Sean Meany no longer with the club?

[southerntiger]

Well for one I'd rather of kept Reddy over Moltzen

Really? Both are mediocre but at least Moltzen has the potential to be a better player long term. Although he certainly hasnt lived up to his potential.

I couldnt have stood another year of Reddy making shocking decisions in defence ala John Carlaw, John Morris.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_

Reddy has a pulse, therefore a heart. I would take a player that gives it his all even though it is proven to be barely enough, than a player that that has had the opportunities yet has no idea how capable he really is. Moltzen has been plagued by injury, an excuse, but also a detracting factor. Tin has coasted, Reddy is a goer.

Moltzen improved last year prior to the injury. He isnt anywhere near as bad as some suggest and clearly has a greater potential upside than Reddy.

I really didnt rate Reddy so my comments arent necessarily an endorsement of Tim.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_

 

[underdog]

The trouble with Moltzen is all his great try saving tackles in defense were all made prior to 2010.

I can't think of a single moment from 2011 onwards where Moltzen made a try saver.

I can immediately think of a couple before that - one being at the end of Bonstonkers Video of Moltzen - where he made a brilliant Lion Hearted tackle on Minichello when he was odds on to scores a try.

Since then he's been a shadow - whether it been injury, or coasting along behind Benji Marshall - who knows.

 

[1_4_chicken_chips]

Meany was never a first grader IMO ,and reddy wow it's a young big and fast players game these days , reddy ticks none of the boxes

 

[jirskyr]

Am I correct that Meaney never recorded a win in any of his FG games at the Tigers? I recall it being something like 0/6.

 

[underdog]

10 games for us in FG - 4 wins.

http://stats.rleague.com/rl/scorers/players/S/Sean_Meaney.html

 

[mtd]

Again, another one no one cares about…
From our 2013 "Leadership Group"

No longer has a contract....
What's he up to now?

Playing anywhere?

playing in italy of all places

 

[Masterton]

Am I correct that Meaney never recorded a win in any of his FG games at the Tigers? I recall it being something like 0/6.

Two games for two wins last year. Not bad considering how shithouse we were.