Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

tigertragic said:
Watching a super league replay (catalans v st Helen’s) a commentator talked about the tigers clean out
Bateman - but not interested in coming home currently
Naden - some interest by clubs
Sullivan - would come at 180,000 pound (say 360,000-400,000), not sure if that takes into consideration of any tigers top up- but some interest by clubs
Click to expand...
We wouldn’t be topping up any player going to the UK.
 
The Chad said:
When you're 3/4 line reads:
Staines
Naden
Olam
Alaimalo


I know I'd feel much better with:

Cotric
Simonssen
Olam
Turuva


And I don't think it would be impossible to put together either..
Click to expand...
Simonsson is a beast winger but Naden out performs him at centre. That's not to say Naden is good, just that Simonsson should never ever be near a centre slot.

Edit: This should be our 3/4 line next season. It also gives a Makasini or a Large a chance to start in 26. Either as a straight swap in for Olam, or if Staines is still struggling in 25 they can get a start on his wing.

2. Simonsson
3. Olam
4. Turuva
5. Staines
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 851
Ecto-1 said:
Reedy just mentioned on MMM that Simpkin will be announced to leave within a week or 2.
Click to expand...
He’s a tough little bugger and I think he will play more NRL somewhere, but he doesn’t have much creativity, no explosive speed off the mark and not much of a kicking game.
So all in all he’ll be better off elsewhere and we need a different type of skill set to what he offers.
 
FrodoTBaggin said:
Simonsson is a beast winger but Naden out performs him at centre. That's not to say Naden is good, just that Simonsson should never ever be near a centre slot.

Edit: This should be our 3/4 line next season. It also gives a Makasini or a Large a chance to start in 26. Either as a straight swap in for Olam, or if Staines is still struggling in 25 they can get a start on his wing.

2. Simonsson
3. Olam
4. Turuva
5. Staines
Click to expand...

I'm interested to see what Lobb does next week. Sounds like Benji will play him and in reality the opportunity is there for him to take. Wasn't it reported he was in the top 3 fittest in the club with Galvin and Bula? So with his size there is no reason at all he can't work his butt off and run for 150-200 metres every game. If he can do that, he just needs to make his tackles and finish well when the opportunity comes. People say he is slow but he is actually fast. His unusual crouching running style for a tall man with long strides makes him look slower the he is. He may surprise a few. I hope so because a winger his size is very valuable. He is as good as Lomax under the high ball.
 
king_sirro said:
I'm interested to see what Lobb does next week. Sounds like Benji will play him and in reality the opportunity is there for him to take. Wasn't it reported he was in the top 3 fittest in the club with Galvin and Bula? So with his size there is no reason at all he can't work his butt off and run for 150-200 metres every game. If he can do that, he just needs to make his tackles and finish well when the opportunity comes. People say he is slow but he is actually fast. His unusual crouching running style for a tall man with long strides makes him look slower the he is. He may surprise a few. I hope so because a winger his size is very valuable. He is as good as Lomax under the high ball.
Click to expand...
You're right, Lobb is another to compete for that right wing spot with Staines. Hopefully we can get the best out of one of them.
 
Kelce68 said:
Watching Lobb this year in Cup, he's very, very average.

As in, we'll below Staines' and Alaimalo's current form average.
Click to expand...

I'm sceptical when looking into our outside backs form in Cup this year, the side is terrible. Out of curiosity what is he doing that's average? I've seen a few games and while he isn't standing out, I haven't seen anything that makes me right him off as potential NRL player.

He has the physical attributes, it really is just a matter of how much of a go he wants to have if Benji names him next week.
 
weststigers said:
What do we see in Cotric?...he's kak

Big Sivo seems to be injury free again. I'd prefer him simply for yardage and finishing. Just for 2 years.
Click to expand...
He’s terrible for yardage. And yes he’s a good finisher when he’s within 10 metre of the line. How often do we put our wingers in that position though.
 
ATown said:
He’s terrible for yardage. And yes he’s a good finisher when he’s within 10 metre of the line. How often do we put our wingers in that position though.
Click to expand...
We have good stats for tackled inside other teams 20. Just can't get over the line.

Hey I dunno...but Cotric is kaksville 🚮
 
king_sirro said:
I'm sceptical when looking into our outside backs form in Cup this year, the side is terrible. Out of curiosity what is he doing that's average? I've seen a few games and while he isn't standing out, I haven't seen anything that makes me right him off as potential NRL player.

He has the physical attributes, it really is just a matter of how much of a go he wants to have if Benji names him next week.
Click to expand...
He's very slow on the turn for starters. Weak(ish) into contact. Haven't seen any evidence of finishing ability being anything special. Isn't especially strong, evasive or a natural tackle-breaker from what I've seen.

That being said, he's safe(ish), understands wing positioning to an adequate level, has an OK straight line top speed, can leap and can goalkick.

I'd say at best, he's a sideways move from Solomon and Charlie and at worst, he's a less impactful version of Corey Oats (albeit a bit quicker).
 
Kelce68 said:
He's very slow on the turn for starters. Weak(ish) into contact. Haven't seen any evidence of finishing ability being anything special. Isn't especially strong, evasive or a natural tackle-breaker from what I've seen.

That being said, he's safe(ish), understands wing positioning to an adequate level, has an OK straight line top speed, can leap and can goalkick.

I'd say at best, he's a sideways move from Solomon and Charlie and at worst, he's a less impactful version of Corey Oats (albeit a bit quicker).
Click to expand...

Perfect player analysis
 
We need a big powerful winger to bring the ball back it’s our biggest deficiency in the 2025 squad. Turuva will help with footwork but Bula relies on footwork and hitting gaps the next hit up has to be a beast. Most clubs have 3-4 outside back runs out of trouble we struggle to make any metres.
 
Kelce68 said:
He's very slow on the turn for starters. Weak(ish) into contact. Haven't seen any evidence of finishing ability being anything special. Isn't especially strong, evasive or a natural tackle-breaker from what I've seen.

That being said, he's safe(ish), understands wing positioning to an adequate level, has an OK straight line top speed, can leap and can goalkick.

I'd say at best, he's a sideways move from Solomon and Charlie and at worst, he's a less impactful version of Corey Oats (albeit a bit quicker).
Click to expand...

Yeh the one thing I'm concerned about is his contact. Something about the way he looks on impact seems a tad softish. That's why I said it comes down to how much of a go he has. Its up to him really. His tackle busting will increase if he increases his aggression. His carries late in the game last week were strong, so I know he has it in him.

I'm not worried about being slow to turn. All wingers his size are, it's part of the trade off of having a big body.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 848 (members: 5, guests: 843)
Back
Top