OFFICIAL Oliver Gildart

[cktiger]

I thought Hastings was pretty good. Very busy. Gildart not so good. He'll get absolutely monstered if he plays like that here.

Happy has turned into a Brooks fanboy lately.

 

[Moh]

Pommy backs (or any other backs doing well over) there do not excite me one bit.

The good Pommy finds are forwards.

 

[happy_tiger]

I thought Hastings was pretty good. Very busy. Gildart not so good. He'll get absolutely monstered if he plays like that here.

Happy has turned into a Brooks fanboy lately.

He has always been trying his ring out and I never questioned that .....

The performance has equalled the effort lately ...and he deserves all of our praise for the last 6 weeks ...if our pussy cat forward pack showed the same heart Brooks has shown ...we'd be in a hell of a better place

 

[weststigerman]

Someone watched them for 10 minutes and has written them off. Better go and tell Hartigan he's a fool.

 

[Deleted member 3518]

Pommy backs (or any other backs doing well over) there do not excite me one bit.

The good Pommy finds are forwards.

I think the issue is they have to be better than all the kids here when they come over . And most pom backs arnt , so they languish in reserve grade .
The forwards are usually tough bastards , so they offer a point of difference to the kids over here .

 

[GNR4LIFE]

hopefully Hastings can be used as a lock not a 6 or 7
Gildart is no world beater but probably better than what we have at present

I’m going to go out on a limb and say he isn’t better than anyone we have.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

hopefully Hastings can be used as a lock not a 6 or 7
Gildart is no world beater but probably better than what we have at present

I’m going to go out on a limb and say he isn’t better than anyone we have.

don't know if we have any internationals on out books in the backline at present

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Someone watched them for 10 minutes and has written them off. Better go and tell Hartigan he's a fool.

He’s signing ESL players, while the Dogs are signing JAC, Burton, Dufty and TPJ. Fool seems like an appropriate word.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Someone watched them for 10 minutes and has written them off. Better go and tell Hartigan he's a fool.

He’s signing ESL players, while the Dogs are signing JAC, Burton, Dufty and TPJ. Fool seems like an appropriate word.

Burton is a great get for the dogs, Burton and Brooks would have looked good for us oh well

 

[avocadoontoast]

Someone watched them for 10 minutes and has written them off. Better go and tell Hartigan he's a fool.

I watched the entire game. Unless he improves his defence and adds some bulk Gildart will get absolutely manhandled in the NRL. At this stage he is KOE Cup at best.

Hastings I thought was pretty good but the quality of the game was a loooooooong way off NRL.

 

[happy_tiger]

Someone watched them for 10 minutes and has written them off. Better go and tell Hartigan he's a fool.

He’s signing ESL players, while the Dogs are signing JAC, Burton, Dufty and TPJ. Fool seems like an appropriate word.

Burton is a great get for the dogs, Burton and Brooks would have looked good for us oh well

Maybe .....we need a good organizing half still .....lets Brooks concentrate on his running game 1st and foremost

 

[GNR4LIFE]

hopefully Hastings can be used as a lock not a 6 or 7
Gildart is no world beater but probably better than what we have at present

I’m going to go out on a limb and say he isn’t better than anyone we have.

don't know if we have any internationals on out books in the backline at present

We have 4

Noffa and BJ - Samoa
Doueihi - Lebanon
Maulmalo - NZ

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

hopefully Hastings can be used as a lock not a 6 or 7
Gildart is no world beater but probably better than what we have at present

I’m going to go out on a limb and say he isn’t better than anyone we have.

don't know if we have any internationals on out books in the backline at present

We have 4

Noffa and BJ - Samoa
Doueihi - Lebanon
Maulmalo - NZ

iSamoa and Lebanon please get serious tier 1 then
I will clarify
Tier one internationals
Maumalo ok give you that one NZ

 

[happy_tiger]

Someone watched them for 10 minutes and has written them off. Better go and tell Hartigan he's a fool.

Both were being lazy 10 minutes into a game and showing a complete lack of urgency or effort

Does that sound eerily familar ....???

Yeah EXACTLY what this club needs .....

Maybe the board and support staff want the club to get relocated to a warmer / better environment

 

[weststigerman]

Someone watched them for 10 minutes and has written them off. Better go and tell Hartigan he's a fool.

He’s signing ESL players, while the Dogs are signing JAC, Burton, Dufty and TPJ. Fool seems like an appropriate word.

And in 2017-18 we signed Reynolds, Packer, Matulino, and Mbye. How did that go?

Not sure why there is a love affair with the dogs in this forum, they have more room in their salary cap because they have a roster who has won 2 games all season.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Someone watched them for 10 minutes and has written them off. Better go and tell Hartigan he's a fool.

He’s signing ESL players, while the Dogs are signing JAC, Burton, Dufty and TPJ. Fool seems like an appropriate word.

Burton is a great get for the dogs, Burton and Brooks would have looked good for us oh well

Maybe .....we need a good organizing half still .....lets Brooks concentrate on his running game 1st and foremost

maybe we dont as some have said we have 4 internationals in out backline
in case anyone forgot ...

 

[avocadoontoast]

Someone watched them for 10 minutes and has written them off. Better go and tell Hartigan he's a fool.

He’s signing ESL players, while the Dogs are signing JAC, Burton, Dufty and TPJ. Fool seems like an appropriate word.

And in 2017-18 we signed Reynolds, Packer, Matulino, and Mbye. How did that go?

Not sure why there is a love affair with the dogs in this forum, they have more room in their salary cap because they have a roster who has won 2 games all season.

we're not exactly flying ourselves you know. we haven't beaten a full strength team all year.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Someone watched them for 10 minutes and has written them off. Better go and tell Hartigan he's a fool.

He’s signing ESL players, while the Dogs are signing JAC, Burton, Dufty and TPJ. Fool seems like an appropriate word.

And in 2017-18 we signed Reynolds, Packer, Matulino, and Mbye. How did that go?

Not sure why there is a love affair with the dogs in this forum, they have more room in their salary cap because they have a roster who has won 2 games all season.

So because we have a bad experience, we should never go for big names again? Bold strategy Cotten.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Someone watched them for 10 minutes and has written them off. Better go and tell Hartigan he's a fool.

He’s signing ESL players, while the Dogs are signing JAC, Burton, Dufty and TPJ. Fool seems like an appropriate word.

Burton is a great get for the dogs, Burton and Brooks would have looked good for us oh well

Maybe .....we need a good organizing half still .....lets Brooks concentrate on his running game 1st and foremost

maybe we dont as some have said we have 4 internationals in out backline
in case anyone forgot ...

Well, we do. Don’t ask questions if you don’t like the answers.

 

[happy_tiger]

Someone watched them for 10 minutes and has written them off. Better go and tell Hartigan he's a fool.

He’s signing ESL players, while the Dogs are signing JAC, Burton, Dufty and TPJ. Fool seems like an appropriate word.

And in 2017-18 we signed Reynolds, Packer, Matulino, and Mbye. How did that go?

Not sure why there is a love affair with the dogs in this forum, they have more room in their salary cap because they have a roster who has won 2 games all season.

So because we have a bad experience, we should never go for big names again? Bold strategy Cotten.

LOL at the Underdog reference .....maybe we need Lance Armstrong as our motivational speaker ......