Tom Shines
Well-known member
Has Bateman been a dud here ?
"Salary Cap mess" Newcastle to pull out the big broom for a cleanout.
- Thread starter Tigerdazz2
- Start date
Has Bateman been a dud here ?
BAGNF05
Well-known member
Bateman 32 games in 1.5 seasons
Blore roughly the same in 4 seasons
Results much the same, effort goes to Bateman in a knockout.
Hope he has better luck with injuries going forward but he was a burden on our club.
Tom Shines
Well-known member
What about Douehi ? Is he a burden ?
A “dud” if you will?
Been injured … a lot… including with season ending injuries… twice wasnt it?
So using the same logic ..
Last edited:
innsaneink
Well-known member
Funny
Every time I watch melb I see him heavily involved
Don't know why people post things others can easily refute as it's on the public domain for all to see... Just to win an argument on the net.
It's just stupid
Tom Shines
Well-known member
It’s opinions at the end of the day … mostly harmless stuff … but as I say.. it’s pretty hard to argue in respect of the results on the field …that tells the story in black and white
Mighty_Tiger
Well-known member
It’s clear he doesn’t watch games.
Blore has been good & is improving.
Storm rate him highly.
As it stands Storm are infront on the 1yr player swap.
BAGNF05
Well-known member
Total dud.
And they were both signed coming off major injuries so the club can’t say they they were blindsided.
Tucker
Well-known member
Blore is doing well currently. That’s bad luck for us…
HOWEVER, he was next to useless when with us and the risk was that he’d continue to suck our cap whilst not delivering.
It wasn’t a diabolical decision at the time.
HOWEVER, he was next to useless when with us and the risk was that he’d continue to suck our cap whilst not delivering.
It wasn’t a diabolical decision at the time.
426Tlgerland
Well-known member
Blore for me was a loss that should not have happened , the kid stated on TV he wanted to stay , club did not make any effort to keep him so he moved on , Blore in our team right now and just the level he was at the last few months with us would be an absolute positive , bad call by the club , Stefs current contract another cock up by the club ,, that’s passed management , but now we see how good he new team are , so far I’m not overly impressed at this point , we need to see some serious action over next month or so , with
Stef if gone replaced with 2 solid props
1 x Solid hard running back rower
1 x Solid centre
this lot added to Luai and Turuva would see us improve but they can’t be left over players we need some experience and tuffness added to this team , we will on the likes of big Sam who is already well on his way , then his 2 brothers who are just starting to come into play , add Young Tallyn and more experience for Galvin , sky is the limit
And where are the 5 players u want coming from , Richo and benji both have stated that kids will be used , we have stuffed up are roster big time , we should have kept,
Big joe
Blore
And signed Nathan brown , Curran , amone, with more grunt , maybe stepho and Galvin would not want out .
With moving papa and Bateman going we would nearly have paid for them 5 ,
More alluding to we cut our losses with a bloke who was already going to Melbourne
AmericanHistoryX
Well-known member
Baddabing Baddaboom. Learning the art of football from a real good coach.
BAGNF05
Well-known member
it’s true Shawn Blore watched more of our games than I did when he was here.
jirskyr
Well-known member
I believe the word everyone wants to find is "basketcase".
Knights cannot manage their salary cap. Parramatta reported today half their players have options in their favour, which means the club cannot move them on (e.g. Whatza Matterson).
Basketcases, all.
You know what, also whilst on topic, Jarrad Wallace is being released by Dolphins, with immediate effect and prior to end of contract, to Catalans Dragons. What a basketcase they are. Or is it only when Tigers do it?
Knights cannot manage their salary cap. Parramatta reported today half their players have options in their favour, which means the club cannot move them on (e.g. Whatza Matterson).
Basketcases, all.
You know what, also whilst on topic, Jarrad Wallace is being released by Dolphins, with immediate effect and prior to end of contract, to Catalans Dragons. What a basketcase they are. Or is it only when Tigers do it?
AmericanHistoryX
Well-known member
What are their finals records?
