Referee challenges

  • Thread starter Thread starter GoTiges62
  • Start date Start date
G

GoTiges62

Guest
Can I bowl this suggestion up and see if it can stir a debate;
I'd like to see a system similar to Test cricket and tennis where a team - via the captain - can challenge a referee's decision twice per half.
It would not include a video ref's decision as that is referred by the on field ref. the only problem could be the vid ref is often as blind as the two blokes on the paddock, but at least it would give a team an opportunity to have a bad decision adjudicated and the vid ref would/should at least look at the challenges with a critical eye.
Your thoughts?
 
If you can challenge and get one right, why not get all of them right?
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
 
It's set in stone in the future. One day. It's inevitable. Like I said- do you trust a ref- or do you trust technology. However the problem is that they still might get it wrong because a human makes the final decision. Can we really win? Depressing isn't it.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
 
I still preferred them looking at strips while teams were sorting themselves out before a scrum

How many of these decisions turn games on their heads ??

But then again thats me I want every call to be right everytime time no excuses
 
Back
Top