NRL The Best 2010/19

[mike]

I really thought SKD would be a sleeper. Clearly not ?

Sailor didn’t even play in that decade ?

Yeah I’m stumped how he OR Koroibete beats out players like Ferguson and Rapana... many distractions and time spent out of the game for both of them but at their peak not many better.

Valentine Holmes? Please. That needs recountin’

Holmes is overrated

 

[GNR4LIFE]

I really thought SKD would be a sleeper. Clearly not ?

Sailor didn’t even play in that decade ?

Yeah I’m stumped how he OR Koroibete beats out players like Ferguson and Rapana... many distractions and time spent out of the game for both of them but at their peak not many better.

Valentine Holmes? Please. That needs recountin’

Holmes is overrated

Absolutely

 

[hobbo1]

I really thought SKD would be a sleeper. Clearly not ?

Sailor didn’t even play in that decade ?

Yeah I’m stumped how he OR Koroibete beats out players like Ferguson and Rapana... many distractions and time spent out of the game for both of them but at their peak not many better.

Valentine Holmes? Please. That needs recountin’

Just vote and stop whinging ?

 

[Geo]

1 Val Holmes (not even a winger)

Ok this goes against my better judgement and will make it harder when I do the votes but this is surely a gee up...Holmes has played more games on the wing in his career than he has Fullback including Grand Finals and Origin..

 

[Tigerboy]

I really thought SKD would be a sleeper. Clearly not ?

Sailor didn’t even play in that decade ?

Yeah I’m stumped how he OR Koroibete beats out players like Ferguson and Rapana... many distractions and time spent out of the game for both of them but at their peak not many better.

Valentine Holmes? Please. That needs recountin’

Holmes is overrated

Had nice record for about two whole years

 

[Tigerboy]

1 Val Holmes (not even a winger)

Ok this goes against my better judgement and will make it harder when I do the votes but this is surely a gee up...Holmes has played more games on the wing in his career than he has Fullback including Grand Finals and Origin..

He’s no winger in the comp today , I’m not trying to gee you up at all I really do not rate him.

Fox could probably move up to 6 - he’s lucky to get that high. Holmes left the game and hasn’t been as good for about 3 seasons. Checked out a lot of his NFL trials too so can certainly comment... would you like me to scrap my vote?? Kinda goes against what you said about objectively voting because I’m actually trying to use form lines and ability, not just stats. If you rely on just stats then Hodges probably had a better record than Inglis. At FB though?

Different story... Holmes on the wing (diff story)

*somebody* should’ve had him at FB lol

 

[hobbo1]

@baconandeggs

Wake up !

 

[Tigerboy]

1 Val Holmes (not even a winger)

Ok this goes against my better judgement and will make it harder when I do the votes but this is surely a gee up...Holmes has played more games on the wing in his career than he has Fullback including Grand Finals and Origin..

He won with the Sharks ...cheated. I’ll give him his due on career when/if he makes the international level again, and in his preferred position, seeing as that’s how I’ll be judging his natural ability (many others agree)

Otherwise Origin, he’s just another Gagai.

@hobbo1 don’t even pretend that you don’t agree... nah I don’t mind re-doing it Geo but it was a totally objective vote. Doesn’t help that he’s a stinking, dirty Queenslander! It shouldn’t make it harder for you to count votes, maybe to comprehend the subjective nature?

 

[Geo]

1 Val Holmes (not even a winger)

Ok this goes against my better judgement and will make it harder when I do the votes but this is surely a gee up...Holmes has played more games on the wing in his career than he has Fullback including Grand Finals and Origin..

He’s no winger in the comp today , I’m not trying to gee you up at all I really do not rate him.

Fox could probably move up to 6 - he’s lucky to get that high. Holmes left the game and hasn’t been as good for about 3 seasons. Checked out a lot of his NFL trials too so can certainly comment... would you like me to scrap my vote?? Kinda goes against what you said about objectively voting because I’m actually trying to use form lines and ability, not just stats. If you rely on just stats then Hodges probably had a better record than Inglis. At FB though?

Different story... Holmes on the wing (diff story)

*somebody* should’ve had him at FB lol

Seriously it's a bit of fun no need to get narky..you can have your vote that's what it's all about no need to jump down people's throats cause the have a different view to yours..

Seriously...I don't really have to do this ..just thought it would be a bit of FUN during these troubled times...just enjoy it for what it is...

 

[Tigerlily]

I really thought SKD would be a sleeper. Clearly not ?

Sailor didn’t even play in that decade ?

