Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Vicious said:
No Sione should not be used on an edge at all, he is only a middle forward and a good solid, improving middle forward.
If we re-sign Sukkar, he and Ethan Roberts will be a year older and wiser and much more ready to step up to the plate when required.
Ideally recruiting someone who has a lot more speed and athleticism as an option would be great, but at age 32 I cannot see Jack Gosiewski being that person.
Click to expand...

How many times did Sione play on the edge this year ? Must have been double figures

If a younger athletic guy ( with some NRL experience ) wants to sign up to be our edge 4 on $200k a year than great … I won’t be holding my breath though ..
 
Last edited:
Seems like players we get attached to are going to be the cheap ones , club says it got $$$ to spend but I don’t think it’s big dollars , Frizell ! Mann , Jack G / broncos , O’Sullivan , Brailey , not big coin , Alverillo probably the only one who is on $ 500 + these others above would be 250/300 , O’Sullivan may want a bit more , feels like we got $ 250 to spend per head , that’s not much that’s reserve grade value. So 2027 suffers again if injury strikes
 
426Tlgerland said:
Seems like players we get attached to are going to be the cheap ones , club says it got $$$ to spend but I don’t think it’s big dollars , Frizell ! Mann , Jack G / broncos , O’Sullivan , Brailey , not big coin , Alverillo probably the only one who is on $ 500 + these others above would be 250/300 , O’Sullivan may want a bit more , feels like we got $ 250 to spend per head , that’s not much that’s reserve grade value. So 2027 suffers again if injury strikes
Click to expand...

Gotta be a bit realistic … we assume money is tight next year and they got a few gaps to fill ,..
 
Cultured_Bogan said:
From NRL.com

Adam Doueihi: 200 tackles, 23 missed - 89.7% tackle efficiency (14 games, 14.3 tackles PG)
Jock Madden: 295 tackles, 44 missed - 85.1% tackle efficiency (15 games, 19.7 tackles PG)
Jarome Luai: 320 tackles, 61 missed - 81% tackle efficiency (20 games, 16 tackles PG)

It would appear Jock takes on 4-5 extra tackles a game than his halves partner.
Click to expand...
That's about what I expected. So many people on here bag Maddens defence. Or are they just sheep following a previous comment. His defence stacks up with our 2026 heros IMO.
A lot more tackles than Doueihi but less efficient because Doueihi's arm grabs or him not really in a position to make a tackle are not recorded.
Luai tops the missed tackles, which usually lead to tries.
Thanks, CB for clarifying in my mind what I had suspected.
Maddens defence is not as bad as a lot on here would have you believe.
Same with those saying he doesn't have a long kicking game. He did a very long kick in the Panthers game, so it does exist. But are usually strategically shorter. But we rarely contest these because of our slow backline [head and legs].
A very good backup, just a bit slower than ideal. But costing us SFA.
 
Tom Shines said:
Firstly …it’s the mole , so I’m not going to believe it just yet ,,,

But we don’t know the value of the contract - so how can we judge it? If it’s like 200k I don’t see the issue - we need experienced depth as proven this year

How many games do you expect him to play ? Might only be 4 or 5 off the bench if they get a good run with injuries …

You know what else is no good ? When injuries bite, having to rely on inexperienced 20 year olds that the opposition targets and costs us the game when they leak 3 tries .
Click to expand...
And what makes you think this 32yr old reserve grader, journey man will plug that gap?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 5,777 (members: 30, guests: 5,747)
Back
Top