On review

[Tiger_heart]

Was at least one of the Ellis trys a fair dinkum 4 pointer? Fancy being penalized for a push and shove, cheez :unamused:

 

[Tigerdave]

yes I think it was, we were dudded on a couple of decisions

 

[tiger_tigers]

rule number 1 … when you have the pill you dont throw a punch .. benji was in the wrong and it was a no try ....

 

[senexx]

Yes Ellis was dudded a try. Ellis crossed the line twice and was short once. The juggle of the ball of rooster to ellis and put down is a try.

 

[Tiger_heart]

rule number 1 … when you have the pill you dont throw a punch .. benji was in the wrong and it was a no try ....

And what impact did the "fight" have on the play??

 

[tiger_tigers]

it was a dumb play when in pocession

 

[Granto87]

Benjis goal kicking finaly cost us ouch

 

[senexx]

Fair point

 

[mike]

Was at least one of the Ellis trys a fair dinkum 4 pointer? Fancy being penalized for a push and shove, cheez :unamused:

Totally agree. If a try had not been scored there would have been no video ref involvement and it would have been play on.

 

[Marshall_magic]

it was a dumb play when in pocession

This. Stupid play from a senior player. absolutely no reason for it.

 

[tiger05]

rule number 1 … when you have the pill you dont throw a punch .. benji was in the wrong and it was a no try ....

Totally agree. Just don't do it - it is dumb.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

how dumb is it?