Yeah I’m stumped how he OR Koroibete beats out players like Ferguson and Rapana... many distractions and time spent out of the game for both of them but at their peak not many better.

Valentine Holmes? Please. That needs recountin’

Just vote and stop whinging ?

Not wrong...Considering Val played over 100 games and as Geo pointed out the majority of that was on the wing...So if that’s the way people are voting, it doesn’t bode well for future voting on some of these player selections...

 

[Tigerboy]

1 Val Holmes (not even a winger)

Ok this goes against my better judgement and will make it harder when I do the votes but this is surely a gee up...Holmes has played more games on the wing in his career than he has Fullback including Grand Finals and Origin..

He’s no winger in the comp today , I’m not trying to gee you up at all I really do not rate him.

Fox could probably move up to 6 - he’s lucky to get that high. Holmes left the game and hasn’t been as good for about 3 seasons. Checked out a lot of his NFL trials too so can certainly comment... would you like me to scrap my vote?? Kinda goes against what you said about objectively voting because I’m actually trying to use form lines and ability, not just stats. If you rely on just stats then Hodges probably had a better record than Inglis. At FB though?

Different story... Holmes on the wing (diff story)

*somebody* should’ve had him at FB lol

Seriously it's a bit of fun no need to get narky..you can have your vote that's what it's all about no need to jump down people's throats cause the have a different view to yours..

Seriously...I don't really have to do this ..just thought it would be a bit of FUN during these troubled times...just enjoy it for what it is...

Mate you had Hayne down at 8th best fullback and 2/3rd of the comp ahead of him with players haven’t played the position this decade ! I know it’s all a bit of fun to everybody but it’s nice to do it properly and I honestly have no issue in re-doing the vote. He might drop to 0 though.

 

[Tigerboy]

I really thought SKD would be a sleeper. Clearly not ?

Sailor didn’t even play in that decade ?

Yeah I’m stumped how he OR Koroibete beats out players like Ferguson and Rapana... many distractions and time spent out of the game for both of them but at their peak not many better.

Valentine Holmes? Please. That needs recountin’

Just vote and stop whinging ?

Not wrong...Considering Val played over 100 games and as Geo pointed out the majority of that was on the wing...So if that’s the way people are voting, it doesn’t bode well for future voting on some of these player selections...

So wrong on this one, hun! ?

 

[Geo]

1 Val Holmes (not even a winger)

Ok this goes against my better judgement and will make it harder when I do the votes but this is surely a gee up...Holmes has played more games on the wing in his career than he has Fullback including Grand Finals and Origin..

He’s no winger in the comp today , I’m not trying to gee you up at all I really do not rate him.

Fox could probably move up to 6 - he’s lucky to get that high. Holmes left the game and hasn’t been as good for about 3 seasons. Checked out a lot of his NFL trials too so can certainly comment... would you like me to scrap my vote?? Kinda goes against what you said about objectively voting because I’m actually trying to use form lines and ability, not just stats. If you rely on just stats then Hodges probably had a better record than Inglis. At FB though?

Different story... Holmes on the wing (diff story)

*somebody* should’ve had him at FB lol

Seriously it's a bit of fun no need to get narky..you can have your vote that's what it's all about no need to jump down people's throats cause the have a different view to yours..

Seriously...I don't really have to do this ..just thought it would be a bit of FUN during these troubled times...just enjoy it for what it is...

Mate you had Hayne down at 8th best fullback and 2/3rd of the comp ahead of him with players haven’t played the position this decade ! I know it’s all a bit of fun to everybody but it’s nice to do it properly and I honestly have no issue in re-doing the vote. He might drop to 0 though.

I wasn't the only one with Hayne ..I'm just wondering why you singled me out..

 

[Chicken_Faced_Killa]

11 Lote Tuqiri
10 Josh Addo-Carr
9 Blake Ferguson
8 Valentine Holmes
7 Shaun Kenny-Dowell
6 Wendell Sailor
5 Jordan Rapana
4 Jason Nightingale
3 Nick Cotric
2 Akuila Uate
Sisa Waqa

 

[Tigerboy]

I really thought SKD would be a sleeper. Clearly not ?

Sailor didn’t even play in that decade ?

Yeah I’m stumped how he OR Koroibete beats out players like Ferguson and Rapana... many distractions and time spent out of the game for both of them but at their peak not many better.

Valentine Holmes? Please. That needs recountin’

Just vote and stop whinging ?

Not wrong...Considering Val played over 100 games and as Geo pointed out the majority of that was on the wing...So if that’s the way people are voting, it doesn’t bode well for future voting on some of these player selections...

