Opinions re: former WT players still in the NRL

[innsaneink]

Panthers seem appreciative of Spud Elfords efforts….

http://www.penrithpanthers.com.au/default.aspx?s=profile-player

 

[redemption]

Out of what demps listed, I'd only have Kapow or Bronson back, and even then I wouldn't shaft anyone to make room for either of them since we are bursting at the seams for quality second rowers.

I wouldn't have Prince back on principle.

I am with you re: Prince CB!!! 2006 will forever live in my memory!!!

Aside from the principle we agree upon - I also believe (having watched him try to play in a dinner suit in many games in 2010 + the All Stars game) that he no longer has the hunger to fully compete while he is busy getting houses built & looking after his whinging missus!!!!

He is forever dead to me!!!! And both Lui & Moltz have the potential to be better than he ever was!!!!

His flagrant disregard for the fans of this club by under performing in 2006 was disgraceful and i'll never forgive any player who shows no pride in our jersey or uses us as a transit club. I would have had more respect for him if he requested a release and sat the year out or played for another club.

Fitzy may have been maligned, but that guy bled for our colours and will always be personally held in higher esteem than that dog Prince, irrespective of what he did in 2005!

We're kindred spirits brother!!!

Boof kept trying - Princey just dropped his bundle!!!

As for Spud ink - the bloke gave up a lucrative two year deal at Souths to stay with us for one (for a relative pittance) in 2006 - and Princey let his own highly committed team-mate down!!! That is unforgiveable!!!!

And for Fitzy - great club man who gave his all in every position he played!! Loved seeing him score that final try versus the Raiders at Leichhardt in 2010 (that cemented the win - for those who still claim it didn't win it for us)!!

He deserved that great Leichhardt Oval roar to all but finish a quality career on a high note!!!

 

[batboy]

I am warmed to find that i am not the only one that thinks from the moment Prince lifteed the trophy in 2005…. He couldn't wait until 2007!! I thought I was alone....

 

[redemption]

I am warmed to find that i am not the only one that thinks from the moment Prince lifteed the trophy in 2005…. He couldn't wait until 2007!! I thought I was alone....

Not at all my man!!!

Still looking for those cards brother!

 

[derailed]

For me it's great to see Harrison doing well as I always thought he had great potential in the 2nd row which he has proven

Prince is a given but he was always going to leave and I don't blame him for that.

and I agree with a few on here that 'The Hammer' will have a big year this year and show some worth at the dogs

 

[Demps]

I was beginning to like you demps and agree with all but 2….

Issac De Gois should be the NSW hooker should Robbie be unavailable....9/10

Dene Halatau will be a boom for the Scumdogs this year.....get his Kiwi jersey back too 9.5/10

I might be the only one on this forum that thinks De Gois is useless, but a few people I've spoken to around the gym and so on (I'm from Newcastle) don't rate him either.

As I said, Dene was one of my favorite players but hasn't done anything impressive since departing.
Hopefully he gets some solid games this year.