Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[hugh1954]

If we can get Klemmer to bring leadership and steel to our pack and Leinu with his steel and impact, we are going to improve next year. Also our backs including Brooks will have more time and space to operate.

God help us if Brooks has more time and space to stuff things up as he usually does over the years. How many years have we told Brooks to run and he goes missing, like him as a good clubman and yes his defense has improved over the years BUT its time to move him on if its a sound decision in our favour

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

Saw that written here somewhere - Don't know that Sheens said it publicly...
I'd be keeping Musgrove over Tuki.
Having watched him a bit in Reserves, I don't see anything much in him...
To the point he's well behind Dias and Aitasi.

Tuki wouldn't have been near firsts at any other club...
Musgrove would've (And has) And will....
I can't say that for Tuki unfortunately...

Perhaps you're right it could have been the pom who said it.

 

[Glenji95]

Blore
Brooks
Doueihi
Fainu
Gildart
Hastings
Kepaoa
Koroisau
Laurie
Maumalo
Musgrove
Naden
Ngataikaura (Rua)
Nofoaluma
Ofahenague
Papali’i
Peachy
Pole
Reily
Seyfarth
Simpkin
Simpkins
To’a
Tumeth
Tupou
Twal
Utoikamanu

That’s 27. Matamua and Saukuru are on development next year more will be added eventually but we currently have 3 spots left.

 

[loklok]

I think even Keith Barnes told him to sign with Superleague. Balmain were going to offer him 50k or something, SL offered him $1m over three years. Can’t blame him for taking the offer. As I recall when he told the Balmain management what the offer was they said he should accept it.

Edit: Turns out it was John Chalk who told him to take the $uper League money. Our offer may have been as low as $40k for one season.

Does anyone remember Conlon kicking for the sideline on penalties

 

[Halbrowne61]

Did Mattel ever make a Ross Conlon doll?
View attachment 2788

Does anyone remember Conlon kicking for the sideline on penalties

Yes I do. That originated from Jack Gibson via Mick Cronin at Parra. I also remember Rooster FB Alan McKeon doing it a few times.
I guess you’d call it a fad that would be howled down today.

 

[jrtiger]

We can easily accommodate Klemmer and Leniu, be it cap or spots available. It's not like our forwards are worth keeping happy. We have forwards who can do a job and that is it. Musgrove, Seyfarth, Simpkins, goodbye. Our depth is hopeless. A backrower is needed urgently too.

I would only be content with one of Nofoaluma or Maumalo. Need difference in our backline, some speed on the other wing wouldn't hurt. Doueihi is not a centre.

agree wholeheartedly on the one of Nofoaluma and Maumalo take. was very hopeful Nofo would stay at Melbourne permanently but doesn't seem as if they want him. regardless I'd be shopping him around.

Scolari and Hill should be made priority #1 as far as wingers go. providing they rip in over preseason I'd be giving them both Top 30 contracts and having them on the wings in place of Nofo and Maumalo by 2024. throw Tupou and Feledy in the centres and that's a very good backline.

 

[Halbrowne61]

Yes I do. That originated from Jack Gibson via Mick Cronin at Parra. I also remember Rooster FB Alan McKeon doing it a few times.
I guess you’d call it a fad that would be howled down today.

Of course we are talking place kicking for touch.

 

[loklok]

Yes I do. That originated from Jack Gibson via Mick Cronin at Parra. I also remember Rooster FB Alan McKeon doing it a few times.
I guess you’d call it a fad that would be howled down today.

Yep .would it still be allowed in today's game .they can kick it a long way of the tees these days ?

 

[Halbrowne61]

Yep .would it still be allowed in today's game .they can kick it a long way of the tees these days ?

Maybe it would insure that Brooks kicked it out.
He fluffed a few this year and didn’t find touch.

 

[loklok]

Maybe it would insure that Brooks kicked it out.
He fluffed a few this year and didn’t find touch.

🤣🤣🤣🤣

 

[tiger_one]

Yes I do. That originated from Jack Gibson via Mick Cronin at Parra. I also remember Rooster FB Alan McKeon doing it a few times.
I guess you’d call it a fad that would be howled down today.

But just the breather the forwards would love.

 

[king_sirro]

God help us if Brooks has more time and space to stuff things up as he usually does over the years. How many years have we told Brooks to run and he goes missing, like him as a good clubman and yes his defense has improved over the years BUT its time to move him on if its a sound decision in our favour

Have you seen any half "run" behind a weak pack? It's like running into a brick wall.

 

[Halbrowne61]

But just the breather the forwards would love.

Gibson once said that was one of the major reasons they did it, especially if they got a penalty whilst under pressure. Gave everyone a chance to clear their head, plus it tended to gain more ground.

 

[Yossarian]

Does anyone remember Conlon kicking for the sideline on penalties

Yep.

 

[Stevec]

What's going on with Tommy Talau he plays center for us in 2021. He was sort of ok but he does his ACL and spends entire 2022 rehabbing and now I see he's not even signed for next year ? What's the story ?

 

[BAGNF05]

I’m still holding a candle for Nado.

In my experience, unless a side has some get go up the middle, the backline will struggle to get into its groove.

You can win games with lighter forwards, but they have to make up for it by being courageous and busier than their opponents as a start.

I’m still desperate for a ball playing forward. Everytime we take the ball up we need options and I’m tired of seeing wingers die with the ball relieving pressure. Just sitting ducks usually when I think we could make more of it.

We’ve been too predictable. There were some spurts during Noddys formative games, some closer matches, but our bark was worse than our bite.

I definitely agree it’s hard to judge our backs when our forwards are so far off the pace. Makes the re-signings of Naden and To’a seem strange.

 

[Scorpion]

How do you know we have 28 spots filled for next year .Where can u see it the west's website shows 30 odd including those that have left

According to the NRL website WT have 27 contracted. Media has reported they have offered Talau and Brown contracts.

 

[Halbrowne61]

Yes I do. That originated from Jack Gibson via Mick Cronin at Parra. I also remember Rooster FB Alan McKeon doing it a few times.
I guess you’d call it a fad that would be howled down today.

Actually just did some checking and Roosters introduced it( under Jack Gibson) back in 1967 when he took over the 66 team that never won a game. Alan McKeon was the fb in that team.
He then reintroduced it to Parra when he went there in early 80s.And Cronin was the kicker for Parra.
Guess the old memory was a bit out of alignment but I like to get my facts straight.

 

[Red88_Tiger]

Look at Klemmer's stats. He's absolutely still an elite prop and a capable pack leader. He generates second phase play and consistently gets over the advtanage line - a lot of this talk about his play being limited is wrong. He may not be the most damaging runner, but I'll take a guy who puts up a quality 150m+ and 25+ tackles a week no worries.

Also tackles with his shoulders

 

[batboy]

Have you seen any half "run" behind a weak pack? It's like running into a brick wall.

They'd probably missed the grand final...
Moses has a rep pack and didn't do much in that game.