He won with the Sharks …cheated. I’ll give him his due on career when/if he makes the international level again, and in his preferred position, seeing as that’s how I’ll be judging his natural ability (many others agree)

Otherwise Origin, he’s just another Gagai.

Just in case it was missed* he’s not a winger’s bootlace Lily but has great footwork, speed and an extremely decent origin record, 4 years ago. Since coming back how does he look?

That absolutely must be taken into account or for retired players, last appearances/best form.

Holmes, as Geo said, is a funny one because if you put him at FB gets even less votes. That is his self-proclaimed best position. I don’t know...

 

[Tigerboy]

1 Val Holmes (not even a winger)

Ok this goes against my better judgement and will make it harder when I do the votes but this is surely a gee up...Holmes has played more games on the wing in his career than he has Fullback including Grand Finals and Origin..

He’s no winger in the comp today , I’m not trying to gee you up at all I really do not rate him.

Fox could probably move up to 6 - he’s lucky to get that high. Holmes left the game and hasn’t been as good for about 3 seasons. Checked out a lot of his NFL trials too so can certainly comment... would you like me to scrap my vote?? Kinda goes against what you said about objectively voting because I’m actually trying to use form lines and ability, not just stats. If you rely on just stats then Hodges probably had a better record than Inglis. At FB though?

Different story... Holmes on the wing (diff story)

*somebody* should’ve had him at FB lol

Seriously it's a bit of fun no need to get narky..you can have your vote that's what it's all about no need to jump down people's throats cause the have a different view to yours..

Seriously...I don't really have to do this ..just thought it would be a bit of FUN during these troubled times...just enjoy it for what it is...

Mate you had Hayne down at 8th best fullback and 2/3rd of the comp ahead of him with players haven’t played the position this decade ! I know it’s all a bit of fun to everybody but it’s nice to do it properly and I honestly have no issue in re-doing the vote. He might drop to 0 though.

I wasn't the only one with Hayne ..I'm just wondering why you singled me out..

That’s true. It is your competition. You were also the first. Nothing personal at all ! Apologies

 

[Tigerlily]

I really thought SKD would be a sleeper. Clearly not ?

Sailor didn’t even play in that decade ?

Yeah I’m stumped how he OR Koroibete beats out players like Ferguson and Rapana... many distractions and time spent out of the game for both of them but at their peak not many better.

Valentine Holmes? Please. That needs recountin’

Just vote and stop whinging ?

Not wrong...Considering Val played over 100 games and as Geo pointed out the majority of that was on the wing...So if that’s the way people are voting, it doesn’t bode well for future voting on some of these player selections...

So wrong on this one, hun! ?

Oh! So going by your theory...Jack Wighton is only getting marked on the handful of games his played at 5/8 then...

 

[hobbo1]

@baconandeggs

 

[Geo]

1 Val Holmes (not even a winger)

Ok this goes against my better judgement and will make it harder when I do the votes but this is surely a gee up...Holmes has played more games on the wing in his career than he has Fullback including Grand Finals and Origin..

He’s no winger in the comp today , I’m not trying to gee you up at all I really do not rate him.

Fox could probably move up to 6 - he’s lucky to get that high. Holmes left the game and hasn’t been as good for about 3 seasons. Checked out a lot of his NFL trials too so can certainly comment... would you like me to scrap my vote?? Kinda goes against what you said about objectively voting because I’m actually trying to use form lines and ability, not just stats. If you rely on just stats then Hodges probably had a better record than Inglis. At FB though?

Different story... Holmes on the wing (diff story)

*somebody* should’ve had him at FB lol

Seriously it's a bit of fun no need to get narky..you can have your vote that's what it's all about no need to jump down people's throats cause the have a different view to yours..

Seriously...I don't really have to do this ..just thought it would be a bit of FUN during these troubled times...just enjoy it for what it is...

Mate you had Hayne down at 8th best fullback and 2/3rd of the comp ahead of him with players haven’t played the position this decade ! I know it’s all a bit of fun to everybody but it’s nice to do it properly and I honestly have no issue in re-doing the vote. He might drop to 0 though.

I wasn't the only one with Hayne ..I'm just wondering why you singled me out..

That’s true. It is your competition. You were also the first. Nothing personal at all ! Apologies

Thank you

See that's where your wrong it's not my competition ..It's Everyone who entered..I'm just facilitating it...

Just have your vote..discuss for sure if you wish but this is going to take a very long time if we debate every bloody pick

 

[hobbo1]

Leichhardt Lote for the win !