Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Go_You_Good_Things]

Yes, we should improve. Better roster, a combinations forming, etc.
And it's likely we do improve.
But isn't that what we say every single January ?
Oh, and yes I know that this time feels different. It does every year.
In the end, I'm sure that all of us that suffer following this club of ours hope that we improve. But let's be realistic . . . the list of failure excuses is long and varied, and has been that way long before something that happened 3 months ago.
All that being said, this year does feel different.

 

[batboy]

We are dust and s
As long as you're Shaw and sure and Shaw

Ha ha ha 🤣 hilarious

Shore

 

[balmain boy]

Cant catch a high ball,so fullback out of the question.
Poor defender,so 9 wont work
Hes either a half or five eight,but the inn is very full
Hes best to move on and restart elsewhere

Actual front on he's a very good defender. Very strong and aggressive for his size. Being caught out of position out wide and arm grabbing is his issue. In the middle his defence will look better.

He's a 14. That's it. Could play in the backs of there's a mid game injury otherwise his future is at hooker

 

[balmain boy]

Would not surprise if Tino Tavana becomes the NSW Cup fullback this season. He's more advanced in experience & development than Attard and the closest thing as a like-for-like to Bula the club has. I maintain high hopes for this kid!

I think Tavana replaces Laulilii or Thompson on a wing.

Doesn't have the explosive pace or ball playing for fullback. He's great in the air, a lesser man's Coates. Put him on the wing and tell Madden to kick to him.

 

[upthetigers]

Yes, we should improve. Better roster, a combinations forming, etc.
And it's likely we do improve.
But isn't that what we say every single January ?
Oh, and yes I know that this time feels different. It does every year.
In the end, I'm sure that all of us that suffer following this club of ours hope that we improve. But let's be realistic . . . the list of failure excuses is long and varied, and has been that way long before something that happened 3 months ago.
All that being said, this year does feel different.

This year does feel different. We're a young team and there is a higher ceiling for growth.

 

[Odessa]

This year does feel different. We're a young team and there is a higher ceiling for growth.

Such a big upside to this team I think that what Richo meant by most of the squad locked up


Most will becoming into there best years

 

[king_sirro]

Thanks. I don't mean it to be negative and as I concluded I'm not saying we won't improve. Just not yet convinced.

I dont think we will truly improve until we play a consistent style. The ab lib style of attack won't get us anywhere.

 

[clontarfkid]

Actual front on he's a very good defender. Very strong and aggressive for his size. Being caught out of position out wide and arm grabbing is his issue. In the middle his defence will look better.

He's a 14. That's it. Could play in the backs of there's a mid game injury otherwise his future is at hooker

Weve got a bunch of 14s already..we need genuine 1st graders

 

[Tiger Stripes]

Cant catch a high ball,so fullback out of the question.
Poor defender,so 9 wont work
Hes either a half or five eight,but the inn is very full
Hes best to move on and restart elsewhere

He's signed here for 2026 only.
Without a stellar year he should be downgraded to cup level and start again OR try elsewhere.
Not personal, just want what's best for WT. He has been given plenty of opportunities.
Can't persevere forever, there are others out there vying to play NRL.

 

[Demps]

Forum fav Soni Luke has joined NQ cowboys

 

[Modman]

Tell us what you really think ?
Not too many 19 year olds play NRL, I wouldn’t be writing him off just yet.

I think hes a victim of coaching staff throwing him in to early. Id be suprised that there would be many very good first grade players playing NRL at his age. Problem is once you play them early they start making a fuss abt going back to lower grades to get experience. Idk Bloody kids of today. lol

 

[GNR4LIFE]

As much as I hate Parra, how is the NRL threatening to step in and allow the Storm to get their way? God I hate PVL.

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

As much as I hate Parra, how is the NRL threatening to step in and allow the Storm to get their way? God I hate PVL.

Parra shouldn’t have let him go.
They agreed to Lomax leaving which people forget.

They also have instigated players breaking contracts at other clubs.

Hope he joins the Storm and scores the match winner.

 

[wstigers11]

How Parra fans carried on when they thought they were getting Galvin, karma

 

[user118245]

How Parra fans carried on when they thought they were getting Galvin, karma

Yeh we got burnt from it but as much as I hate parra I wouldn’t want it to happen to others, would much rather them just fix the system

 

[wstigers11]

Yeh we got burnt from it but as much as I hate parra I wouldn’t want it to happen to others, would much rather them just fix the system

Does set an ugly precedent if the NRL comes to save a guy who’s ditched 2 contracts in 2 years

 

[gallagher]

As much as I hate Parra, how is the NRL threatening to step in and allow the Storm to get their way? God I hate PVL.

Absolutely. Especially after he said anyone negotiating with r360 would be banned.

 

[batboy]

Does set an ugly precedent if the NRL comes to save a guy who’s ditched 2 contracts in 2 years

Yeah, He's that guy...

But he's also the Guy that signed 'long term' to play Fullback for a certain coach, Then his club sacked the coach - He never played Fullback, Then they got another Coach who plays him on the Wing, where (Rightly or Wrongly) he's said he doesn't want to play...

So then he's coaxed to Parra on the promise of playing his preferred position of Centre,
And before he gets there - They've speared the Coach he came to play for and the Captain he wanted
to Play with
- And Again, he doesn't get to play his preferred position.

I get that he plays well on the Wing, and he should do what's best for the team
- But it is his life / career.
If he doesn't want to play there, He does have a choice.

Understanding it could be seen as somewhat different,
But how many of us are forced to do a job everyday that we didn't apply to do,
And have no interest in doing?

It sucks (For Parra) But they've had this coming for some time.

 

[Tiger_Yoshi]

Soni Luke was available this whole time and he just signed with the Cowboys

I guess they’re okay with Hope off the bench

Let's hope you are right

 

[Tiger_Yoshi]

Absolutely. Especially after he said anyone negotiating with r360 would be banned.

Worse than Albo backflip