (parra)
6 Benji Marshall(NZ)
7 Shaun Johnson (warriors)

8 Sam Burgess (Souths)
9 Cam Smith (Aus)
10 Matt Scott (Cowboys)
11 Glenn Stewart (Manly)
12 Luke Lewis (panthers)
13 Paul Gallen (Sharks)

Reserves
14 K Gidley (Knights)
15 Alex Glenn (Brisbane)
15 Shaun Fensom (Canberra)
17 Luke Bailey (Gold Coast)
18\. Josh Morris (Bulldogs)

plus the coaches choices

I'd go Cronk & Gillett for them
18
 
@Goose said:
assuming everyone is available, and the premise of 1 from each club, plus the captains this is my 18

1\. Slater (melbourne)
2 J Nightingale (Saints)
3 Shaun Kenny Dowell (Roosters)
4 Chris Lawrence (WT)
5 Jarryd Hayne (parra)
6 Benji Marshall(NZ)
7 Shaun Johnson (warriors)

8 Sam Burgess (Souths)
9 Cam Smith (Aus)
10 Matt Scott (Cowboys)
11 Glenn Stewart (Manly)
12 Luke Lewis (panthers)
13 Paul Gallen (Sharks)

Reserves
14 K Gidley (Knights)
15 Alex Glenn (Brisbane)
15 Shaun Fensom (Canberra)
17 Luke Bailey (Gold Coast)
18\. Josh Morris (Bulldogs)

plus the coaches choices

I'd go Cronk & Gillett for them
18
Click to expand...

Mate you missed the VC for both countries
 
the new selection policy is not the VC, but coached choice. 2 skippers, 1 per club and 2 to the coach
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 403 (members: 11, guests: 392)
Back
Top